The Restless Mind
Blog

The need for integration in talking therapies

15 Jun 2022·8 min read

So, today marks the end of another fulfilling, challenging, stimulating week teaching at the University I work in.  I have particularly enjoyed the contact with students.  These people are the psychotherapists of the future, and I am always taken aback by their passion and receptiveness to new ideas.  If only I was able to work there full-time. A theme that has come up for me this week is that of the need for integration in talking therapies. 

Talking about integration in real life

This shouldn’t be, by any means, a new theme to any of us. Indeed, integrative psychotherapy has been around for many years.  More recently, certainly over the past five years or so, I have watched with interest as Mick Cooper expounds the virtues of pluralistic counselling practice.  There is a temptation to reduce the two approaches to the same thing, and thus apply pluralism to psychotherapy, but the two are very different, in my opinion.

I won’t offer the various definitions of integration here, but aim to provide my own. And this isn’t the space to provide a manual of integrative psychotherapy – there are loads of books out there that do this already. And I encourage you to find your own definition of the practice.  But I definitely use this approach within my work.

In brief, I understand integration as the process of deeply assimilating concepts, ideas, and theories from multiple perspectives into our core self as practitioners.  This is akin to Ken Evans and Maria Gilbert’s position, whereby we relate to different therapeutic approaches through the I-Thou.   Integration is not about aping something, such as reading very loosely about an idea, and using it maybe once or twice, but incorporating that idea into our very being; knowing, understanding, and being changed by that idea within the consulting room. 

Integrative psychotherapy is not about being flaky, but about depth, passion, and assimilation. It’s not about learning one or two phrases, but the whole language, in depth.  There is a value to what we do in integration. I think it’s right to be wary of someone who knows everything, rather than someone who uses a few things well.  Integration is about using less more, not more less. 

Integration and the Gestalt Field

I like to think about the idea of the Gestalt field here.  Gestalt is – in my opinion – the original integrative psychotherapy, and continues to evolve; practitioners are not stagnant.  Indeed, there are lots of models out there in our field as psychotherapists to understand the principle of integration, but it is the process of incorporating theory from our figure into our ground and back, which is the key principle.  And through that symbiotic process of transmission, absorption, and recapitulation, we integrate ideas and processes into our field. 

I like to believe that we are all integrative psychotherapists at one level – we all integrate at least one idea within what we do in the consulting room.  Also, none of us use any model or approach identically.  In fact, our process of integration is always unique, and integration occurs in the here and now.  Which is partially about how we understand the field.  We are not robots after all.  But this isn’t an article on the practice of integrating theory into psychotherapy practice, but a wider exploration of the process of integration within the psychotherapy field. 

Are we all integrative in reality?

Apart from work with student psychotherapists, I have met with three different psychotherapists this week.  I won’t name them, I don’t have permission, but I remain fascinated by the way they expressed a wonderful passion for their preferred modality. One was an esteemed, highly experienced psychodynamic psychotherapist, one a leading existentialist, and the third an expert in CBT approaches.  All three essentially do the same work in their own unique ways, in that all meet with clients, all form relationships, and all maintain those relationships over time.  And all possess a shared sense of being a psychotherapist, arising from their extensive clinical training and professional practice. 

However, each one identified as their modality primarily, rather than their professional title of psychotherapist.  This is a reality of our professional careers, that when we enter any room of therapists, our first point of interest is generally their modality.  We then evaluate our internal hierarchy, around whether we are superior or not to them.  Humans are intrinsically hierarchical, and our modality structure reinforces that.  However, if more of us adopted the integrative approach, recognising levels of training rather than kinds of training, I am sure we could become more integrated also as a professional community.  For we are divided.

Are all trainings the same?

One of the challenges here when we talk about integration in the field, is if all psychotherapy trainings are the same, or if a counsellor is actually the same level as a psychotherapist?  Is being ‘different’ an adequate explanation?  Does a practitioner with a 100 client hours and 20 hours therapy work as effectively as a practitioner with 400 client hours and 200 personal therapy hours?  Does the amount of training you have had make you better or worse? Is effectively a good word to use when discussing this principle?  How would we ever know the answer?  I know the research base isn’t exactly advanced in this field, but we certainly know about the importance of ‘common factors’ and the ‘relationship’ amongst others.

My sense is that the two professions above lead to different levels of expertise – a practitioner with 400 hours will have been exposed to far more material, more ways of working, more awareness of self, and more clients over longer periods of time; this suggests, essentially, a greater capacity to integrate, or even understand the notion of integration.  The same goes for therapy – was I the same when I had had 20 hours psychotherapy, or when I had had 240 hours psychotherapy at the end of my training?  I would say I was an entirely different person, and that therapy, through the reduction of my defence mechanisms, facilitated the process of integration for me.  Which leads to the question around if personal therapy maketh the psychotherapist? 

Importance of personal therapy in integration

I would suggest that someone who has spent two hundred hours exploring the self, and having continuous feedback on the way they relate to themselves and the world can only impact them powerfully.  And if you have never experienced what it is like to be held in a therapeutic space for four years, how can you reliably support someone else?  I wish I had undertaken my journey much earlier than I did, but it was still a gift. And in the spirit of contemporary offence culture, should we ask the questions and formulate our answers even if it upsets someone else?  I am aware I have moved from integration into the field of SCoPEd, which is not the ‘scope’ (excuse the pun) of this article, but therapy does facilitate our capacity to integrate. For those of you who have had therapy for over two years, would you say you are different now to then?

The wider therapeutic field

But within the therapeutic field, change is afoot.  The UKCP, the BACP, and the APC (and others) have now completed the latest version of the SCoPEd documentation, and it seems that we now wait for titles to be given to the three columns of practitioner.  I imagine that, despite the offence taken by the suggestion of using ‘counsellor’, ‘psychotherapist’, psychotherapeutic counsellor’, we will end up with those titles.  For I do believe that if the field is going to be organised in to three tiers of expertise based on training length, no psychotherapist will want their professional title removing, or used by someone without that level of training.  This might well be the beginning of protecting titles, but that remains to be seen. It may be that the process of having protected titles could lead to more integrative practice amongst practitioners, not less.

However, do I believe that having different titles supports or hinders the process of being an integrative practitioner? I fundamentally believe that you can call yourself whatever you wish, but you need to understand and work with the process of integration if you are to work effectively with whatever the client brings to you within their field.

Moving forwards…

Consequently, I love the concept of integration, and also the process.  Even though there are differing levels of integration within our profession, we all integrate as we work.  Integration allows me a breathtaking level of versatility, and I can offer my clients interventions based on their needs, rather than bending the rules of the modality I am trained in to fit the client.  We are far more reflexive if we can do this, as not every client is at the same developmental stage, and although a psychodynamic approach may work for one client, it may not work for the next, who may want a more relational, contactful intervention.  And client’s needs change. 

Finally, for those of us who are a little longer in the tooth, integrative practice allows us to continuously develop what we do – in fact, integration is a way of staying on top of our game, and supports us in keeping aligned with developments in the field.  In this sense, integrative practice is a necessity.  Here’s to continuously developing our relationship with integration, and integrating the concept of integration itself!

And finally, here is an integrative chihuahua – a fine example of courage, knowledge and wisdom.

Enjoy your week,

Andrew

Receive new essays

New pieces arrive infrequently and without filler. No newsletters about newsletters. Just writing, when there is something worth saying.