Good morning from cloudy Calderdale. I pulled a muscle/trapped a nerve in my back at the weekend, probably by lugging my concert grand up and down some stairs to a stage. It’s been absolutely shocking pain – to the point I couldn’t lift my left arm. It was a sober reminder to ensure that harps are moved carefully and with support. Going rogue, like I do, is not a good look! And another reminder to us as musicians, that if we are unwell we don’t work, and we don’t get paid. I’m not quite ready for a life of poverty! Anyway, are there issues with classical music training? I’d say definitely. Here’s why.
Rigidity
Most teachers I have trained with, in all the instruments I’ve been taught, had a level of rigidity. This isn’t a criticism in itself, but reality. On the violin I most definitely had to hold the instrument in a particular way. On the flute, I had to play the Irish ornamentation, whether I liked the sound or not, and there was no room for including, say, Baroque ornamentation. And with the harp, you either learn traditionally by ear, or classically, with everything that comes with it. Every teacher has their method, and generally they tend to not detract from that.
Now, in itself, a bit of clarity is helpful. You wouldn’t want to go to a teacher who says, just do it how you want to, would you? You pay them to learn their methods. I also think we all benefit from the reassurance that comes with knowing we are getting something right, i.e. their methods. However, what happens in the practice room is that the methodologies can become a means to shame and proverbially beat the student, no matter how nice the teacher is. Shame emerges at the intersection between teachers’ expectations, clumsy and misaligned teaching methods, and external pressure on students. .
The impact of shame
The issue with this is that students end up building shame about themselves and their practice, and often looks like perfectionism. A whole host of issues can arise from this. Even myself, an adult who has worked in mental health for decades, can be affected. I lose count of the amount of times I come out of lessons thinking about my inadequacies and how badly I played. And this is another challenge for teachers. You can’t reinforce unhelpful techniques, but need to frame the feedback in a way which won’t wipe out the student.
I have had some shocking teachers in the past. Often teachers who didn’t want to teach, seeing themselves more as performers. It can feel like you are such a disappointment to the teacher, that you get even less confident. I remember one teacher where I became so anxious, the instrument would slip in my hands with sweat. This is not an optimal learning environment for anyone. Now, you could say that, if you can rise above that kind of conduct, you will be hardened for performing. But should we become brutalised in this way?
Technique focus
So there are positives with shame, in that you can use it to be as perfect as you can. But it isn’t healthy ultimately. As a psychotherapist with vast experience, shame is the process which brings most people to therapy at some level. and if you are shaming your students to perfection, there is an ethical issue here. And it’s not the only way to develop great players – you can easily nurture and challenge and support students to excel.
I have learnt best when my needs are understood, and when my efforts are validated and seen. When we reinforce something positively, we are more likely to repeat it. For some years I became so neurotic about my playing, I made more mistakes than I ever did. I became worse. My confidence disappeared. And I’m sure I’m not the only one. No learning pedagogy confirms that shaming anyone is helpful. And getting my legs slapped in 1979 for gossiping during a lesson ensured a complete breakaway from that particular instrument.
Innovation
I don’t think that being too rigidly stuck in classical methodologies ultimately helps develop new and innovative ways of playing your instrument. You just learn how others have always done it. I see the impact of this in performers. They become so focused on playing how they believe they should. I know many classical performers who are so disabled by this, that they go completely frozen when asked to improvise something. If the rules (i.e. sheet music) aren’t in front of them, they can’t play. This can result in freezing on stage, and utter panic. And eventually leaving the industry.
Whilst classically trained musicians can obviously create new music, there is a steep learning curve for them. This is because, even though we know our instruments, and the rules, we are not developing the necessary symbiosis between player and instrument. I only truly discovered the harp when I began to put the sheet music down, and ‘noodle’ around. And it’s only truly when I’m playing ‘my’ music, that the instrument and I become one.
Putting the music down
If we are to write new music we have to forget the old music. If we want to play as our true self, we have to find that self, not the self that has been created. And if you’re afraid of wrong technique, just listen to what you’re playing. This is engineering – work out a new way of playing that particular phrase that works for you. Get it right for you. And this is the other scary part of innovation. When we step out on our own, we necessarily – at times – contradict what we have been taught. We go against, or away from, our teachers. Which requires courage. And self-belief
Final thoughts
Go to your lessons, and learn what your teachers have to offer, but don’t lose yourself. There are huge benefits to learning an instrument. If you struggle with your teacher, find someone else. The teaching ‘fit’ is most important, and if you don’t feel nurtured, find someone who will nurture you. If you spend your teaching time in fight or flight you are not learning, just surviving.
And remember that you can branch out of your learning at any time. Put your music down, and begin to discover your instrument for you. Use the instrument to express you, wherever you are. If you’re sad, crack into those minor keys, and create a beautiful melody. If you’re angry, pick up the percussive instruments and bash away until the feeling has elapsed. And finally, more than anything, get comfortable with your mistakes. You’re ok, we all make them, whatever they are. Just imagine – if we develop a world where musicians are ok to be imperfect, and music is that which we need it to be; nourishing, creative, and expressive.
And let me know what you think,
Andrew x