The Restless Mind
Blog

What is happening within the therapeutic field?

25 Oct 2021·7 min read

What is happening within the therapeutic field? This is a question that seems to be quite relevant nowadays. In fact, the therapeutic industry is replete with a multitude of therapies. Often clients do not know if they are getting either a counsellor or a psychotherapist, what the modality means, or understand the difference between the two. Most professionals increasingly refer to themselves as ‘therapists’, which is a catch all term that anyone can use.

Clients seeing therapists in the NHS generally don’t see people registered in any of the regulatory professions, as they are often trained in ‘NHS therapies’. Some people definitely see some roles as better than the others, and this has come in to focus more clearly within the SCoPEd process. This is creating an hierarchy of provision.

Ultimately, how a member of the public finds someone to meet their needs within this confusing process, I do not know. And that issue, let me tell you, is my priority.

Perceptions of the two titles

There is certainly an hierarchy between the roles of psychotherapist and counsellor, with one being seen as better than the other in some quarters. It is likely that this tension has resulted in the current muddying of the water, with counselling trainings adding ‘psychotherapy’ in to its course materials (presumably as a money-making exercise – by widening the scope, they get more applicants). However, the two roles have not completely merged.

In the background, there is also the hybrid role of psychotherapeutic counsellor. This is a role which seems to occupy the middle ground between the counsellor and psychotherapist. I am open to not understanding this properly. Obviously some medical professionals such as psychiatrists and nurses also train in psychotherapy, as do psychologists, and so choose their own preferred title – i.e. counselling psychologist.

Does this matter to clients?

In reality, there is a difference between the three or four primary terms, and in my opinion it is vital we understand and address this difference in order to ensure clients can make informed decisions about support. Whilst the differences may be ok to us, it is less meaningful for many clients. And it is very different starting therapy with someone who has only done a three day training (such as in the NHS), compared to someone who has done a four year psychotherapy training independently. And even though the evidence suggests the kind of therapy is irrelevant to change anyway (change is all about the relationship), there does seem to be a need to tease out the differences in profession.

In order to accomplish this, I will present my understanding of the differences and similarities, situate this within the need for greater professional accountability, and explore the issues of complexity and length of work which underpins the issue of identity.

My understanding

Fifteen years or so ago, there was a furore in the psychotherapy world. The Department Of Health decided to recruit a minister to start the process of statutory regulation of the profession. The minister found herself awash with contact from the profession, who successfully managed to resist the attempt for statutory regulation, and retained autonomy of their own profession. This was a landmark win for psychotherapists.

I was still in training to be a psychotherapist at the time, and was amazed with how assertive the profession could be collectively. The Government definitely bit off more than it could chew. The Government again attempted to pursue statutory regulation in 2020 via various Private Members’ Bills (for everyone in the therapeutic industry), but it was again acknowledged (by Lord Bethel) that:

While statutory regulation is sometimes necessary where significant risks to users of services cannot be mitigated in other ways, it is not always the most proportionate or effective means of assuring the safe and effective care of service users.

Lord Bethel

This meant that the industry continues to regulate itself (within the professional standards’ framework).

However, the challenge in this currently is that anyone can continue to identify as any title. Whilst registration with a particular body may not be possible, they can still advertise themselves as, say, a psychotherapist, without completing a UKCP accredited psychotherapy training. For example, a qualified psychotherapeutic counsellor or psychotherapist can only join UKCP via an organisational member initially, before becoming a Direct Member. Anyone can join the BACP if they pass the entrance examination and provide evidence of a minimum level of training. Thus, there is clearly a difference between how the regulatory bodies regulate their members.

SCoPEd

As a result of the difference in expertise and training, the industry began its own mapping of training requirements and practice standards via the SCoPEd project (Scope of Practice and Education for the counselling and psychotherapy professions) in 2016. Currently, the project consists of seven partner organisations, and has appointed an ‘independent’ chair. The project has been controversial because of the perceived hierarchical nature of the SCoPEd ladder, and the BACP in particular has received much negativity on social media as a result.

Rightly or wrongly, this process will impact pay and conditions as a result of its future implementation, and some commissioners inevitably will be more inclined towards one category of professional as opposed to others. And whilst this interminable process chunters on, the public remain confused and unclear about what they are paying for outside of the NHS. In fact, the ever-increasing range of trendy therapies within the NHS adds to this confusing process, with clients coming for particular therapies as opposed to professions. This is important as shouldn’t the professionals be able to choose the right therapy for the right client?

Differences in training

For information purposes I could usefully map out the differences in trainings here. So here goes. Firstly, there is the issue of length of training. Most MA counselling programmes are for two years, three years with a dissertation, and generally require between 6-20 hours personal counselling and 100 client hours. Psychotherapy trainings are generally postgraduate diplomas, increasingly becoming Masters’ programmes, and require a minimum of 40 hours personal therapy each year of the four year training, and 450 client hours. This is a substantially different investment, and someone who has had their own extensive therapy is very different to someone who has had just a few sessions. On this basis, it is clear why SCoPEd have focused on training requirements as opposed to just experience.

Most masters programmes (as I have already indicated), run over two years. Psychotherapy training programs run over four years as a minimum, sometimes five. This means that the psychotherapists are exposed to far more material, over a greater length of time. One would expect that psychotherapists should have a greater depth of knowledge in the subject, and the greater range of techniques and skills that they have learnt during the four years. This is why psychotherapists will be in ‘column C’ (pending agreement on title).

It is sad that the NHS does not see that all three professions are able to work competently and professionally, and usefully within that organisation. And also to assess whichever therapy is seen to be more helpful at whatever juncture.

Next Steps

We await the outcome from the SCoPEd process. We have been waiting six years now, and there is no immediate end in sight. I can’t imagine that the titles will be any different to:

  1. Column A – Counsellor

2. Column B – Psychotherapeutic Counsellor

3. Column C – Psychotherapist

In a way, the process really hasn’t added anything substantial to the field. Many of us will just go on as we have done for decades. There may well be a difference in commissioning practices, but increasingly, the NHS only supports its own kind of therapies rather than professions anyway. In a way it is all wind and water. The public will continue to invest in their own therapy based on whether or not the therapist is registered, affordable, and likeable.

I am not aware of the NHS being part of the SCoPEd process, and I am not aware of any commitment from the NHS to start commissioning people based on title rather than individual therapy. I think that the NHS does need to stop being a lone ranger and get involved with the discussion. But that complex issue is for another time!

Final Words

The bottom line is that, regardless of what you want to call the therapist, they are only one small part of a client’s overall recovery journey. The SCoPEd process has taken six years already.

However, let’s just not get too caught up in talking about differences. Therapy will be one big investment for clients, but this only entails one session a week in general. A client’s journey will need to factor in the other 168 hours each week for a comprehensive recovery – read my book for ways in which to complement your recovery journey using well-evidenced strategies.

Much love,

Dr. A x

Receive new essays

New pieces arrive infrequently and without filler. No newsletters about newsletters. Just writing, when there is something worth saying.