The Restless Mind
Blog

Book Review – The Yoga of Eating

11 Jan 2022·9 min read

by Dr. Andrew Smith

Book Review – The Yoga of Eating (Charles Eisenstein)

Good morning to you all.  I’m writing today from the cold of Sowerby Bridge, the wonder of the North of England.  Here, the grass is frozen, the air is cutting, and I am praying for some snow later in the day.  I am astonished I took the dogs out in the cold in shorts – I have always been critical of that in other people, but hey, here I am with egg on my face.  It wasn’t too bad ;0D.  In the meantime, here I write a review on The Yoga of Eating.

So, I picked up The Yoga of Eating last week.  I have been going through all the key books by spiritual writers, and will be reading and subsequently reviewing them all.  I am excited to do this – perhaps there could also be an opportunity for some proper research into them, but for now, I just want to understand what others are writing so I don’t replicate anything.  I started with Eisenstein’s book, as I have also been listening to his podcasts.  I do find them intriguing, stimulating, and they now accompany my daily constitutional. Incidentally, the first one I listened to was on the notion of a spiritual bypass with Mellody Hayes, which absolutely blew my mind, and so I intend listening to more of his thinking and also Mellody’s.  On to the book.

The book content…

This is a well written book, in terms of the prose being accessible and easily readable, and not too academic.  The length is also not too onerous, with just 175 pages with endnotes.  I also like that he uses endnotes because the reader has a choice as to whether or not to disrupt the readerly flow by flicking through the back sheets.  I didn’t bother reading them, but didn’t feel like I lost out on anything.  When I went through them at the end I was a little surprised to find they weren’t references, just more views.  I wonder if there was a way to have not used endnotes?  But I know if I wanted to read something on one of the points, I could find the reference and do that.

I want to also talk about the cover.  For an artist like myself, the cover is always significant.  I want to know how the cover connects the reader to the contents.  The cover uses some art deco fonts, and images of leaves, and I couldn’t really work out the relevance or connection to the content of the book.  Maybe that’s my bad.  The book also has a bit of a psychedelic vibe to the art work, which kind of left me disconnected with the material inside – I notice that the publisher also prints books with a similar, busy style, which I just don’t love.  I also think that the colour scheme – orange, black, green, and yellow – was not an obvious fit for the content.  However, the design was neat and had resonances with classical thinking, I guess intimating how Eisenstein positions himself. 

I also want to say that the pages were great quality – they felt nice to turn, and was like I had a great quality book in my hands, not something that had been printed on tatt.  For £9.34 it’s probably on the more expensive end of normality.  On to the Amazon reviews.

Wider reviews…

I read the one star reviews with some interest.  They seem to consist of vegans who take umbrage with Eisenstein’s view on meat, and people with an axe to grind about something else, i.e. one was ‘incensed’ that he had collaborated with Melanie Avalon.  I obviously need to research Melanie Avalon and find out what happened there!  I noticed that the five star reviews were all fluffy and amazing, not really grounded.  I can’t dispute the views, but I noticed the hyperbole.  I think that you often get those superlative reviews from the cult members – I think Charles is that kind of personality who attracts those kinds of personalities. 

I also noticed there were no reviews since 2019 – not sure what that is about.  I wondered if this means that sales of the book have peaked?  The book was published originally in 2009.  I also noticed the reviewer who felt there were not enough variations in the songs???  Maybe she was on the wrong planet. On to the content.

The book is formed like a sandwich, the meaty part is in the middle, padded out with carbs.  Whether or not this is a tasty BLT or a benign egg and cress is up to you.  For me,  the book’s mission – to help people with dietary problems, – is an important one, and close to my own heart.  I have worked with many people struggling with managing food.  In fact, I have another blog article on this subject coming up in a few days, and I think there is some material I can assimilate within my practice.  So the purpose of the book is important and valuable, and helpful to those who struggle with weight and food. 

