This is article is for anyone wondering about climate disaster. In particular, want to understand why governments and people are not acting as robustly as they need to. The issue of climate disaster is hugely triggering for some, and I am only going to discuss a few points today. But I hope that they are of use to you in your work, whatever that is.
The back story
I drove home from work last night, and for the first time in months, I needed to put my lights on. The temperature was also much cooler than it has been for some weeks. I also noticed that it was also cooler this morning. It occurred to me that autumn was on its way, (in the Northern hemisphere at least) and I would like us to reflect on this change.
Firstly, the arrival of autumn reminds me of the disconnection between contemporary society and that of our ancestors. Just decades ago, our relationship with the seasonal transitions was far more pronounced. We were intimately connected with the seasons, and our lives depended on good harvests. If the crops failed, we died. This is still the case around the world.
Now that food just arrives in the supermarkets, we complacently just take what is there with little thought for the production process behind the products on the shelves. We have less connection with nature, and in particular, the rhythms of the seasons, and most people have no idea what foodstuffs are ‘in season’. Our concern nowadays isn’t ensuring our crops do well, it’s ensuring there are food on the shelves. This has come in t focus more sharply during the current cost of living crisis.
The cost of living crisis
The reaction to the mere mention of the cost of living crisis demonstrates the anxiety that a threat to our food supplies can trigger. Which makes sense. The concern, however, is that we are not making the connection between the climate disaster and future loss of food supplies. I have wondered why the same activation doesn’t exist with regards to the climate crisis, and have a realised a few things that might be helpful to reflect on.
The issue of denial
Firstly, the issue of denial. Denial is a profound defence mechanism. Denial helps us stop feeling difficult feelings. It is an emotional disconnect button. You will have seen it in life. Ask any politician a difficult question, and they will respond with denial, usually. Ask the adulterous partner a question about it, and they may deny doing anything. Think also about yourself – what have you denied? Have you ever stolen anything, and then denied it was you? Have you broken something and denied it was you?
Most of us have. The issue isn’t so much that people commit adultery or steal, it’s that our instinctive response can be, when challenged, to deny it. The process of denial stops us feeling shame, fear, or anger usually. All of these feelings can be overwhelming. And I think that the mention of climate destruction is so triggering, so activating on a deep level, that it is impossible for many people to tap in to the feelings this generates. This isn’t the case for everyone – read my article on self-immolation. But it is common.
Failure to act
Not being able to buy Junior’s special brand of crisps is very different to the issue of international starvation, floods, and the end of life as we know it. The former triggers an immediate run down to the supermarket, the latter, because of its vastness, its horrors, and its complexity, leads us to grab another bag of crisps. Ultimately, denial alleviates anxiety but factors in delay and procrastination for effecting the changes we need to see now. The other issue is fear.
Most governments don’t act because of fear of the other. They don’t want to invest because they are afraid other governments won’t invest. They don’t want to stop burning fossil fuels because they are afraid they might lose profit. I am reminded of me and my brother, fighting over who had to give the largest piece of chocolate to the visiting cousin. Both enraged and panicky because we might have to give up more than the other. The situation is exactly the same.
The issues of fear and greed
In this situation, fear is linked to greed. People are ok to buy a reusable carrier bag, but not stop using their car as that will entail ‘hardship’. We are ok to offer a surface contribution that makes no dint in our resources, but are paralysed with fear when faced with the reality of needing to make dramatic changes to our lifestyles and way of living. I imagine there is a solution there, e.g. by gradually, imperceptibly making necessary changes, humans have the opportunity to adapt rather than panic.
But greed and fear are definitely the key feelings we need to consider and address in order to effect the much needed environmental changes. And, like my parents intervened with my brother and I over the chocolate, the world leaders need to intervene more robustly, and not from a position of greed and self-serving behaviours.
In the meantime, let’s think about what we can do emotionally for ourselves.
- Meditate on the notion of greed. What does greed look like for you? What do you covet? What do you hoard? What do you throw out?
- Consider the role of denial in your life. What do you deny? How does denial function? If you deny denial exists, I recommend that be the starting point.
- Consider how to activate and educate your local MP/government official. Knowing they are functioning from a place of fear and/or greed, how can you make contact with them which effectively helps them to break through their denial, and activate their capacity to do something now?
- Climate disaster is hugely distressing and anxiety-provoking for those involved in the movement. It’s time to ensure you maintain health and stability in order to be as effective as possible. What are you doing to maintain your own equanimity?
If you need advice or would like support on how to better activate those around you, watch this space!
Best wishes,
Dr. A x