The Restless Mind
Blog

Time to stop using Trauma?

12 Aug 2022·7 min read

Good morning. The U.K. is threatened with warm weather over the next three days, so naturally we have had a hosepipe ban and drought warnings. I’ve no idea where the past two weeks of rain went, but I feel traumatised by how all the water disappeared. And that’s the problem, we are all using the word, trauma, far too frequently. No longer does trauma refer to war-like symptoms, either physical and/or emotional. Now trauma seems to encompass anything and everything slightly tricky. In this article, I therefore ask if it is time to stop using trauma as a diagnostic term.

Trauma in psychological literature

Over the past ten years the word ‘trauma’ has seemingly invaded most of the psychological literature and beyond. There was an obvious move away from terms used in social care research – which uses the terms ‘abuse and neglect’ – to use this more psychological term. It all seemed quite trendy and clever at the time, and now we’re all using it.

In the past, trauma was used to refer to war-like symptoms. You were traumatised if you had been in a war. In fact, most of what we know about trauma derives from research in that field. And trauma sustained in the field i.e. shell shock, is completely different to that experienced in the home in childhood. There may well be similar impacts on the brain, but there are also vital differences. One isn’t more important than the other, just different.

Thus, the impact of childhood abuse, the impact of violent attacks, the impact of being dumped, are just not the same. The impact on individuals is also very different. If you were to be assaulted at work, the impact on you will be different to me. When we use trauma to refer to all these and many other situations in life, we lose specificity. What are we actually talking about? And in using a catch all term lacking meaning and clarity, we do an injustice to those very unique experiences

Defining childhood abuse and the nature of uniqueness

The nature of childhood abuse is that it involves an adult, usually a caregiver, causing harm to a child, whether that be emotional, physical, sexual, or neglect. The adult either knows they are doing harm, or lacks awareness about the impact of what they are doing on others. Indeed, denial is a force that holds many of us to ransom. The definition and clarity around this is enshrined within law, in particular section 47 of the Children Act (1989) and (2004). Saying someone is traumatised does not do justice to the range of ways in which that child’s life has been impacted.

Whilst the experiences are inevitably traumatic at some level, the manner in which we are impacted is uniquely variable. The way my brother and I were impacted by the same childhood experiences are very different. Whereas I had a propensity to internalise the hurt, I also used that energy as determination to survive and achieve. And I’m still impacted by it in some ways. My brother became so lost in the confusing and harmful conduct, that he found himself in dark, isolating places, and ultimately ended his own life.

We cannot measure or quantify human experiences through questionnaires

My point here, is that the word trauma was introduced in the well-intentioned belief that we can reliably measure and quantify human experience, preferably in a questionnaire. Whilst questionnaires do measure something at that moment in time, I have no doubt that the questionnaire does not measure what scientists would have us believe. I know those people who are invested in the myth of measurement may disagree. This article isn’t going to critique the use of questionnaires (find one here), but I do maintain my point.

My major issue though is that when we use questionnaires, we inhibit an opportunity to fully inhabit and know our client’s experiences. And that experience may change from day to day, moment to moment. The way I spoke of my mother yesterday in therapy, may well be different forevermore. It certainly changed from the beginning to the end of therapy. Our interpersonal and intrapersonal experience of abuse and neglect also varies over time.

Questionnaires also make massive presumptions about historical experiences. They score you higher for having had certain experiences such as, for example, being ran over by a car. However, the way my cousin was runover in 1978 and when he was again runover in 1979 (yes, he didn’t seem to learn), was entirely different. Different abuses are scaled differently. But again, what may have been traumatic for one person, may not have been traumatic for another, and for different lengths of time. I would have been deeply upset if I had been assaulted and for a long time, but my brother would have shrugged it off.

Trauma in therapy

In therapy, not only do we now talk about trauma freely, we have also changed the way in which we talk about those experiences. Historically we ALWAYS wanted to know what happened to a client. Now we are told that this can also be traumatising. Whilst this idea is compelling and seems trendy also, I remain convinced that it can be immensely cathartic to verbalise what happened. Having your story witnessed and validated is incredibly healing. What isn’t cathartic, is making someone talk about something they do not want to talk about. So the issue isn’t, for me, whether or not we talk about the abuse, it’s how and when.

Unfortunately, this is where traditional psychotherapies come again into conflict with the newer, Government funded approaches. What works is time. Sitting with a skilled psychotherapist (with a traditional four year clinical training) over years rather than months, taking time to develop a deep, nourishing alliance, allows the abuse to heal gradually and sensitively. No block of 12 sessions could ever accomplish this, obviously.

Problems in the field

I recently attended a psychotherapy conference (indeed, was even a member) where lots of non-psychotherapists were lecturing other non-psychotherapists about psychotherapy. I sat in dismay and disbelief as they pretended to know the nuances and challenges within the profession. They also stated that psychotherapists were not best placed to research their own profession. This was incredibly insulting to the profession. I know some highly skilled researchers and academics who are also practitioners. This is akin to a nurse researching occupational therapy, and then lecturing those therapists on how to do their job. Whilst the nurse may have conducted some high quality research, they would always lack the knowledge and experience to fully appreciate the nuanced elements of the job. With this in mind, I feel it is imperative that psychotherapists begin to research and talk about their profession more robustly than ever before.

Also, when you have so many people talking about the same concept, in so many different ways, the seriousness of the term is reduced. When I’m talking about trauma, I am using my own frame of reference, including what I have learnt and studied. I think trauma is at the extreme end of human experience; it has to be for it to be trauma. When my colleagues talks about trauma, their vision is also coloured by their own experiences and learning. If the way we talk about trauma is so varied, lacking in a meaningful consensus, should we therefore be using it?

Diversity issues

And what about diversity? The use of trauma, and most importantly, the approach to ‘treating’ it, is influenced by the white, middle class population who set out the norms for researching and exploring this phenomenon. Also, much of the recent research predominantly uses a majority of white, middle class, female participants. Can we reliably extrapolate from that population to the rest of us? I’d say there are pitfalls.

Final Words

I know there are people who are resting their whole career on the idea of trauma. They talk volubly and sensibly (in some ways) about what they believe trauma to be. They are influential, convincing, and they are often defensive. However, there is more to life than trauma, and one person’s trauma is another person’s growth. Psychotherapy needs to begin to separate out the nuanced process of traumatic hurt, and more importantly, begin to test more effectively its approach to healing.

Dr. Andrew x

Receive new essays

New pieces arrive infrequently and without filler. No newsletters about newsletters. Just writing, when there is something worth saying.