I’m in the midst of learning ‘Clair de Lune’ at the moment, and I’ve already gone past the ‘I love this music’ part. I don’t know about you, but when we learn complex, classical pieces, they are often more a feat of stamina than anything else. Is that the same for you? My teacher also loves a metronome still, and this piece in particular is a challenge for its use of complex rhythms and key changes. I’m almost there though! So as I think of great music, I also regularly ask myself, what are the key features of great songs?
Today I wanted to ask, ‘What are the key features of great songs’. I think that, if you want to write great songs, you need to know what the components of those songs are. Whilst this article won’t be an automatic ticket to a number one hit single, it could at least develop what we do as songwriters, which isn’t a bad thing. And we will be talking about general components with specific references.
Way forwards
In order to make at least a bit of sense, I’ve numbered the features, and will provide examples throughout. I did a lot of research for this article, and I do think there are some really helpful suggestions from what I found. The key is that the features I include are related to memorability and appeal – why people remember them, and what it is about the song that is appealing. Let me know also what you think.
Catchy Melodies
The key feature of a great song is a catchy melody, believe it or not. A great song usually has a memorable and catchy melody that sticks in the listener’s mind. This is often the hook that draws people in and keeps them coming back.
If you think about the songs you find memorable, there will be a melody that hooks you in. My favourite music at the moment is ‘River Flows in You‘, and one phrase is repeated throughout. The piece is in A major, the chord progression is FDAE, and the repetition keeps us soothed and contained within the variations. But other singing songs such as I Will Always Love You, keep us hooked in with the repetition of the title of the song.
Strong Lyrics
Lyrics that resonate with listeners, whether through their emotional depth, storytelling, or relatability, are a hallmark of great songs. They can evoke feelings, tell a story, or convey a message that connects with the audience. If I’m honest, I listen less to lyrics now than I used to. It is the melody that hooks me in. But I do like good lyrics. It’s important to me to write lyrics as well as I can, which is why there is always a great story to each of my songs, such as Emerald Isle.
Dolly Parton, again, is an astounding lyricist. We all remember intimately the stories of Jolene, the Smoky Mountains, and her Coat of Many Colours. Her lyrics draw you in to her memories and lived experiences in Tennessee. Cohen also writes great lyrics. I think in particular of Hallelujah, and his interweaving of the bible with contemporary life.
Emotional Impact
Great songs often evoke strong emotions in listeners, whether it’s joy, sadness, nostalgia, or any other feeling. The ability to evoke emotions and create a connection with the audience is crucial. This also makes sense – we all have songs that we associated with different feelings. I have songs I listen to when sad (Edwina Hayes, always haha), songs I go to when excited (The Black Keys), and also songs when I’m feeling inspired. I don’t always go to vocals, and can just as likely go to classical or Gaelic, but music is always connected with feeling.
I’m sure you also have playlists you associate with different thoughts and feelings.
Dynamic Structure
A well-crafted song typically has a dynamic structure that keeps the listener engaged from beginning to end. This may include changes in tempo, intensity, or instrumentation to create contrast and maintain interest. I learnt lots from this. My early songs were just straight in to the verse and then the chorus. Actually, if we take time to step back from the song, and think about the emotional journey from the moment we pick up the instruments, we will go a long way.
So for me, this point is more about performance and structuring a song to be heard. I think Jeff Buckley got this perfectly right in Hallelujah. His performance just captivates us from the very start, and drags us wailing and wrung out to the very end. A master of emotion if ever there was one. Whilst I’m no Taylor Swift fan, I understand she works hard on a particular style of dynamic structure to retain interest in her audience.
Memorable Hooks
Catchy hooks or choruses that are instantly recognisable and easy to sing along to are a key feature of many great songs. These hooks often serve as the focal point of the song and leave a lasting impression on the listener. I think the British are particularly vulnerable to a memorable hook lol. I remember growing up (perhaps the 70s/80s), and the kinds of songs that became staples were things like ‘Grandma‘ and ‘Ah Shaddupayaface‘ by Joe Dolce. Obviously, we were also hooked in by Power Ballads in the 80s, but we love a good hook.
And ultimately, songs are meant to be sung. If the song is so over-thought out and complicated, how can we be expected to even want to learn it? Popular music is popular because of its accessibility. Our songs should draw people in, not exclude them.
Strong Instrumentation and Production
The instrumentation and production of a song play a significant role in its impact. Great songs often feature skilled musicianship, innovative production techniques, and high-quality sound engineering that enhance the overall listening experience. This is possibly the most important part of singing for me. I have always traditionally got caught up in the cadence and the lyrics, forgetting that a song is just meant to be sung. And the instrumentation is a vital component.
Don’t get me wrong, I think that the likes of ‘Carnivorine‘ get the instrumentation right for the song, but it is always a growing edge for me. I will return again to Buckley. His live performance in Frankfurt in 1995 was absolutely stupendous. The emotional nuances, the variety of his tone of voice, the music, all contributed to a profound musical experience. I’m not sure how they possibly learnt the pieces collectively, but it was a sheer feat of inspiration and determination.
Authenticity
Authenticity is important in music, and great songs often feel genuine and sincere. Whether it’s the raw emotion in the vocals or the sincerity of the lyrics, authenticity can help a song resonate with listeners on a deeper level. My audiences tell me that my music is definitely ‘me’ ( I hope in a good way), but there are multifarious performers out there who bring this element out. I get switched off by performers who can barely be bothered to be there. I want to get to know them a bit through their music, don’t you?
And it is through memorable performances that we ‘meet’ performers. A great song is often enhanced by a memorable performance from the artist or band. Whether it’s a powerful vocal delivery, impressive instrumental solos, or captivating stage presence, a memorable performance can elevate a song to new heights. I think Tracy Chapman is amazing in this respect, as is Tina Turner, Whitney, Mariah, and so many others.
Finally – Timelessness
Truly great songs have a timeless quality that allows them to resonate with listeners across generations. They don’t feel tied to a specific era or trend but instead have a universal appeal that transcends time. This is often, but not inevitably, about the song’s cultural impact. Some great songs go beyond mere popularity and have a significant cultural impact, influencing other artists, shaping musical trends, or becoming anthems for social movements. These songs often leave a lasting legacy that extends far beyond their initial release.
Let’s think about the likes of those songs that get remixed or covered. The most covered song in music history is often considered to be ‘Yesterday’ by The Beatles. Written by Paul McCartney and released in 1965 on the album ‘Help!’, ‘Yesterday’ has been covered by hundreds, if not thousands, of artists in various languages and musical styles since its release. It’s been estimated that there are over 2,200 recorded versions of the song, making it one of the most enduring and widely interpreted compositions of all time.
For me, this song’s popularity is about its simple yet poignant melody and universal themes of love and loss which have contributed to its enduring popularity and widespread appeal among musicians and listeners alike. And as performers, I think we all have those songs which resonate more with our listeners. I’d suggest you unpick those songs for yourself, and try to understand what it is that make them successful, or more ‘listenable’.
Final thoughts
I hope that there are some helpful snippets here for you. I think ultimately, we should enjoy the process of songwriting rather than getting caught up in writing ‘great songs’. If our primary concern is greatness, I think you’re more likely to encounter ‘block’ than success. The great thing about human songwriting is that we are human. And in fact, the songs that will be more successful are probably the ones that you think less about.
So get out there, and let people hear your music. Building an audience happens mostly in the pubs and clubs, not Facebook. Audience’s want to see music performed, and then listen in their front rooms. not the other way around.
Much love
Andrew x