It is fairly well established that therapeutic work with adoptive families is complex, intense, and, at times, downright gruelling. This kind of therapy traverses themes of identity, be-longing, abuse, and recovery. As clinicians in this field, we are often working with children who are ambivalent at best about their status as an adopted child, as well as parents who are at the end of the road with their capacity and willingness to provide care to their adopted children. The impact on us as individual therapists can also be intense. It is, therefore, immensely helpful that the Adoption Support Fund was set up to help families affected by adoption.
Indeed, the work often leads us to needing to think on our feet, and dealing with far more external influences – social workers, teachers, reviewing officers – than we may do in, say, private practice. This means that we may need to think about the legal/political/organisational and ethical predicaments far more than with other kinds of work. And this is rightly so – these families deserve support that is of high quality, consistent, and meaningful, and as therapists, we should remember the importance of meaningful, multi-agency working where appropriate. Reading any serious case review into a child death can immediately remind us of the importance of this.
However, the work can also be incredibly rewarding. Equipped with skills around the established evidence base around what works, and a real willingness to be determined, creative, and forthright even in difficult circumstances, we are, I believe, well able to effect last-ing change with families. It was a welcome relief to many when, in 2015, the Government recognised the struggles, and brought in the Adoption Support Fund. But what is this, and how is the fund accessed?
What it is…
The Adoption Support Fund was implemented on the 1st May, 2015. The fund was created to support adoptive families who were struggling with the care of their children, who often struggled with complex trauma and attachment difficulties. The fund’s implementation followed much work on behalf of those affected by adoption (in particular, Adoption UK), who, quite rightly, felt that more was required to support the permanent placements for these children.
The help itself could be anything to support the family, and could follow an assessment of need by a local authority, although this was not inevitable. There is an individual fund for each child, currently £2,500 for assessment in any financial year, and £5,000 for therapeutic input. There is an expectation that support is provided by Adoption Support Agencies who are OFSTED registered, although this is not consistently applied throughout the country.
Support can be provided up until the age of 21, (or 25 with an Statement of Educational Needs or Education, Health & Care Plan) who have been adopted from Local Authority care in England or adopted from Wales, Scotland or Northern Ireland but who are living in England and for whom the English Local Authority bears the statutory responsibility to assess. Since 1st April 2016, the fund is now also available to inter-country adopters and Special Guardians who care for children who were previously looked after.
So, whilst this is a welcome source of support, it is not without its pitfalls.
Some of the problems in the Adoption Support Fund…
The fund only supports a very small selection of therapies (roughly 25), and they have to be therapies that are not provided by a local authority. To put this in to context, there are over a thousand different therapeutic modalities across the UK. By having such a small, focused group of therapies, they limit accessibility and choice for families. They also limit clinician choice. A clinician may, for example, have trained in many more than just the funded modalities, but could well find themselves with a very limited selection of therapeutic approaches that they are legitimately permitted to use. They may also think that an alternative, unfunded approach could be helpful. Can we then use this approach, despite it being unfunded, legitimately? I would say possibly, depending on the context.
Curiously, if, say, ‘Psychotherapy’ is the funded therapy, does this allow free reign for a psychotherapist to provide multiple approaches, but, say, also limits them if it is a psycho-therapist that is providing, for example, DDP. I’m not convinced the DfE fully thought this through. This issue is also linked to questions around how do we know, as clinicians, when we are ‘cleanly’ using specific approaches? This is especially important as many of the funded therapies use identical techniques but in other names from the more established therapeutic approaches.
Case Study of someone supported by the Adoption Support Fund
Julie was a teacher who had trained in Non-violent resistance, and had been working with a family for six months, using most of the available techniques she had learnt from her NVR training. The violence from the 17 year old daughter, Jasmine, to her mother, Matilda, was increasing. Julie was beginning to feel hopeless about effecting change within the family. She was also trained in Dyadic Developmental Process, and thought there could be elements of this approach that could be helpful. However, the local authority were very clear that she was commissioned to only provide NVR. Julie, not in supervision either, began to feel lost.
There is also the notion of what constitutes a therapist in the first instance. It seems that, essentially, anyone can call them self a therapist, and this isn’t a title protected in law. Obviously, most local authorities will ensure people are vetted and screened, and DBS checks should be the norm. However, some of the training for many of the funded therapies can be completed in a matter of days. How can someone who then calls them self a therapist, without any personal therapy or supervision involved in their training, be permitted to practice with such a vulnerable and challenging client group? It is clear that more robust consultation between the Government and a wider cohort of practitioners would have helped with this. Maybe even better, would have been the professional standards’ associations to lead the consultation in the first instance.
