The Restless Mind
Mental Health

The issue of suffering

25 Aug 2022·9 min read

The issue of suffering is a highly pertinent one in personal transformation. In fact, the idea of suffering haunts us across the globe, regardless of age, gender, or culture. Humans are fearful of suffering, and work hard to avoid the sense of suffering is prevalent across the globe. Thus, I think is vital that we consider the issue of suffering, not just for those we work with, but for life in general.

Suffering in religion

Within many spiritual traditions lies the issue of suffering.  Buddhism’s four noble truths refer to the idea that: we all suffer, that suffering is part of existence, and that we are part of the cycle of samsara (dukkha); that something causes suffering to happen, i.e. illness (samudaya); that suffering can end (nirodha); and that there is a way to end suffering, i.e. through buddhism (magga).  We are said to experience suffering repeatedly over many lives. According to buddhism, the challenge for humans is to accept that suffering is there and accept that we cannot do anything about it. But there are other traditions that consider the idea of suffering, albeit with different connotations.

Let’s take Christianity for example.  Jesus suffered variously, and taught that suffering is a product of the fall, i.e. a consequence of human sin against God (Romans 5:12; 1 Corinthians 15:21).  Because the world is broken, we suffer, although some suffering is due to sinful and wrong choices. We are taught that suffering was not part of God’s original plan, as the world was originally perfect. Christianity teaches us that suffering and evil is an opportunity to become better people and improve our souls.  By following the Ten commandments, we are offered a way to avoid suffering. Others follow a similar train of thought.

Islam teaches that a knowledge of right and wrong is intrinsic to human nature, and that individuals should know, without being informed, what actions are evil and will contribute to others’ suffering (fitrah).  Allah’s guidance will help humans avoid the temptations of the devil. There is a theme here, isn’t there?  Firstly, that humans suffer, but that religion or spirituality can reduce, ameliorate, or eliminate suffering.

Why the teaching on suffering?

I ask myself why this is the case.  Why would an organisation of people, regardless of their belief format, teach that, by following a certain path or teachings, we can avoid suffering? Also, I ask if suffering so inevitable a part of life? Is suffering so intolerable that we lack the personal resources to manage or ameliorate it? Is suffering so prevalent?

When I think of my own life, I feel contented most of the time. I can afford to eat, I go on holidays, I have loved ones around me, and am in good health.  I have suffered significant losses in my life, but am ok. Even though I notice I am equating my lack of suffering all to external factors. Many other people I know would say similar things. Some people I know would gloat about how much stuff they have, how successful they are, etc. And I understand that many of us live privileged lives that others can only dream about.

However, I haven’t worked in psychotherapy for twenty years to not have any idea about other people’s lives.  Also, my own earlier life was not like this. I have known the shadow side of humanity, in the face of poverty, hunger, violence, and fear.  I have spent many years trying to mend myself from what occurred in times gone by.  And I am not naïve enough to believe there is no suffering out there, even though I may be inoculated from much of this.

Suffering in history

In the past, suffering was inevitable.  We survived times where hunger was the biggest killer of us all, and where life was – in many ways – far trickier than it is now.  Life was more brutal, living conditions were harsher, and suffering must have been de rigeur. When reading – particularly in the West – ancient texts, we learn of certain practices that would just not be acceptable nowadays (think state-sanctioned torture, hanging/drawing/quartering). Reading texts such as The Canterbury Tales show us that simply surviving winter was an achievement.  Women would face high chances of dying in childbirth, and families tried for large numbers of children as the chance of infant mortality was also distressingly high. Some claim mortality was as high as 50%. Times certainly seem much better in the 21st Century.

We no longer, for example, hang/draw/quarter people. Welfare standards are much higher, as is Education accessibility, and health care. This isn’t the case across the globe, but is more common than not. I can take vaccinations to avoid major viruses, and can dial emergency services in, well, emergencies. However, even though the things that used to preoccupy our fears have largely abated, other fears now occupy us. 

Suffering now

We still fear poverty, violence, and crime.  The notion of attachment to ‘pretties’ is still as prevalent as it always has been. We fear death as much as ever before, and spend our lives trying to get fit, eating well, and avoiding addictions to survive (avoid death) longer.  There is still the grim chance that we experience loss of loved ones, sometimes of our children.  We still get into financial hardship, and social media has created new ways of hurting others through trolling, cancelling, and online hate.

