Why change is important (to me)
I have been thinking a lot about the notion of change lately. This makes sense, as I’m a therapist, and thus, an agent of change. Change is my currency, and I am passionate about effecting change, in myself and others. If you’re a therapist, you’ll hopefully agree that our clients pay us to help them become different in their lives. Commissioners pay us to effect change in clients referred to us. Therefore, I thought it would be helpful to explore how to understand change, look at defining it, and offer some suggestions on how to achieve it.
If you’re a client, you may or may not have thought about what change could look like for you in such depth. This is normal. We don’t always know what the end goal is in our journey of growth. Nor do we always want to think that a different life is possible. Hopefully, though, you will also be able to get something from this discussion.
I am also aware of the biological-neurological processes that underpin change. We can discuss this another time – this article is about practical ways of thinking about and effecting change.
Defining change
The definitions of change are various. Change is essentially when something becomes different; we do, act, or feel something different from what we normally or routinely do, act, or feel. Change can be as obvious as the leaves changing colour in autumn, or decorating our house a different colour. It can also be about us acting and relating to people in massively different ways that they might not immediately be aware of.
As therapists or healers (regardless of your modality), our currency is change. Indeed, our clients come to us to feel differently, act differently, and have a different sense of life for themselves. This expectation can be direct, indirect, and spoken or unspoken. Change can be articulated verbally by a client finishing a session (‘I understand it differently’), or formally recorded by a client on a questionnaire (i.e. scoring less in levels of distress than previously). However, change can also be observed by us as therapists, and passed to us through third party information, (i.e. a residential worker reports a client acting in a way not seen previously).
The nature of change
Some changes are permanent, and some are more transitory. Some changes are minor such as feeling slightly less anxious, and other changes are huge, as in a relationship breakdown, or experiencing the death of a loved one. A parent may begin to relate differently to their child for a few days by not reacting when the child raises their voice, but resort to shouting thereafter. Someone may give up smoking and never return to the habit. This tension between sustaining changes is often the challenge we face as therapists – most people can, in good faith, make some fairly dramatic changes very quickly, i.e. a diet, but may not be able to maintain them for lengths of time.
Research on forming habits
In the European Journal of Social Psychology, it was reported that, Phillippa Lally and colleagues from University College, London, recruited 96 people who were interested in forming a new habit such as eating a piece of fruit with lunch or doing a 15 minute run each day (Lally et al., 2009). Participants were then asked daily how automatic their chosen behaviours felt. The questions included things like whether the behaviour was ‘hard not to do’ and could be done ‘without thinking’. When the researchers examined the different habits, many of the participants showed a curved relationship between practice and automaticity. On average a plateau in automaticity was reached after 66 days. This suggests that it takes 66 days to fully assimilate something new. We change after a couple of months of daily practising something.
Applying research in practice
For some of you, that may be sobering. In therapy, we often drop suggestions or ideas that seem important at the time. I myself have suggested that someone just ‘breathe’, or ‘listen to their body’. Both are vital in developing self-awareness. However, in doing so, I fail to fully assimilate the fact that, in order to systematically become more attuned to our bodily processes, using the logic above, it would require us to tune in daily to raise our awareness. What distractions do our clients have in their lives that get in the way of thinking about their bodily processes? How do they experience this? What would it be like for them trying to do this? Do you understand the nature of forming habits?
Also, whilst it may be feel we have developed a new awareness in a therapy session, how can we be assured our client has retained it until next time? How many times do we review what has gone before? Should we? I guess the person-centred school of thought would claim we shouldn’t do this if we take the client out of their frame of reference – does this mean there is never any comprehensive review of the client’s goals or the work? Seemingly even thinking about change has its complexities.
Moving in to habit formation
We do know lots about habit formation though. The behaviouralists suggest that, in order to build upon new habits, we should stack new habits on to those we already do. If we need to start taking a new medication, we should take it when we take other medications that we have been taking for a while. For myself, as I do yoga each morning, I slotted in some mindfulness practice afterwards, and this felt very accessible and doable; the kind of change, and placement during the day, is important.
There is also the issue of sizing. We shouldn’t attempt a regime change overnight. Whilst we may want to eat a healthy diet, the way to do this manageably is to make almost unnoticeable changes, and do it every day – leave a spoonful of food on the plate each day if we are reducing portion sizes. Don’t expect to learn a musical instrument in a year, but practice an hour a day, every day, and progress will happen.
I also encourage my clients to scale their goals – if you want to manage the agoraphobia differently, don’t expect to get out of the house ‘normally’ within a week, but spend a minute out of the house each day. Increase surreptitiously over time, and you will see and sustain the changes.
Obstacles to change
Another key factor in change is the notion of obstacles. Much of our work as therapists is about helping clients think about the internal and external barriers to change. If we want to have a better relationship with our child, but our partner prevents this through contact, we need to resolve the partner issue beforehand. If you want to stop drinking, but have drink in the house, remove the drink. Obstacles are often practical issues that get in the way of our good intentions.
I am writing about obstacles to change very briefly here, but the obstacles can be challenging. If our partner does not want to see us independent and in work, but the partner means a lot to us, this can leave us deeply stuck. This is why the process of change needs to be approached realistically and steadily. A more truculent issue can be motivation.
