The Restless Mind
Mental Health

I will not cure you

11 Sep 2022·4 min read

You may well wonder why I state, ‘I will not cure you’. Let me tell you. Most of us have assimilated the idea of a cure from science. When we start therapy we expect all symptoms to be removed, and, for example, the depression to be removed completely. As we would a lump. Let’s face it, who wouldn’t want all depressive feelings removed? However, in this article we need to talk about other ways of thinking about what therapy will actually offer us.

1. Therapists do not offer medical model-type interventions.

The word ‘cure’ is from the medical world, where they measure and observe ‘data’. Their belief system is based on something called ‘positivism‘. This position influences much of the world in terms of treatment and interventions. However, therapy acknowledges that much of what being a human about is not measurable. We are not robots. Therapists do not make attempts to measure this, and recognise the limitations of the medical model in this respect. We are ok with not knowing, and recognise also the negative impact of the medical model on therapeutic interventions.

2. Your perception is not mine

Even if we did work with the idea of a cure, your perception of what constituted that cure would be different to mine. For the sense of when we are cured varies for us all. When you are ready to leave therapy, I may have a different sense. You may wonder why your partner is leaving therapy, and vice versa. This is all ok, but we should respect the difference. If I brought the cure to your door, and said you were cured because my tick boxes were full, what would it be like if you didn’t agree? Not helpful at best!

3. Reality versus fantasy

People often imagine therapy is about removing all negative emotions. What would life be like if we all only felt happiness? Would it not be weird? Isn’t life about feeling the range of emotions in very natural ways? I feel it is important to feel sad if a loved one dies. What isn’t ok is if that sadness permeates everything they do and they stop living. Therapy helps us mediate between the two.

4. Distortions from social media

We read all sorts on social media, and many people presenting themselves as therapists have never stepped foot in a therapy class. However, they are free to post bizarre, unrealistic, and manipulative posts which unduly influence people. Largely in order for people to be parted with their money. This isn’t okay. Any registered therapist will work ethically and within the parameters of their own expertise.

5. Online cures

If anyone is offering just an online ‘cure’, then be cautious. Therapy, as we know through lockdown, can work online, but works infinitely better in person. In the room we can each the whole of each other, and our other senses are more alive to the encounter before us. This is the magic of therapy, and the contact between therapist and client. Whilst online work is convenient, and many therapists shut their therapy rooms down to work solely online, this does reduce the chances of transformation.

6. Transformation not cure

A cure implies that all symptoms (difficult feelings) have gone. This would be untrue, as we will always feel the whole gamut of feelings. Again, we are not robots. However, where therapy’s magic lies is the way in which we transform the way we relate to ourselves and others. Therapy enables us to manage those difficult feelings when they emerge. Therapy also offers us space to reflect on different ways of being around people. If our healing and recovery lie in the combination of both self awareness and contact with others, then this should always be at the heart of what we do in the therapy room.

I hope this helps. Let’s still remember that therapy, with the right people, can be transformative. It could be the best investment you will ever make – I wish I had started my own journey twenty years earlier. Don’t delay yours.

Much love,

Dr. Andrew x

Receive new essays

New pieces arrive infrequently and without filler. No newsletters about newsletters. Just writing, when there is something worth saying.