This is an important question that can come up in therapy. Indeed, there is an urban legend that circulates around the therapeutic world, whereby people are ‘broken down’ before being ‘built back up’. But is this true and/or inevitable? But will therapy make you feel worse? Here’s my thoughts.
Range of feelings
Given the range of feelings we experience in any given hour, it is more than likely you will feel the negative affective experiences as well as the positives. We have seven affective systems, referred to the Seven Pankseppian Affective Systems. In reality, you could feel any one of them before, after, or during therapy. Unfortunately, Psychotherapists are not yet to be able to ensure all clients feel entirely positively at all times. And do we want you to only feel, say, happiness? Wouldn’t the world be a fairly weird place if we all felt ecstatic constantly?
Impact of exposure
However, there is something in the issue of opening trauma, or ‘exposure’ in the industry. Exposure refers to the revisiting of the early trauma in the here and now, although it can also mean opening someone to something they fear. This can, to some, feel re-traumatising, and is the basis of some therapies in current times. The impact of exploring exposure and not exposing has been studied variously. I would generously say that the jury is still out on its efficacy. However, exposure is still firmly embedded within the majority of psychotherapies.
What this means is that, if you want to heal from the early trauma, you need to understand it, and this will involved revisiting the trauma. However, the skill of the clinician is to ensure the trauma is revisited in a way that you can withstand. If you are feeling continually traumatised, this possibly isn’t the case, so needs exploring with your therapist. We only meet for 50 minutes a week generally, so feedback will help ensure the work is regulated at a way that suits you.
Self-awareness
However, there is also the issue of self-awareness. Therapy’s primary currency is self-awareness. We know that self-awareness leads to change, and change is our currency, as I discussed here. In the process of developing realisation about yourself, there is the risk that you uncover or realise things that feel depressing, saddening, or anxiety-provoking. This is normal.
The challenge is, again, to ensure the pace of the realisation fits you and your needs. Inevitably at times this won’t always be a fit, as we are, again, humans, and who knows what will be uncovered? But, the challenge is to, again, explore this in relationship with the therapist, so the therapy can be modified. This is also important if you feel the pace is dragging, and you are getting stuck.
Overall though, self-awareness is the key to transforming your life, so we need to utilise the insights productively. But without you getting wiped out.
The nature of change
Change is discombobulating. The brain doesn’t like change, and needs encouragement. My suggestion is, again, to ensure the change is slow and steady, enacted within in a safe relationship. Your therapist is there to guide you gently and robustly through that process. They will understand the process of change, and should be invested in yours.
Inevitability
But is it inevitable therapy will make you feel worse? On the balance of the above, there is a risk of feelings dipping, rising, and flowing. This is normal. There is a possibility that you will learn things about yourself that you don’t like. But should we avoid those parts? Do you not want your growth to include your shadow parts?
My suggestion is that, whatever comes up for you in therapy, your first point of call is to share it with your therapist. They should hear the observations you are making, and respond to that respectfully and with skill. If they don’t, then something is awry in the therapy, not you. And remember that you call the shots with the material you share. If you don’t want to go somewhere, don’t go. Choose the topic for each session carefully, being attuned to your needs as a person.
Final Words
Most therapists have and should have completed their own course of therapy over 4-5 years. This means they will have gone in to their own shadow parts, and come out stronger. The perils of inappropriate change usually results from less experience of change in self. Check this out with your therapist. Do you really want to do work with someone who hasn’t done their own?
And if I recall my own therapeutic journey, all of these themes also fit for me too. But I’m better for the upset, and certainly stronger. And remember, therapy could, overall, be the key to your overall transformation. I hope this becomes the case for you.
Much love,
Dr. Andrew x