Book Review – Dangerous Lunatics (Brett Kahr)
This article will be a book review of Brett Kahr’s Dangerous Lunatics: Trauma, Criminality and Forensic Psychotherapy. If you are interested in everything lunacy, and forensic mental health, then this book might be for you. I was pleased to be able to read one of his offerings given previous connections, although was a bit hesitant given the triggering words ‘lunatic’ and ‘dangerous’. Whilst this isn’t a book on spirituality, the connection between mental health and spirituality has always been prevalent.
The Content
The book aims to explore an understanding of why humans commit horrific acts of violence such as murder or paedophilia. In doing so, Brett deftly and competently sifts through a wide range of material. He effortlessly shifts from contemporary studies, to ancient material such as that from Seneca. This is truly a thorough exploration of the idea of dangerous lunacy. I was pleased to complete this book review.
The Writing
Although Brett clearly knows his material well, and is a professor in his own right, the writing is accessible, clear, and somehow he avoids the pitfalls of academese. However, some of the terminology is outdated and would benefit from further updating.
The book was a fairly quick read for myself, but an interesting one. I greatly valued the opportunity to revisit Freud’s role in the humanisation of mental illness within the industry. I hadn’t been so aware of Freud’s role in this, so was pleased to have this insight.
If I am honest, I also enjoyed Brett’s exploration of blue-sky thinking, and his thoughts on the future of mental health treatment. Again, backing up his opinions with solid evidence, he points out the need for ongoing development within the field. And that people continue to be understood in the context of their crimes.
The Cover
The cover has an intriguing picture of a skull with a knife resting on it. This is sure to trigger images of murder and everything scandalous. I think the cover was a clever choice, clearly associating the content with the cover. The cover is also clear and uncluttered with words. Overall, it is clean, tidy, and relevant.
The back is a little less helpful. There are a couple of reviews, and seems full of words. I wonder if they just stuck the words they would have put on the front on the back? I do like the fact that the cover is folded, meaning you can use it as a bookmark.
Book Quality
The book is published by Confer Books, and is a manageable 208 pages in total, with 48 of those being references. The paper is fairly rough, meaning that you can get a grip, and you wouldn’t be endlessly licking your fingers in order to turn the page.
More generally
I like how psychoanalysts such as Brett are actively considering the need for humanity in treating offenders. I do believe, on one hand, that all offenders deserve respect, care, and integrity when being treated by services. However, the line between offending and mental health is an unusual one, as many people who offend and have mental health issues are also dangerous. If someone is acting out violently or sexually, regardless of how compassionate your treatment is, there still needs to be clear and unequivocal boundaries in order to protect the public. Will the need for humane treatment compromise safety?
I don’t imagine so, and it’s reasonable to believe that services ‘get this’. However, the assessment of offenders is still fairly untested, and people are still released who then offend. We need to focus on this issue at the same time.
Conclusion
Overall, I like Kahr’s style, tone, and content. If you are interested in the field and would like a basic primer, then this is the one for you. I will definitely use some of his thinking within my own work. Kahr’s resources will help you identify further reading. I guess I am also left with questions around if psychoanalysis is psychotherapy – the two are used interchangeably, but is this accurate? Whilst many psychoanalysts call themselves psychotherapists, no psychotherapist will call themselves an analyst, unless they have had the training. So it’s a curious dilemma for myself – maybe I should take this up with Kahr the next time I meet him!
I would have liked more reference to spirituality, but this wasn’t the purpose of the book. I can live with that!
Hope you’re all ready for spring…
Andrew