The Restless Mind
Blog

The End of Findhorn (or beginning?)

18 Aug 2022·11 min read

Before I answer the question if the pandemic is triggering the end of Findhorn (or beginning), I want to take you back thousands of years. In Neolithic times, the Isle of Orkney was a vibrant home to our ancestors. People lived there, thrived there, and also practiced forms of spirituality. And then, fairly suddenly, they disappeared. The disappearance may have taken place over a few years rather than hours, but the people left. We don’t know why or how, only that it happened. And the landscape changed again – the homes were buried, and a few remnants of what went before remained.

I share this because there are concerns that the spiritual Findhorn community, once a thriving, vibrant home to hundreds, is also on the same trajectory. The community has been ravaged by the pandemic, as our ancestors may have been. An absence of visitors, and a community slashed by 75%, has clearly rocked Findhorn to the core. This is without previous controversies. Also, without the original driving force of Eileen and Peter Caddy, I wonder if the pandemic left Findhorn awash in a turbulent world? In this article I explore some of these ideas.

Disclaimer

Before I go in to this article I have to say that I do not live at Findhorn Foundation (F.F.).  I have not been part of any conversation about the direction and/or future of F.F.  However, I have stayed there a number of times, and am good friends with many members of the extended community.  I am also probably the most drawn towards this spiritual community than any of the other spiritual communities in the world. 

What is clear for me is that I am invested in the community’s future as a venture that aligns itself most closely with my own beliefs. I personally want Findhorn and its current ethos to continue to grow. So whilst that does not qualify me to put my ‘fourpennorth’ in, it’s never stopped me before. 

I think I provide the disclaimer as I know what I am going to talk about could be unintentionally controversial for some. There is no rescue in this, but I do want to offer Findhorn the same qualities that the community have offered me. Even though this is an article written with clarity and care, there is a range of Findhorn lost souls around the world, who have been particularly critical of the community. I know how much Findhorn means to the world, and this article is not seeking to contribute to the difficulties, but to support growth and recovery.

What is Findhorn?

Briefly, F.F. is a large, international, intentional community of people.  Their practice of spirituality, connection with others, and leading a life attuned to nature is what brings them together. As well as lots of other things. The internet will inevitably provide you with further evidence of the F.F. ethos, philosophy, and movement. My purpose isn’t so much exploring the foundation – although possibly should in the future – but to simply consider the impact of the pandemic on organisations such as F.F.

However, I would outline that the foundation supports people around the world to practice spiritually, and to essentially live the best life they can.  Many people are devoted to the organisation, and people will travel to F.F. despite much labour and challenge in getting there. Then we had a pandemic.

The arrival of the pandemic

So, in short, F.F. suffered immensely during the pandemic.  Prior to the pandemic, there was a thriving international community, and there was around 120 paid staff in the foundation, covering a range of roles.  The community’s primary income comes from workshops and events, and these were immediately stopped with the lockdown.  This meant that there were no wages for those employed by the foundation. Once the pandemic hit, the foundation’s income was reduced by 85% immediately. 

In wider terms, this meant that the organisation needed to think about how they would survive. This isn’t a dramatic use of the word, but a clear indication of the need to work out a way of moving forwards.  What was clear was that, even with the temporary furlough support, they could not fund everyone’s wages indefinitely. In fact, desperate situations called for desperate remedies. This was vital given the prognosis for a protracted period of pandemic.  

Findhorn’s redundancies

The organisation realised that people needed to be made redundant.  This resulted in nearly 3/4 of the workforce being let go, albeit reluctantly.  People who had worked at the foundation for 30 years no longer had a job.  Also, this meant that they had nowhere to live, given that may of them lived in the foundation.  The Cluny Hill centre was particularly hard hit, with the population being reduced from nearly 40 to 4.  

To be clear, the redundancies were not made in haste, but made carefully and with dialogue. Everyone were said to have been consulted, and the community realised the changes that needed to be made.  It is obvious that the organisation truly tried to follow the principles and ethos of the community. Someone in the centre put it to me like this, not only was the decision-making excruciating, they realised that they could only keep those who were directly needed, i.e. maintenance staff, and gardeners etc.  This meant that the ‘talent’, much of the workshop presenters etc, had to be let go.  The reverberations from this are still felt.

The pandemic and worse!

The impact was as hard as you imagine it could be.  It was made worse by one man, Joseph Clark, taking matters in to his own hands.  As the community centre manager, facing redundancy and loss of his accommodation, he decided to set fire to the community centre and another building.  I have no recordings or comment from him directly.

This fire destroyed the buildings, and could have been much, much worse.  The fire was found by a cleaner at 2 a.m.  The day after, Clark handed himself in to Police.  Although remanded for some time, he received 300 hours unpaid work as a penalty.  The community lost £400,000 worth of building.  

I struggled to imagine how the community could recover at all from the pandemic, let alone by the advent of a fire.  Whilst the story on site is one of respectful consultation and dialogue, clearly the commitment to the foundation wasn’t shared by everyone. Clark clearly felt rage about being his redundancy, and acted from that place, clearly intending to hurt the community as much as he was hurting.  It feels almost like a ‘if I can’t have it, then no-one  else can’.   

Wider reverberations

In undertaking such a problematic process, this will also inevitably have impacted the community more widely. The trust in what was home would have been shattered. The confidence in the people supposed to be looking after them would also be diminished. And it must have been traumatic to have even survived the ‘cut’ and see so many people disappear. This was amidst the personal loss of loved ones due to covid.

