The Restless Mind
Blog

The problem of difference in therapy (and research)

1 Nov 2022·7 min read

I want to talk about the problem of difference in therapy today. I was just reading the latest edition of the Journal of the Society for Psychotherapy Research, and was horrified. In the first article, the findings from a mindfulness based intervention show that there are significant gaps in knowledge about efficacy of therapy for POC (people of colour). My point isn’t so much about mindfulness based interventions, but the lack of representation of POC participants in research. POC are just not robustly part of Psychotherapy research. And this troubled me for a whole raft of reasons.

Difference is not accounted for within research

Firstly, it troubles me because I know this is true. When I completed my doctoral research, I found that, of the 28 key studies I performed a metasynthesis on, virtually every quantitative study had a participant sample of 75% white women. What this means is that much of the data we have about therapy is gathered from white women. The difficulty with this pertains to how can we reliably extrapolate from data that is centred upon someone who doesn’t share our race, religion, gender, or age? Or anything else? I just don’t think we can. What will be helpful for an old Muslim POC asylum seeker, will not be the same for you.

Now, not only is the data we work from troubling, but the take up of therapy by POC is also lagging behind the white population. There are cultural reasons for this (e.g. community norms, religion, spirituality, integration), but there is a problem in not only how we think about therapy, but how it is sold to certain parts of our communities. And because of this, the development of the profession will remain disconnected from everyone it needs to serve unless massive change is effected.

The history of therapy

As you probably know, Psychotherapy was a product of the early part of the 21st Century. After people began to fall away from Freud, they developed new therapeutic approaches. Overall, these were developed by white men (Perls, Jung, Rogers etc). Therapy was developed from this male, white perspective, from men often in communication with each other. Inherent within that reality was a raft of infinitesimal presumptions, expectations, and cultural norms. I wouldn’t say this was entirely bad, it is what it is. However, one particular issue for me is the legacy of power.

As just a short example, within therapy, we pay to see a professional. We want them to help us to feel differently. Within that we see the therapist when they are available, pay what they demand, and leave when they are ready. This can be sometimes negotiated, but not often. We ultimately await their expertise, and we often idealise them, particularly at the beginning of therapy. And therapists know it. If the therapist is different to us – by virtue of their race, religion, or gender etc – this creates additional power differentials (and let’s face it, the therapist will always hold some level of difference). The spirit of the white man remains within the consulting room, regardless of how different or similar we are.

Studying psychotherapy

The transition of knowledge (another source of power) within psychotherapy is a peculiar one, especially how it relates to difference. The psychotherapists do very little of the actual research in the field, and this is rarely disseminated directly through to training institutes. Occasionally a researcher will visit an institute to teach people about their research. The majority of psychotherapy research is conducted by psychology or research students, and this research is often hugely discordant with what occurs in psychotherapy institutes and the consulting room. The inherent split is obvious and uncomfortable; this is another tension that requires fixing as a priority. The role of psychotherapist is very different, now, to the practice of psychotherapy.

Students of psychotherapy may now feel that they have more right to complain, to resist, to demand, but the fact remains – they also are part of an imbalanced system, where they are required to cooperate and comply within that system, or else they fail. Recently, one student in particular notoriously fell foul of this by articulating views contrary to their training institute, and lost their capacity to train. I share this because, even psychotherapy students (without commenting directly on this case), who we presume should be able to challenge and engage in conversations about difference, are essentially shut down. They can be different, but not that different.

Ironically, the issue of difference is so anxiety-provoking to us all, that we can only share the same ideology rather than share our difference. About the difference.

The problem with difference

Ultimately, it seems we are unable, or too scared, to engage in actual conversations about difference. The fear of what lies in our shadow is apparently too abominable to share. It seems as though the thought of reflecting openly on where we are regarding difference is too anxiety-provoking. I get this, people are cancelled, people lose their jobs, and people are afraid to be authentic in a situation where we need authenticity. But it is not ok.

Whereas in the consulting room we can offer opportunities to explore difference safely, we can’t do this outside the room. And so we cannot process the needs of the members of our community who may need support with working through issues that fall outside the realm of the accepted norms. Unless we can situate ourselves at the contact boundary, our shadow side can never be revealed. And this is a travesty. The ideology overrides relational contact. And I use ideology generally to indicate an inflexible position on difference.

Need for change

If we yield to the idealogical strands of thinking about difference, we close off ourselves to our whole field. I think it is more vital to be open and reflexive with the shadow side, than closed off. All of us discriminate, all of us are intolerant. For when we disown those parts, we act out of awareness, and worse, without the blessings of compassion and empathy. Our process, and our minds, also become split off. The separate parts function dissociatively. There is no wonder the world’s mental health is deteriorating so significantly.

And for a psychotherapist this fills me with fear. For when toxic parts of our inner process are circulating out of awareness, this leads to acting them out, potentially harming others in extreme ways. Expecting the paedophile to shut off those dangerous parts of himself and just be ‘normal’ will never permit him the opportunity of understanding both the inner mechanisms of his process and the toxic impact of his behaviour on others. Expecting the racist to just pretend she is not racist and to ‘be nice’, will never allow her to understand what her racism is about, the impact on others structurally and collectively, and risks her acting out when her pan boils over with bile. This retroflection retards the process of change.

Request to the world

It is vital that we value everyone, both as individuals and as communities of people. Most people who come in to therapy tend to get this. However, as a psychotherapist there is no role for choosing what our clients can bring in to the room, and what they cannot. We need to know the full field out there. There is a place for everyone, especially in therapy, and a concomitant need to manage the full process. This does not mean that you should accept or tolerate inappropriate or harmful behaviour from others – the person is separate to the behaviour and the views. This is an important difference to hold. We need to hold and share our processes, but safely, and in dialogue.

I believe that, as therapists, we should be leading the change that we need to see, through example and through teaching. If therapists can survive a five year clinical training, growing amidst such vast difference, we can do this. But we need places that are safe, where conversations actually happen, in real time, with real people. And where difference of view is embraced, understand, and tolerated; not shut down, shamed, or berated. Even if it is uncomfortable. You can’t help the homophobe if you won’t understand what they have to say.

The real change we need to see is not the place for trolls. For in that process of being seen, being heard, and being valued, people can develop empathy towards one another. They can know the other, not run in fear. And in doing so, recognise our infinite differences and sameness. And from there we have the potential to unite.

Much love,

Dr. Andrew x

Receive new essays

New pieces arrive infrequently and without filler. No newsletters about newsletters. Just writing, when there is something worth saying.