The Actual Content…

The Central Practice is fairly straightforward.  Eisenstein basically wants us to get rid of distractions when eating, eat in silence, and eat slowly.  For those who already do this because they live on their own, I guess there could be limitations on how the material is extrapolated.  Eistenstein isn’t particularly helping you develop new ways of doing food for you.  He’s only offering one basic practice.  Now, it is a very important practice, but not ground-breaking or revelatory.  In fact, we’ve probably all heard it elsewhere; he falls prey to that which he criticises. 

If I’m critical, I would argue that this content doesn’t necessarily require a full book in itself.  The idea is simple, and Eistenstein could have been more creative in helping us develop ways to work with this idea rather than feed us more of his ideas.  He could have used more salami rather than bread.  The idea could probably be promulgated more efficaciously in other ways.  However, the factor that draws you in to the book is him himself.  The writer.  The personality.  The cool kid. 

For Eistenstein is certainly that.  The snippets of his life in the book truly suggests he has had a life where he has hung with the cool kids.  He has the aura and confidence of someone who can make those kinds of connections that some of us can only long for.  His views are also certainly edgy, and not for everyone.  He doesn’t doubt what he is saying, and he certainly owns his opinions which is obviously a very powerful thing.  Unless you get married to them.  In which case you become unstuck, as you risk becoming embroiled in defensiveness and resistance.  I don’t know if this is the case for him, but he certainly doesn’t offer any hesitation on what he believes.

Reading Eistenstein is also like sitting around a campfire with a know all, or going to the pub after a student union meeting.  He knows something about everything, but doesn’t really prove anything.  Other than he has strong opinions, and can navigate those opinions on the sea of life.  The other issue that Eistenstein does well is the old political diatribe.  He is politically astute, and keen to promote his ideas.  This is book is more of that than how to eat differently.  In fact, the only argument behind ‘yoga’ is that the book aims to bring one into wholeness or unity.  Which is discordant with his actual goal, that being to help people eat differently.  

Controversy…

In terms of greater problems, I would say it is the meat issue.  He obviously likes a steak.  He tries to justify this through claiming, “To eat meat is to enact a profound transfer of energy and information, in which an animal loses its life to sustain the life of another.”  This is perhaps Eistenstein’s fatal flaw; the lack of evidence and faulty reasoning.  If he had even provided some research on the impact of eating meat, he could have offered a more balanced section on meat eating.  To claim eating meat is a ‘transfer of energy and information’ is a tad flaky.  On the surface it looks like a spiritual insight, but doesn’t actually mean anything, and suggests he probably needs to reflect on the issues a little more.  In fact, he also misses the reality of life and death and the misuse of animals for human consumption.  And actually, most spiritual people are more mindful towards eating meat, so he misses a trick in terms of his audience.  So I think in parts he endeavours to be clever and insightful and controversial, but ends up coming across as defensive and misguided.  And I’m unsurprised by some of the reviews. 

I was also perturbed by his views on hydrogenated fat.  He kind of justifies it is ok to eat if it is in small amounts.  Again, if he had read (or assimilated) the evidence, he could have provided a more solid position on this.  Hydrogenated fats are clearly associated with heart disease and certain cancers, and I can’t see how people in influential positions should be encouraging this.  Very unhelpful position on this.  I think a case of process over content – personality over evidence.

Overall, I did take away some useful content that I will now practice with.  I will definitely try to eat differently.  I could endeavour to eat more mindfully as a general practice.  I will continue to think about the food I put in my body, as many of us are.  I am pleased he attempted to pull people away from kcals and diets – no-one needs another diet.  I will also not throw the baby out with the bath-water – I do like some of his views, and they resonate with me.  I like the fact he has a voice, and he can articulate it.  And perhaps there is something to learn in how he views and approaches life? 

Let me know what you think,

Andrew 

orange-anteater-584180.hostingersite.com/

Receive new essays

New pieces arrive infrequently and without filler. No newsletters about newsletters. Just writing, when there is something worth saying.