The Restless Mind
Blog

The secret to successful songwriting…

21 Apr 2024·7 min read

Good morning – it’s a grey, overcast day here in Sowerby Bridge. I have a photo shoot planned this afternoon on the moors of Haworth, so I’m hoping that rain won’t interfere! I don’t fancy dragging a harp on the moors in the rain. But I was sat here thinking about what I would write about today – and I came up with the secret to successful songwriting.

This isn’t because I think I know the perfect answer, but because I have a good sense of the characteristics that contribute to success. There isn’t just one thing we need to do, but a whole range of things. But regardless of whatever we do as individuals, there are bigger challenges required. Here’s why.

Practice makes perfect

I think that, if you’re planning on writing that hit song without any previous thought or experience, go ahead. However, I think huge success is unlikely. Whilst I wouldn’t want to pop your balloon of hope, few hit songs emerge on a whim. Whilst an idea may come in the middle of the night for you, there will always be a process of thought and re-thought as the song develops.

Edwina Hayes says that she continues to develop songs, sometimes on stage. She may change a word or phrase where required so it can be tested out in real time. This process of planning and review is really a helpful one. What might sound ok in our own studio may just not sound the same in front of someone else. A song doesn’t have to be a final product – most writers return to their baby’s over time. And most are the product of thought. I continuously re-write mine, even if adding different instruments.

The daily gym

I think the best song-writers are those who are doing this every single day. Those people who have a notebook with them, and who may write a line or riff as they’re waiting in the car for their child to come out of class. Or who meet with others every week to regularly pick up the pen and write. Bob Dylan, the master songwriter, has written for most of his adult life, and continues to write. Definitely follow his example!

The song-writing muscle requires nourishment, care, and usage. So I advise you to invite song-writing in to your life; embrace her daily, think about her always, and love her. If you don’t like song-writing, or feel you can do something else, then definitely do that. Write songs because it is who you are, not who you think you need to be.

A warning against AI

It is very easy to put a search in to chatGPT and you will get a result. You have probably searched ‘songwriting online’ already. Try it yourself, and type in ‘write a hit song’. And you may be tempted to use the lyrics, or potential chord progression. What I found is that the lyrics are often artificial, weird, and a bit out of kilter with what I’m writing. If anything, I think AI could maybe help you get unstuck from Block, but little else.

I imagine that, sometime in the next decade, it may be possible for AI to create programmes to write us beautiful songs that it knows we will love to hear. But we aren’t there yet. Here’s a search I put in just now, ‘write a three verse folk song about the sea’, and here’s the result:


Oh, the sea, the restless sea, Where waves roll wild and free, Beneath the sun’s warm golden gaze, And winds sing ancient melodies.

(Chorus) Oh, sailors brave and fishermen true, Their hearts belong to the ocean blue, With salt-stained decks and tales untold, In the sea’s embrace, they find their gold.

(Verse 2) When twilight paints the sky above, And stars emerge like lights of love, The sea whispers secrets to the shore, Of distant lands and legends of yore.

(Chorus) Oh, sailors brave and fishermen true, Their hearts belong to the ocean blue, With salt-stained decks and tales untold, In the sea’s embrace, they find their gold.(Verse 3)

(Verse 3) Through storms that rage and tempests roar, The sea calls out forevermore, A siren’s song that haunts the soul, Where mysteries dwell and dreams unfold.

(Chorus) Oh, sailors brave and fishermen true, Their hearts belong to the ocean blue, With salt-stained decks and tales untold, In the sea’s embrace, they find their gold.

(Outro) So raise a toast to the mighty sea, To her boundless depths and majesty, For she holds within her timeless grace, A world of wonder, a sacred place.

As you can see, it’s a perfectly legible and coherent folk song about the sea. I think the language is ok, albeit a little dated. But it could certainly help you get unstuck if you were in Block, so let’s not write it off in entirety.

The personal nature of song-writing

Poetry itself has always been an oral tradition. Poems and folk songs in particular were always passed down orally. This is why they often vary so often. But it is because humans like to hear someone talk/sing, that they remain popular. And this is possibly why chart and highly produced songs lose popularity – they are inviting and exciting, but cannot be repeated in real time on a stage.

And I don’t believe that AI could ever truly replace that magic of humanity. In my other job as psychotherapist, this is the same issue – computerised therapy has its uses, but falls way short of the human connection necessary for healing.

So I would encourage you to remain true to you. Use AI carefully, and remember that – in art anyway – AI is now logging its output (check some of my videos where I use some AI-generated artwork). This means that you may fall prey to copyright issues at some juncture, so be safe, and leave a trail of your own process. Writing by hand may become fashionable again!

Songwriting and Coolness

This is another concept that requires attention. Bob Dylan was probably always cool, so wrote cool songs that people love. Cher probably isn’t considered cool (sorry Cher), but she is unique and her songs fit with her. Madonna is manufactured and neurotic, and her songs reflect this. Lady GaGa is rich, inspiring, and vulnerable. Her songs are.

The point of this is that your songs are your DNA. Write who you are not who you think you need to be. I use to write songs that I thought people wanted to hear, but I was wrong. The songs were incongruous with me. My challenge – as is yours – is to always write songs that are from your soul. If the song is true to you, you are a success. It might be that the world isn’t ready for you, but you have been true to you. And who knows what could happen after your death? Curiouser things have happened…

Writing and popularity

The final thing to remember is that you can write as many songs as you want, but if you never let people hear them, they will die a lonely death. I encourage you to try to avoid writing for writing sake – be heard, be seen, take a risk, and develop the skill of being seen.

Songs are for hearing, even if your audience is your Dad and two dogs. If they love your songs, you have won. And if you get the confidence to sing in the local pub, then do that too. If you don’t get thrown off the stage, you have won that audience too.

Another few wise words from Edwina Hayes is around this same issue. She performed after the first day she went to a folk club. She says she would perform anywhere, sometimes in dodgy venues, and sometimes for very low fees. But she is a natural, highly skilled professional performer and songwriter, with a long track record of delivering. There is something powerful to be learnt from her.

Final thoughts

I hope I have introduced you to a few ideas for approaching your songwriting. There are other resources out there promising a panacea or a formula for great songs, but there isn’t one. The formula is you, and what you allow to emerge from your own songwriting process.

The challenge is that, if you’re not writing, you’re not developing. Olympic gymnasts don’t become great through sitting at home. They get in the gym, they practice, they fall, and they get up again. I encourage you to do the same.

And if you want to write with me sometime, get in touch, and let’s do this! And please, I have three little gingers to provide for, so a share and a like will benefit us greatly.

Mucho love,

Andrew x

Receive new essays

New pieces arrive infrequently and without filler. No newsletters about newsletters. Just writing, when there is something worth saying.