I am asking you today, “Are you open to challenge in therapy?” This is for a very good reason. Many therapeutic approaches simply offer a ‘safe space’, where someone can be ‘heard’, and where they can talk about whatever comes up for them. And to be honest, many of us need our therapy space to be precisely that, particularly in the early stages. No-one wants to come in to therapy to meet up with a Fritz Perls’ personality straightaway.
However, what happens is that, over the space of 8-12 weeks, our energetic space begins to change. We become familiar with the process of sharing our stories and what has happened to us. We develop a habit and a particular way of being in the room. And our therapist can either reinforce that habitual way of being – i.e. through simply listening – or they can substantially shake up the pace and progress through the generous offering of challenge. Here’s how.
What is challenge?
In therapy, challenge could look different to whoever is offering the challenge, and whoever is receiving the challenge. Sometimes, even the most innocuous challenge can be interpreted wildly different to how it was intended. This is one of the inherent risks within challenge. What is required is for a challenge to be offered that does not trigger a defensive response. This is incredibly hard, because we need to be acutely empathically attuned to the client. could be offering a different point of view, a reflection, or pointing out inconsistencies between, say, body language and expression of feeling. The client could say they are happy and their body language is closed off; by observing that, the client brings the observation in to awareness, and they have an opportunity to change that behaviour.
In life, humans are wired for habitual ways of relating, as I discussed here. Our brains need rhythmicity and regularity in order to avoid activating our fight/flight/freeze response. And this is the problem with challenge – too much challenge will activate the threat response, too little will reinforce the habits that the client wishes to change.
Challenge from therapists
Firstly I would suggest that challenge is assessed. Does a client need a challenge right now? Where are they energetically? Ask yourself what is their developmental need in the moment? Check out their readiness verbally. Make a gentle enquiry, bearing in the mind the content at the time.
If you assess a client as ready, grade the challenge. What I mean by this is thinking about a scale of numbers from 1-10, where. 10 is the biggest challenge, and 1 is the least. If this is a client you have seen for some years, and they have worked through much of their material, then perhaps come in with a 5 or 6. If they are still fairly new, think about a 1 or a 2.
Your challenge
Therapy is not just about submitting yourself to challenge from a therapist. You don’t even need to be in therapy. It is also about challenging yourself. You may be aware of some of the habitual ways of relating that you engage in. You may never ask a question of the therapist (or anyone else). A big feeling may have been triggered in therapy, but you never say anything. Here’s time to try something new.
The thought of taking yourself out of your comfort zone may be anathema. This is ok, and normal. However, it is important to begin to work out a way of getting yourself out of that comfort zone if you want to grow. If you want to share a negative feeling with the therapist, grade it at a 1. This may look like rolling your eyes. Or perhaps checking something out more than necessary (this technique can be massively powerful).
If you feel confident at grading higher, perhaps share your unhappiness from a very person-centred way. This could look like, “I hope this is ok to say, but I have a different view of that.” And if you’re in the mood for a ten, perhaps, “I’m not happy with what you said last week, and I demand we process that today.”
Next steps
Life doesn’t have to be full of stressful challenge. We can go with the flow as much as we need to. However, for those times that we recognise our way of being gets in the way of us achieving those things that we want to achieve, then challenge is a vital part of life. Even myself, as a psychotherapist, I also find myself not always saying the things i need to say, and perhaps limiting myself in other ways. But as soon as I realise my process, I try to change things up.
Change is, as I’ve mentioned here, stressful, but ultimately growthful. We cannot help but grow and adapt to change, but change shouldn’t be so huge that it feels traumatic. Change can and should invigorate our lives, not wipe us out. In a way, it is like starting a new programme at the gym, maybe starting a new class. Although we may ache and feel tired at first, we ultimately end up in better shape than we start.
Let me know how your change adventures go,
Much love,
Dr. Andrew x