The Restless Mind
Blog

Catrin Finch and Aoife Ni Bhriain: Creating Emotive Musical Masterpieces

9 Jul 2024·6 min read

Before I talk about the album, a couple of weeks back, I had to take my Camac harp to Cardiff for a regulation. It was the time of the Cardiff Harp Festival, and the whole place was abuzz with activity and people. I planned to just helicopter in and then leave – I was drawn to buy a golden harp, and staying would have meant me paying a small fortune on something I didn’t need. So I popped in and out. However, as I was waiting in reception, and nosing around, a woman floated past me, pulling her harp in one hand and holding a bottle of water in the other. She looked imperious, and nonchalantly pushed the harp down a set of stone stairs, single-handed, without even flinching.

I was fuming and just a bit surprised. I had never dared push a harp downstairs alone as I was convinced it wouldn’t go well. Neither had I pulled it upstairs. My experience was one of frustration, arguments with the partner, and a brooding stress about the whole thing. But here, moving a harp seemed effortless. And then I recognised the woman as Catrin Finch – not only was her name everywhere in the harp world, I now knew she was as confident off stage as she was on. And I determined, from there on in, to hate her.

Now don’t get me wrong, there is no logic in that belief, as I have never even met her. I don’t know anything about her, besides an old documentary of her from years ago that I watched. I just know her name is everywhere. It was only last week my own harp teacher suggested Catrin could have played a piece I was working on, faster than I was endeavouring to. Talk about fuel on the fire. And if I had a penny for every time other musicians asked if I know her… Yes, I know of her, but have tended to avoid her.

I then noticed, with outrage, her name appearing at a folk festival – this was a classical performer, who was suddenly appearing at a folk festival. Are there no boundaries for this woman, I snorted with derision at my partner. Thus, picking up this album I didn’t really know what to expect, given I had such a distorted, toxic sense of her, with none of it based on reality. Unfortunately, the album confirmed everything I feared – she is brilliant.

This is an album of nine tracks, all are entitled with words beginning with, unsurprisingly, W. Apparently there is wit as well within the concept. The album mellifluously meanders around various motifs (some traditional folk tunes), using a gorgeous combination of the harp and violin. There are a few pieces that sound more classical than folk, but I can see why the act is considered crossover. The websites describe them both as virtuoso musicians – I think this is a term that is too often used. There must be at least 15 self-proclaimed virtuosos alone in Glastonbury. However, for Catrin especially, she can only be considered virtuoso. Yes, that hurt to write, from a mere non-virtuoso.

Both musicians are highly accomplished. I know nothing of Aoife, but I have to acknowledge that Catrin has earnt her stripes. The playing is immaculate, and there are a few pieces in particular that can only be described as breathtaking. Her career does speak for itself. She was the harpist to the Queen, after all.

With some musicians, you can’t help but suspect they are just playing to show off. They want to be seen, and their music is about sounding clever rather than pleasing. And there is something indulgent in that, more of what the musician thinks you want to hear, rather than what you want to hear. Unfortunately, this isn’t the case for this album. The sound is mesmerising, contemporary, and hypnotic. And to be honest, Catrin understands this issue, and knows that audiences don’t just want the fancy stuff.

Even the violin, which often can sound abrasive and can wipe out the harp, sounds lovely. Somehow they have both worked out pieces which kind of take turns to prioritise different sounds at different levels. This is a very sensitive approach to the work, and remarkable, and not easy. Also, with competent and skilled production. Thus, I have to conclude that the album is definitely felt, and is not about narcissism. It’s just very good.

I found myself wondering if this was all ad lib (noodling) or if they had spent time transcribing this and then performing? I don’t know, but if it was transcribed, then they deserve more acclaim – these are nine hefty pieces. On reflection, think it is probably much of the two – developing nine pieces like this is miraculous, if it was written all by hand in that time frame. And I think I detect moments where the recording studio has added on layers of sound that Catrin couldn’t have been playing at the same time. This isn’t criticism, but working out how the piece was made. If the pieces are ever transcribed I should be the first to buy the sheet music. I’m not claiming I’d be able to play them, but I’d try.

There are also some valuable points within the music that I noticed. Not one technique is over-used. There are moments where you will hear a solitary harmonic which adds clarity and a change of tempo, and others where Catrin’s fingers are raining down on the strings, producing a heavenly, brilliant sound. I love the use of motif throughout – varying the pace, the range, and the tempo within each piece. We recognise the piece, yet it becomes innovative in the hands of these musicians.

Honestly, it’s the first time in a while I have wanted to listen to a music only album all the way through twice in a row, and again this morning. If you want to write a great album, this is how you do it. Not by listening to albums,

Anyway, just go and listen to it yourself. I have now developed respect for Catrin now I ‘know her’ (from one harpist to another), and will definitely watch her stuff more carefully. I think there is also learning here that, in our envy, we miss off opportunities for ourselves, especially learning. This is an album that we all as musicians could learn from. And hopefully love. Let me know what you think!

Much love

Andrew x

Receive new essays

New pieces arrive infrequently and without filler. No newsletters about newsletters. Just writing, when there is something worth saying.