I recently heard about a drama teacher conducting a Stanislavsky exercise with a class. The exercise itself was difficult, but the impact on the student was immense. This leads me to ask the question, ‘Should we be careful with feedback?’ Is the quality of our feedback important, regardless of how or why we give it? I think so. Here’s why.
Doing feedback badly
The above exercise required students to think about something they feared the most, and act from there. This was acutely triggering for one of the participants, and the situation escalated. The person could not recover themselves, and had to leave the class. This was distressing itself, and the exercise irresponsibly opened up the person’s trauma.
Later, when the student returned, the teacher blamed the student for choosing something too fearful and too anxiety provoking. The student was devastated, not only because of the impact of tapping in to the fear stimulus, but because they were blamed for following the instructions. The teacher took no responsibility for the leading of the exercise, and the student was left shamed, confused, and disappointed.
My own experiences
Even for myself, I have recently fallen foul of feedback. I took another harp examination last week. Whilst I never set my expectations up too high given I am ancient, I had hoped for some helpful feedback in order to develop my practice. The feedback that I received was, let’s say, interesting. The comments were vague, superfluous, and didn’t really mean anything when I unpicked them. There’s another issue here that it is often a non-harp teacher that ends up giving feedback on an instrument they do not play. This meant more of a distance between them and me.
The terminology they used was also wordy and inappropriately eloquent. This meant that, although I could understand the feedback, if I was a student still at school, I may well have struggled to understand what they meant. This made me realise as, the person who delivers feedback daily to both clients, supervisees, and trainees, do I always get the feedback right? Here’s a few thoughts.
Value of feedback
Feedback is helpful if you can absorb it (i.e. not too prickly), can understand it (delivered in a language or way you understand), and is relevant (not feeding back irrelevancies). Effective and constructive feedback helps us understand our skills and processes better. When we absorb the message effectively, we can develop what we do e.g. be different with others, improve weaknesses, and achieve better.
I think that it’s so important that feedback is authentic, and that the ‘feedbacker’ does not pretend to be something that they are not, eg able to play an instrument that they cannot. Also, that the feedback is delivered in the way that someone can understand the feedback. It’s also vital that the feedback is delivered carefully knowing that the person reads the feedback will absorb it. I am well old and able to take feedback, but I know that the kind of feedback I’ve had recently would not have been absorbed so readily by other people.
Further thoughts
We need feedback to help us grow. The issue with social media in particular (I talk about this often) is that when we read something challenging we just block the offender, and move on. Whilst this is helpful on social media, in life it is not so helpful. If we shut off from feedback, we inhibit opportunities for growth.
Feedback is an incredibly useful mechanism to help us think about what we are doing or how we are doing something. Feedback also helps us connect with how somebody else sees us. Thus, the importance of feedback is immensely powerful. However, with the feedback is that often feedback is delivered clunkily or poorly, we actually inhibit opportunities for growth.
Developing our capacity to give feedback
Thus, please, remember to consider how the person will receive your feedback, however you give it. Written feedback is more precarious than verbal. Will you trigger them? Will you wipe them out? Are you giving feedback out of care or anger (think about emotional states) – if you’re offering from care, you are more likely to success. If anger is around, manage your anger first as you will inevitably contaminate the work you are trying to accomplish.
And if you doubt it, don’t do it.
Best wishes,
Dr. Andrew x