If the notion of relationship is the primary factor which enhances therapeutic growth (and it appears to be ), can we definitively say that a therapist can fully achieve this through such a limited training opportunity as above? I would argue that using practitioners with very limited training, without their own personal therapy and supervision, actually places families in vulnerable situations, with people who may be unable to cope or adequately even understand the complex and challenging material they may be faced with. They could easily be sucked in to quite toxic and pervasive patterns of manipulation, control, and splitting.
This may well also lead to unnecessary changes of clinician, thus repeating historical patterns of attachment and disruption to children and their families. Now, such practitioners may be well intentioned and committed, and there is no critique of them as individuals, but this kind of work needs much more from us as professionals in my opinion.
There is also the issue of evidence. Quite soon after the fund was established, the Government realised that there was little in the way of empirical evidence to support many of the chosen therapeutic approaches. This led to them publishing a retrospective review of the evidence base for all of the named therapies. Very few of the named therapies had a substantial evidence base to support their efficacy. One therapy in particular (which shall remain nameless) has even been accused of creating a woozle – i.e. overstating its claims of effectiveness, and repeating them until they become ‘evidence’. I understand practitioners may have different views, and there are political undertones to the report in terms of which evidence it was including, but the issue is that the research and questioning of the evidence came after the fund was implemented, and focused again on individual therapies rather than the professions.
Interestingly, despite Psychotherapy as a profession having a high quality evidence based developed over 50 years, they appear not to have processed this sufficiently, and don’t mention Counselling at all. Whilst individual practitioners were involved in the DfE consultation, each firing off their own agendas, it doesn’t appear that the primary regulatory and professional standards’ bodies, were. This is lamentable.
Another major concern is that the ASF is encouraging a continued focus on schoolism. Schoolism is essentially when we get married to our model or modality. We tend to dis-count other approaches because they are different and we may not understand them fully. This has happened in respect of the therapy mentioned above, where people now ‘love’ the therapy so much, they discount the rather worrying conclusions that contradict any notion of effectiveness. Clarkson defined schoolism in psychotherapy as, “…the result of passionately held convictions of being right that fly in the face of the facts.” Indeed, we are clan creatures by nature, and have a general tendency to be part of specifically-focused groups or organisations. This can be helpful in terms of individual learning, but can lead to conflict between groups.
This is also an issue within this field as there is an element of pyramid selling to practitioners, as the organisations supporting most of the specific mod-els increasingly demand very specific supervision (usually provided by themselves for very high fees coincidentally), and additional subscription fees and expectations for those choosing to use these approaches. This is opposed to supporting a pluralistic approach to therapeutic help, whereby qualified practitioners can decide which tool or approach they use themselves.
My final gripe, is that the focus on individual therapies (i.e. DDP, Theraplay) as opposed to types of clinician, i.e. a counsellor, a psychotherapist, or a psychologist, undermines our professional autonomy and expertise. My position is that a state registered psychotherapist or counsellor is best placed to choose whatever type of therapeutic approach is going to be beneficial to a family, than a narrow, prescriptive selection by someone who has a minimal if non-existent experience or training in any of the therapeutic modalities. Therapist choice appears, in this instance, to have been overtaken somewhat, and this is, in my view, is unacceptable.
1. It Takes a Village to Raise a Child, Pennington (2012)
2. https://www.nspcc.org.uk/preventing-abuse/child-protection-system/england/serious-case-reviews/
3. i.e. DDP, Theraplay, NVR
4. Front Psychol. 2011; 2: 270. Published online 2011 Oct 18.
Therapeutic Alliance and Outcome of Psychotherapy: Historical Excursus, Measurements, and Prospects for Research. Rita B. Ardito and Daniela Rabellino
5. DfE (2015)
6. Mercer, 2015: Revisiting an Article About Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy: The Life Cycle of a Woozle
7. Harold, G. T., Hampden-Thompson, G. (2015-16). An evaluation of the AdOpt parenting pro-gramme. National Implementation Service (NIS) and Department for Education (DfE)
8. On Psychotherapy 2: Including the 7-Level Model: Clarkson on Psychotherapy v. 2 Paperback – 15 Dec 2001, Petruska Clarkson
Andrew
orange-anteater-584180.hostingersite.com/