And these are human beings, with real and messy relationships. People would need to say goodbye to neighbours, friends, and lovers, in a way that they may not have chosen to do so. I am sure that, even within spiritual communities, where we are programmed to ‘be kind’, and ‘loving’, that the hurt and dismay lurks around within our psyches. And spirituality is a process that can lead us to denial of our more human parts. In particular, that we disown and split off from our shadow side, favouring only positive emotions and processes. This leaves the darker side lurking inside, bubbling away, never fully resolved.

Further observations

Those are the basic facts as far as I can establish.  A couple of observations come to mind. Firstly, the story of cooperation and realisation doesn’t seem to have been as widespread as current members would suggest.  In fact, some people were clearly enraged by the changes, probably also afraid.  Is this unusual for a group of people, especially the middle class intelligentsia? Absolutely not.

In addition, there doesn’t seem to have been a consistent shared commitment to the redundancies, and some were obviously left upset. Was Clarke’s response a psychological reflection of the collective rather than the individual? I don’t want to imagine for one second others would have wanted to destroy part of the organisation, but I don’t believe he would be the only one carrying difficult feelings towards the organisation. Reading more widely online, this certainly seems to be the case.

That a utopian community has detractors is not unusual. Most utopian communities around the world have them. And most communities struggle at various times (take Biosphere 2 for instance), at best. Some fail dramatically (see Upton Sinclair). What is unusual about Findhorn is that it has survived so long under such challenges. This perhaps speaks to the very special nature of Findhorn.

Analysis

I think it’s important to ask what Clark’s actions were about?  Was the communication across the community not as comprehensive as we would imagine it would be? Is being ‘loving’ not sufficient for complex human relationships? I imagine that there may never have been sufficient levels of communication for what needed to happen. If something doesn’t fit for you, no amount of clarity or care will be enough. You can tell me that I am going to lose my livelihood and home, and even if done nicely, there will be no consolation for me.

Ultimately, I am informed that the community went out of their way to support this transition, offering financial support also where possible. However, finance doesn’t ameliorate hurt, or perhaps only temporarily.

Other options?

I wonder if the community could have fared better with a greater openness to working online?  This could have potentially retained a better connection with the global community, and could have brought an income in. Was the ambivalence about working online a reflection of the organisation’s values, an ageing community, and a distrust of technology? 

They were also slow to come out of lockdown.  This isn’t unusual in itself. I was resistant to coming out of lockdown. I think it was because we all were traumatised collectively by what happened. But even this week, workshop participants are asked to take covid tests.  Nowhere else in the country requires this as far as I can tell. Most of us are working face to face, with no restrictions, no mandatory testing, and without complaint. Was this a reflection of the inward looking nature of an intentional community?

Further concerns

I also worry about how they will recover. If their workforce is so depleted, and there is a breaking away from some members due to the process of redundancy, how will it rebuild? Does Findhorn want to bring back those people who are gone, and is this within their plan? More importantly, as the community endeavours to fight a way forward, I wonder how they will rebuild people’s trust again? Will love in action be sufficient?

My overall concern is that the community was born and grown under the leadership and drive of three very special people, the Caddys, and Dorothy Maclean. And whilst numerous people have come and gone since, the community is still all about what the pioneers offered. They remain, despite having passed, hugely influential, and are spoken about today as much as they have always been spoken about. But is this enough to get the community through the pandemic recovery? I hope so.

Next Steps

I feel fear about the future here. I am sat in the empty living room of a large community space at Findhorn, and feel the loneliness. Quiet allows our projections to grow not diminish. There is activity though, lots of meetings, lots of trainings, and certainly an intention to move forwards. I don’t know if it will be too little too late, but I do hope and pray that the leadership – who clearly love and respect the community – will move with the times. There is always a desperate remedy to a desperate situation.

So let’s all remain optimistic. Findhorn is, for many of us, a sanctuary we revisit when finances allow. It is a beautiful, spiritually energetic space, where many of us have lived and thrived before. Most of us with spiritual lives owe Findhorn our support in these difficult times. The problems referred to above are not unusual for any group of people.

What I feel Findhorn needs is the following:

  1. The leadership need to lead. Being overly permissive leaves humans lacking direction. There is nothing wrong with a loving boundary, and humans are, like it or not, hierarchical creatures. More bureaucracy leads to stagnation, not growth, and often reflects leadership anxiety. We all need to believe that Findhorn’s future is bright.
  2. Embrace technology. Offering more online resources and workshops means that Findhorn can remain connected with the world. It also means that income can be maintained, and so will support the growth and maintenance of the community.
  3. Develop what it does. Offering processes that are 30 years old will not meet the needs of new participants. Change it up, develop initiative and creativity, and embrace change. I’m sure it will need to given what has happened. We also need to remain connected with the question of how we can truly encourage Generation Z in.
  4. Find new personalities, especially those with large online presences, and thus widen the offerings.
  5. Encourage diversity. Appealing solely to only a few demographics will not sustain any organisation in to the future. Does Findhorn appeal to all?
  6. Be courageous and optimistic. We can do this.

Much love,

Dr. Andrew x 

Receive new essays

New pieces arrive infrequently and without filler. No newsletters about newsletters. Just writing, when there is something worth saying.