I just watched a video by an organisation I have much respect for, Ascension. Ascension has a comprehensive bible reading course led by Fr. Mike Schmitz, and they offer many free resources to help people on their spiritual journey, albeit from a Roman Catholic perspective. On the surface, the video has much relevance to contemporary lifestyles – if we find ourselves alone, we shouldn’t consider ourselves inadequate, or stop the search for meaning in life. And how wonderful it is to have young adults speaking about spirituality. However, the speaker is advocating for and normalising isolation. This leads me to ask the question, does a spiritual life need to be isolated? Should spirituality be one of connection rather than disconnection. This, for so many reasons, is something I would exercise acute caution with. Here’s why.
Loneliness is a killer
Loneliness is the sensation we get when our innate need for contact with others is not met. There is a difference between being alone and being lonely; the former is more about choice and needs, the latter is about needs not being met. And sometimes, even when we are surrounded by people, we can feel acutely lonely. In fact, some of you may feel phobic about people, and seek your own company whenever possible.
Loneliness, in the UK at least, is a bigger killer than lung cancer. Being alone, being isolated, especially as we age, is dangerous. Loneliness in particular can impact our mental health. We also know that people who engage in meaningful activities with others tend to live longer, happier lives. We are social creatures, and we have a fundamental need for attachment and connection with others, at whatever level.
Is singledom all bad?
I have written on the virtues of solitude here. However, solitude in a choiceful, mindful way, especially for short periods of time, is very different to isolation.
And for people who are considering a life without connection at all, I feel should be careful. If you have a secure base of people around you, and you have developed sound coping mechanisms, there should be no issue. However, for those who have had a shakier start to life, or who already struggle with their mental health, I would exercise caution.
The neurology of contact with others
Thousands of years ago, we lived more isolated, more dangerous lives. Life was short, harsh, and unforgiving. Over time, we needed to connect with other humans to ensure survival; we needed to trade, to join forces against aggressors, and to mate. We still do. And our brains developed in order to meet this need. I have also written about this variously.
In fact, we still need contact with others; it is the contact with others that helps us heal. Gestaltists are acutely aware of this, and have geared their entire therapy to support people in developing the quality of contact in their lives.
Contact is hard
I often hear how some of us avoid contact because it is too difficult. The right level and quality of contact with others is incredibly hard for anyone to accomplish. I probably do not get the titration right for myself all the time. But it is important we try, that we spend our lives improving what we do, taking responsibility for us, and developing our capacity for contact.
So whilst I understand that relationships are not for everyone, just copping out of them because they are hard is insufficient. And whilst social media may have hooked us in emotionally to believe our complex intra-personal needs are being met, it is now. Social Media might feel enough in some ways – but being drawn in through out feedback loop propensity is not the same as sitting with someone, getting hugs, being loved. I also think that the younger generation are more likely to argue for isolation, but this is, I fear, misguided.
Getting your own contact
I would spend time thinking about what contact you need in your life. It won’t be the same for everyone. If there is a sense for you that you do not have enough, then I would spend time contemplating on what this is about. Do you draw back from contact? Does contact feel scary? Do you fall out with people too easily? Find the answer, and begin to work on remedying it now. For our spiritual practice offers us an invaluable opportunity to not only feel good about ourselves, but to support our capacity for contact with others.
I would also encourage you to find your own tribe. Begin joining events and activities that you enjoy, and connect with others. Learn how to chat in real time in person. Put your phone down, and learn how to tolerate contact with others. Social media too easily lets us block, ignore, and demean that which we find challenging. Life is about tolerating difference, surviving adversity, and developing our hidden edges.
I hope this is helpful. If you want further support with this, follow me on all platforms, as I will shortly be offering intensive Gestalt workshops to support your own personal growth.
Best wishes,
Dr. Andrew x