There is no coincidence that the over-prescribing of anti-depressants is a way of psychoactively trying to manage the impact of suffering. However, even the drugs we take to alleviate suffering cannot truly be said to work in the way we imagine. Drugs are certainly not the cure all that they are sold as. Ultimately, it seems as though the notion of suffering is still as relevant as previously, albeit of a different, perhaps more insidious nature.

Need to help with suffering

Thus, there is still an argument for helping people feel differently about their reality.  And again, as a psychotherapist, I have much experience in trying to support people feel differently about their lives.  In fact, the amount of referrals I get myself (Sometimes five a day), is constant and impossible to meet the rising need for help. I don’t believe I’m the only one experiencing such demand.

However, as a psychotherapist, we are trained to offer clients an opportunity to get out of suffering using particular models or techniques.  I may use Gestalt, Transpersonal, or systemic ideas to support that process. However, despite that weekly hour’s session being an important one, during which we work very hard and focused on the problem at hand, it is a very small part of the client’s week. In fact, just one of the 168 hours.  If we don’t even consider the notion of suffering, how can we truly maximise what we do in the consulting room?

Increasing the value of intervention

We certainly need to come at the management of suffering from all bases. In fact, the argument for still engaging in religious or spiritual practices seems a pertinent one for lots of reasons. 

Firstly, spirituality helps us reconfigure our consciousness in ways that can ameliorate suffering. If we consider suffering intellectually, we may believe we know our reality, or our world in an intellectual sense. However, the truth is that reality is not reality; reality does not exist.  Reality is data structures that we create. Or rather, collections of sense perceptions.  If reality is so subjective, and if there is an inherent level of ‘unknown’ within reality, spiritual practices help fill in that gap. Thus, spirituality helps us understand our world more coherently than just intellectually. If we know it, we can do something different.

Reconfiguring reality to make suffering seem different

Suffering only exists when we perceive it to exist. We create data structures differently to everyone else, even though we may see shared elements. My particular group of data structures may signal suffering to me. And again, what may be suffering to me may not be suffering to you. For this is the core meaning of any transformation process – if we are to manage suffering, we need to remove the meaning we attach to the data structures in our existence through managing our projections into what we perceive as the world. For this is the only reality – consciousness.

Therapy is a process of working through the endless projections we have in the world, in a very clear, systematic way (for those of us trained to work with them). The saying is, ‘we live, we breathe, and we project’. If you don’t know what projections are, it would be helpful to begin with the Course in Miracles. This will help you navigate that process.

De-activating the physiological arousal from suffering

What we know from the likes of Joe Dispenza, in fact, from a ton of researchers across the world, is that spiritual practices are highly beneficial on overall health.  They are most helpful when they are helping us calm the body.  Meditation and yoga are specific practices that support this process.  The evidence suggests that experienced meditators were found to have affected their health positively at a cellular level. Meditators were found to have levels of positive arousal, measured in blood plasma, similar to the idea of ‘ecstasy’ or ‘bliss’.  Meditation then, helps us experience life far differently than those who don’t.

Experienced meditators were also shown to reverse infection and create disease-fighting proteins.  This is a massive benefit from spiritual practices. In addition, breath, that which we take for granted, has been shown, when we learn to control it, to be central to our physical wellbeing and, indeed, our spiritual transformation. However, this isn’t simply just breathing – if it was, we would all be fine now.  The object is to become consciously aware of breath.  There is no coincidence that there is a massive resurgence in popularity of breathwork given what we know.

Concluding thoughts

Suffering is a terrible reality of human existence. Spirituality helps us not only survive suffering differently, but helps us to recover from the physiological impact. When we do this, we can reconfigure our neurological patterns differently, allowing us to achieve the life we want.

Spirituality also helps us develop consciousness differently. Through learning about ourselves within spiritual practices, we can understand the existential reality of our life far better. The benefits of spiritual practices are, apart from the reasons cited above, vast. What is clear to me is that we need more spirituality in the world, not less.

I also include this because for those who work in the therapeutic world, there is an argument here for ensuring we maximise the chances of our client’s growth through the inclusion of spirituality. This is not to suggest we force-feed clients spirituality, but certainly offer the practices as additional benefits to what goes on in the room. I recommend we include attention to breath at all stages, encouraging clients to step out of flight/fight/freeze and thus ‘think’. I also advise the use of meditation work as much as possible, even if this is directing people to other resources.

Let me know what you think. Does spirituality help you in your life?

Much love,

Dr. Andrew x

Receive new essays

New pieces arrive infrequently and without filler. No newsletters about newsletters. Just writing, when there is something worth saying.