I want to write a bit today about the role of specificity in psychotherapy. For many of the traditional psychotherapies, the idea of specificity, or direction, can seem to be somewhat problematic. This is because many of them are considered to be non-directive, and this is taken seriously by practitioners. Non-directive means that the clients remain the focus of all the interventions (which is obviously important), and their needs remain paramount.
However, some people take the idea of non-directive approaches to a fault. I have taught on programmes where even the idea of asking a direct question can be seen as ‘bad’. This can leave clients feeling a bit weirded out by the therapists’ endless paraphrasing. Thus, I want to talk about how specificity as a theme can be included within the therapeutic encounter helpfully. Regardless of your modality.
Clients reactions to non-directive approaches
This, overall, is really important. Therapists were talking about the issue of non-directive approaches even in the 50s. It was an important concept as it moved away somewhat from the notion of therapeutic expertise and reliance on the professional, usually a man. However, it became polarised, and therapists then seemed to either be directive or non-directive. There was no inbetween.
I maintain that it is important that the clients recognise their own voice and their own role in the healing journey. I have no issue in some elements of non-directive work. However, what happens is that some clients can feel totally lost in the vastness of choice and accountability presented to them in pure non-directive therapy. This can lead them feeling unsupported and not held by the therapeutic alliance. Thus, it seems that there is a time and a place for non-directive work.
The role of professionalism and evidence
There is also the issue that society expects a professional to be able to offer answers to clients, and when we just put all questions back to clients, this perpetuates the idea that we don’t actually know the answer. In order to improve professional accountability, is there not a role for professionals offering opinions and facts to support client growth?
There is some evidence that shows that other techniques, such as Behaviour Rehearsal, can be twice as effective as non-directive therapy. If we know this, then shouldn’t there be a moral incentive to use that material within our work?
Practitioners’ Anxiety
Having trained practitioners to use non-directive therapy over some years, it is also clear to me that many practitioners feel over-whelmed themselves by just paraphrasing. They see the client concern about everything they say being paraphrased in front of them, and are impacted by this. This can give trainees negative reinforcement about what they are doing, which is unhelpful. We don’t want to have nervous trainees, who aren’t confident about what they are doing.
In contrast, using paraphrasing is easy to pick up as a technique and evidence competence in, so the discussion is nuanced.
Similarly, we don’t want practitioners who just lecture clients endlessly. When we hear chalk and talk for long periods of time, we lose focus, concentration, and the interventions becomes even less effective. Thus, this suggests that there is a need to intervene therapeutically with care, attunement to our clients’ needs (who will need different things at different times), and respect to the inherent power imbalances, being as creative as we can be, safely and respectfully.
Client feedback on the need for specificity
It is important for everyone that they have a sense about how they are experienced. This is a vital component of the primary, reconstructed attachment relationship. We want to know how therapists feel about us, and when we don’t get feedback, we just fill in the blanks. In particular, clients often report issues such as not knowing what’s happening, not knowing if they’re making any progress. Is it ethical to encourage clients to think about us, and work through their projections about us? Whilst there is some use for this, does this not also sidestep the reasons which brought our clients to therapy?
As a result of this kind of dilemma between the therapeutic principles of practice, and the actual needs of our clients, I think it’s helpful and important to think about the idea of specificity in the work. I think this is also a really important point in current times, as money is tight. We are in a cost of living crisis, and for those of us who rely on private clients for most of our work, it’s important that they are getting value for money within the therapeutic intervention. Endless, non-directive, or narcissistic work is not okay.
What is specificity in therapy?
I understand the idea of specificity to be very clear about a number of factors for the client. Firstly, there is the idea of what therapy does. Therapy will not heal people as we imagine them to be healed. Managing expectations is absolutely vital to effective and professional psychotherapy. Clients deserve to know what we are doing and why. And we should know the answer.
Managing expectations in helping them realise that, whilst we work with the idea of characterological transformation, this may not be as transformative as they imagine. Plus, there is a need to negotiate and make sure our clients are clear and understand this point.
Specificity through contracting
Specificity is also about soft contracting at the beginning of every session. What this means is that we sit with our clients at the beginning of the session and once we’ve had some time to connect to attune to each other, it’s time to then think about what the clients focus will be on that session. For clients who have experienced complex developmental trauma this is also really important because what happens to the client is that they can feel chaotic in life. Which they can be very difficult to focus on very clear outcomes and objectives for the therapeutic encounter.
By encouraging the client to contract, and asking the question specifically, this helps move out of that potential impasse. I also know that this might not be right for everyone, but I do feel that if you want to get value for money, that you need to know what you want to work on in the therapy. And even if that is not figural at the beginning of the therapy, this is the responsibility of the therapist to help clients become more clear about what the focus of the work could be.
Specificity through goals and reflection
It’s so important that clients leave sessions knowing what they’ve worked on. Also, knowing what they are going to look at over the coming days and weeks. This is because change takes time (I have written about ideas on change here), and , and also what new insights and awareness they have gained from the session. This builds a pace and a process of growth within the work that fits with their needs.
Specificity over time
There is also a need to manage specificity in some ways. Specificity does not have to look like a robotic, manualised therapeutic intervention. Specificity is actually more containing. However, the role of specificity changes throughout the therapeutic intervention. At the very beginning, clients may well need more of the specificity rather than less, however, over time, especially years, the client will begin to assimilate the need to focus and think about what they want to work on, this means that they will be able to do this effectively themselves and will require less prompting from the therapist.
And this is the gift of therapy really, and probably where Rogers was in thinking about non-directive therapy. For Rogers did ask questions, he was directive at times, albeit with a care and a respect for the client not seen in other therapies of the time. Obviously, we always have a choice if we will just sit back and let clients project into the void, but in my experience this often leads to distress and shame for the client, which is unhelpful.
Final thoughts
Without clear goals we can feel stuck. For our neurological change mechanisms to be activated, we have to let go of the current associations, and see really clearly ourselves in our transformed state. The increases the possibility of change. Non-directive work can lead to clients feelings stuck.
Whilst change might seem challenging to some, we are in the process of change. Clients come to us to have their distress alleviated, and to make sense of tricky circumstances. Their reactions are often normal responses to abnormal situations. Keeping them stuck isn’t appropriate, as is forcing a pace of change that leaves them wiped out. We need, clearly, some balance, and specificity can be the way of achieving this.
Warmly,
Dr. Andrew x