The Restless Mind
Mental Health

Are you worried about misinformation?

26 Sep 2022·6 min read

I am worried about misinformation. Only yesterday, I was reading an article online via my apple news app. I came across one that said that the Chinese were controlling the algorithms. In particular, that they are controlling the way in which white people are viewed. The writer claimed that we no longer see white men in successful or skilled positions in social media posts as an intentional means of deconstructing the idea of powerful white people.

I reflected on my streams, and reflected on the fact that I do only tend to see nonsense. Some may say I write nonsense. I see pranks, and cooking programmes, but nothing special about white people. The occasional white politician pops up, but generally in a demeaning way. Conversely, the Chinese algorithms, apparently, only show Chinese people in successful and skilled posts. This is, allegedly, designed to undermine the West and strengthen the East.

Fact-checking misinformation

When I reflected further, I realised that what I read wasn’t accurate. The algorithms are actually designed to hook people in, so that their data can be used for financial benefit. The Chinese do not control the algorithms, they are set by those working in Silicone Valley. Doesn’t Twitter set its own algorithms? I concluded that this was a post designed to split people on the basis of race, attempting to cause anti-Chinese sentiment. What was awry, was that the news I read had slunk itself in to my feed.

I am a reasonably educated person, and was easily able to reflect and evaluate this story. But what about those who are not able? When I subsequently read about the troubles in Leicester, I began to sweat a little. I learned that they too, were victims of misinformation. We all were and are. And that, let me tell you, caused me a restless night’s sleep.

Leicester Riots

I’m not sure it’s accurate to state that there were riots in Leicester, but there was certainly evidence of groups of people in Leicester participating in unrest. We have read of houses being egged, people photographing strangers, and some men being arrested with knives. They were not the kind of troubles we read about in Northern Ireland a few years back. However, they were enough to cause alarm and unrest.

The trouble appears to have arisen from a cricket match between India and Pakistan. On further research, the culprit actually seems to be misinformation spread from India. In fact, there are reports of 97% of the Leicester material online being either untrue or fabricated. In fact, other stories also emanated from this. A Muslim girl was allegedly the victim of an attempted abduction. This resulted in people activating other groups of people to ‘investigate’. There was never any incident. The extent of the spread of false stories is probably bigger than we know. But it leaves us with an obvious problem (amongst others), doesn’t it?

The problem of misinformation

If we are assured that some parts of social media news are untrue, how do we recognise fact and fiction? How do you or I only get the truth? Can the media truly report accurately? The trouble in Leicester grew rapidly, without the Police having any intelligence of it. This was to the point that they only had 8 Police Officers there, and were unable to do anything. Perpetrators report being influenced by social media. This meant a very precarious situation was at high risk of escalating. I’m still not clear if it was either over-emphasised or minimised.

Ultimately, this has created unrest in Leicester that will need to be worked through carefully, over time. On top of the fake news, people have to reconcile the impact of people attacking them because of their identity, i.e. Muslim or Hindu, regardless of the cause. Such attacks linger in the human psyche, because they are, fundamentally, traumatic. And I’m not oblivious to the fact that these particular communities often contain people who have already fled violence from other countries, thinking Britain was a safe place. It clearly wasn’t in this instance.

Misinformation in our future

If communities are activated in this way on the basis of misinformation, this gives undue power to people who puppeteer the difficulties. There is no need to even enter another country, trouble can be caused in your own lounge, on your computer. And that is horrifying. The thought that there are people in the world intentionally and carefully creating false propaganda to stir up hatred and social unrest is damnable. That it was so successful is sobering.

There is a part of me that perhaps could easily worry about what this means for the future. Given the billionaires in Silicone Valley are building their own protected compounds, I am not reassured. The demand for panic rooms and safe houses is sky-rocketing and there is surely no coincidence between the level of social anxiety and reality. And this leaves people like me with the dilemma, of do we talk about it or ignore it?

Analysing the problem

In ignoring the news we are left unawares of important developments in the world. In talking about misinformation we fan the flames of concern. We have more than enough to already worry about as a global population. But the problem of misinformation is real, and the tech companies are clearly not ahead of the game. Neither are local Police, seemingly. And this is a totally new problem, in that social media can stir up social unrest so effortlessly. Governments need to pull their pants up and create a solution quickly.

And we need to put our dismay/panic/concern to one side, and tap in to the thinking parts of our brain. We need to robustly consider how we can meaningfully stop the spread of misinformation, without clouding the flow of real information. It’s a balance act to avoid the concerns of 1984, whilst ensuring society is safe.

Final thoughts

Even more importantly, the Leicester troubles remind us that, even in communities that are considered ‘cohesive’, there is division. And the U.K. is not an island with a cohesive identity, it is one of separate communities. We are separated by race, religion, age, and gender. And class. And many other things. Our challenge is to develop a way of bridging difference to create unity.

If there was ever an argument for developing our capacity for dialogue (In the Buber sense), this is it. We need to step foot out of our own community, and into the next one. For in that handshake we offer to someone different to us, regardless of that difference, we build bridges, not worsen them. And in doing that in real time, in person, we over-ride what the brooding matrix box tells us to think.

So step out of your own comfort zone, connect with your neighbour, and let’s see what miracles we can make ourselves. We all need to offer a helping hand to Leicester, to show they are all part of the wider island community of Britain. Let’s fill our feeds, the ones we control, with images of the love we have for our neighbours. Let’s over-ride the algorithm ourselves.

Much love,

Dr. Andrew x

Receive new essays

New pieces arrive infrequently and without filler. No newsletters about newsletters. Just writing, when there is something worth saying.