According to Greg Matos!
Today I noticed this article popping up in my feed, exploring the rise of single and lonely men. Being a man, I’m naturally interested in men’s issues, and decided to click on the link and read the article. To describe adequately how disappointed I was in what I read is hard. Not only was the article full of generalisations, it was lacking in rigour, depth, and clarity. Here’s why.
Generalising about entire populations
Firstly, I am extremely nervous about reading any writing that generalises across a whole population of people, whether that be women, man, non-binary, people of colour, or female Tibetan Buddhist monks over the age of 106. Generalisations lack clarity, meaning, and depth, and fail to capture the innate wondrousness of human uniqueness. And if you’re going to make such a generalisation, I think it’s helpful to cite a reliable source at least.
The source
So as I read this article, I noticed a number of glaring problems. Firstly, there are lots of people regardless of their gender who struggle in relationships. When we pigeonhole people into certain boxes this means that they often struggle to get back out of that box. I don’t think this is helpful. Nor is the reliance on statistics.
This is especially important here because Mr. Matos seems to use the idea of loneliness in men as an argument to chastising them as deficient. He recommends men, ‘Level up your mental health game’, attributing their reluctance to take up relationships with women as due to their ‘loneliness’.
I think there are also a lot of misconceptions regarding certain phenomena that the ‘psychologist’ reports. He claims that men report being lonely more frequently. However, the researchers note that the sample was not representative, and possibly only presents people who are willing to talk about loneliness. The problem may actually be worse. Or better. If the sample is unrepresentative, should we not be cautious about extrapolating?
Men in Dating Apps
Matos claims that men are more frequent users on dating apps, and attributes this to them being lonely. Whilst the research he cites – here – is about loneliness, there is no detail, and no qualitative exploration of what this actually means. Why are they reporting their loneliness? What contributes to this? The research states nothing, and the statistic, when unpicked, has little value or meaning. There is no cause and effect in studies such as this, and so from such a small, unrepresentative sample, we need to be highly cautious about extrapolating.
The loneliness issue is an important observation in itself, however. I certainly don’t dispute the statistic, although I would recommend we are all remain sceptical about what is claimed to be a statistic. Thus, whilst I don’t dispute that 62% of men are on dating apps, the presumption from the psychologist is that this is because they are all lonely and single and searching for partners. My immediate observation is that in reality most men on apps are not there to meet the love of their life, but to have sex.
Men and sex
Men’s primary motivation is to meet women to have sexual contact on apps(or hookups), without the emotional connection if possible.
Men’s sex drive is often underestimated and not understood. Men think about sex twice as much as women. Men are 30% more likely to engage in masturbation. Men are far more likely to agree to casual sex. Gay men in particular are more likely to have anonymous sex. We need to really factor in this component into understanding men’s behaviour of conduct on apps. Read and understand the research, but don’t make presumptions about what the ‘evidence’ means, if it is evidence at all.
Changing lifestyles
The other reason that fuels my position on men and dating apps, is that men are retreating from relationships more generally. It’s difficult to get more than anecdotal information, but it is certainly my experience right now. There are a wealth of men who are just choosing to avoid relationships, and it scares me that we are procreating less in a time when we need it more.
This trend is perhaps fuelled by the likes of Jordan Petersen. But the reality is that divorces are initiated 80% by women, and 45% of marriages end in divorce. Men only get custody of their children 10% of the time, but are responsible for alimony ALL of the time. How could this entice men in to marriage?
So, whilst men still have an attachment style, they still want to be in love, and to be loved, the system is rigged against them in ways which make the commitment unviable. Also, what hasn’t been factored in to this yet is the fact that men have, over the past 50 years, lost the footing from their very existence. Some of this is for good reasons. However, whilst the male roles have been taken away, the new way of being in relationships was never offered.
There is no wonder men are cautious and ambivalent about the risks to them in relationships. Thus, whilst singledom might be challenging in some ways, Apps that actually enable men to have sexual relations with consenting adults which doesn’t leave them financially destitute is, right now, the best option.
Final thoughts
I took umbrage at Matos, the author of this article, because this is actually a man, and a psychologist. He is one of us. And within what he writes I see him disowning that lonely part of himself and projecting it onto men, for political purposes. I also don’t think it is the job of therapists to effect social control and make men into what some people feel they want them to be.
Matos also writes from a position of superiority and I wonder what makes him so unimpeachable. He throws men under the bus, and uses the research to bull whip men in to being a particular way in relationships. If you tell men they’re single and lonely, this will become a self-fulfilling prophecy. I would’ve expected a psychologist to be aware of that.
I found that the article ultimately lacked any hope of possibility for change in men. When we malign someone because of a certain characteristic, they become stuck in that characteristic. In my 30 years of work with people, if you tell someone they’re bad, they will become bad. If you tell them they’re stupid, they will believe they’re stupid. We are impressionable, we are vulnerable to the introjective process (this is a Gestalt term, I talk about it here). Introjection is whereby we internalise the negative messages from our parents and they become part of our personality. If you tell men they’re bad and dysfunctional in relationships, they will fit that bill.
Moving forwards
What we need for men is not more ridicule, more isolation, and more ambivalence. We need to celebrate their contribution to the world, whilst challenging them to develop what they do. And to women. If we strengthen our men, help them learn how to relate to others in this brave new world, we offer them a lifeline. We also offer women lifelines, as they can also develop the way they relate to men in relationships.
None of us are perfect. Do we not want our children to have amazing parental role models? Do we not all want someone to love us? Is this not our fundamental human need? This isn’t about tolerating men’s problematic behaviours, but supporting their growth in a different way.
And as I write this I realise how much in love I am with my partner. That this is my reinforcement that men are able to love passionately, to be loved in return, and to forge out amazing relationships. And I know that my needs in this relationship probably won’t be very much different to the men’s needs in other relationships.
And I also know there are so many amazing men out there, actively trying to be great people, and relate to people with care and respect. Men are evolving. Our challenge is to not give ourselves away in the process. So men, don’t worry for two. We will get there.
Much love,
Dr. Andrew x