Motivation
Motivation is the process that initiates, guides, and maintains behaviours. Our motivation can be thought of as that which causes you to act, whether it is getting a glass of water to reduce thirst or reading a book to gain knowledge. We are motivated to do or have something which will bring us a perceived reward. In therapy, this may simply be a client coming to therapy for help. It may be a parent wanting to stop smacking their child (child protection issue being separate to the purposes of this article), or the above client with agoraphobia wishing to get out of the house.
Again, there are grades of motivation. At one level we might want to complete an examination, but are ok with just an average grade. I am currently working through my music examinations, but I have no intention to achieve a distinction, and will be happy with a simple pass. For myself, the joy is in the practice and accomplishing a piece of music, not the grade that someone sees fit to label me with on the day. Alternatively, if you are a parent whose children have been removed by a local authority, you may desire nothing else but to do everything that is required of you in order for the local authority to withdraw. Again, scaling motivation is helpful – I am a 6 in my music, the parent facing removal of their children may be a strong 10.
The nature of motivation
Some motivations are organised as intrinsic and extrinsic motivations (Hockenbury and Hockenbury, 2010). Extrinsic motivations may be passing your driving test so you can get a new job. Intrinsic motivations may be the joy of completing a cross word, or the feeling of satisfaction when you have eaten an amazing meal that you have cooked. Some writers refer to three components of motivation; activation, persistence (that old word again), and intensity. Activation being the decision to start something (a client coming to therapy); persistence is the continued effort to achieve a goal (client continuing to attend therapy so they can affect change in their emotional processing); intensity is the concentration and effort in achieving the goal – me practicing once a day for an hour, compared to an undergraduate practising daily for 8 hours prior to a recital (Tranquillo and Stecker, 2016).
Obviously, you can see that lots of these components are interlinked; ultimately, motivation arises out of internal and external factors, with a fairly important chunk of physiological processes such as pleasure, desire, and fear. I personally think that this is an important component that we sometimes miss – much of our behaviour has physiological components; if we are struggling with fear, we have to approach changing this through a combination of physiological and cognitive solutions.
So, we have talked about habit forming, which is an integral part of change. We then linked this to motivation to change. Motivation is multi-faceted and complex, and thus challenging to provide a quick fix solution. However, if a client is in therapy, especially private therapy where the client is paying, one could safely assume that there is motivation present. There are also lots of motivation tools out there than can assist us in measuring motivation. Use at your leisure.
Maintaining change
The final point I want to mention is the maintenance of change. This refers to stage five of the cycle of change (Prochaska & Velicer, 1997). Whilst this is a helpful model, it is particularly ‘cognitive’, dry, and lacking in accessibility in some ways. Maintenance, however, ultimately refers to the challenge in not slipping back into old habits. It is where we maintain the daily yoga practice, continue to refrain from smoking, and maintain our relationships with our children. In short, it refers to a continued commitment to maintaining change.
Most people, even if they love the change they made, can fall prey to slippage. Even though I began my daily yoga practice 30 years ago, it hasn’t always followed a set pattern; sometimes I flow for many months, working hard and effortlessly; sometimes I struggle to stay on the mat for more than twenty minutes, with numerous aches and pains and resistance, which I need to battle. But I try to remember my original motivation, I remind myself of the benefits of practice, and essentially coach myself to increase the practice and develop it wherever pertinent. This is the same for change in therapy.
Maintaining change and avoiding slippage
Some of us may wish to relate better to people. Therapy may help us understand how we function in those relationships. Therapy may also lead us to develop a motivation to do something different, and the therapist may offer feedback and suggestions on how to go about this. The therapist may also monitor our progress, and support us when things are difficult. We may well begin our determinations well; we may breeze in to meetings, and try to relate differently to others. We may well maintain it for a number of months. But after a six months or so, we may notice our determination lacking. We may begin to question our superiors more, and we may decide to justify our behaviour through other people’s. And in no time at all, we find ourselves back at the beginning, feeling isolated, lonely, and miserable.
The magic of change
Finally, there is magic in the change process. So many processes in ourselves and our being change without any obvious reason. Suddenly we may wake up feeling clear about a problem that has bothered us for months; we may go off a certain type of food without an explanation. This may result from metaphysical, transpersonal processes, or simply prayer. I share this because science often persuades us that it holds the only answer, and if science hasn’t rubber stamped it, it is not worth anything. I urge you to question this stance, and remember that we know so little about our minds, that anything we do claim to know, there are probably a zillion other positions on the same point.
For those of you who have been in therapy previously, you will also recognise that often you felt differently, or did things differently, without a clear obvious sense of why. Many times I have myself wondered why I felt so special after such a connection, or wondered how I achieved so much clarity in the time between sessions, as my mind just unfurled. This is what I refer to as the magic of change; sometimes things just happen, and it is vital we remain open to this possibility. If we are closed to magic in therapy, magic will definitely never happen. Yes, that’s right, Magic.
Tips to activate your change
So here are some tips for both activating change, sustaining habits, and maintaining hard fought change. Please also see the diagram which illustrates what I’m talking about, and hopefully, how you’re reading it.
1. Manage your expectations. Rome wasn’t built in a week. It’s ok to take your time.
2. Scale your goals. Start with the most miniscule, almost imperceptible changes, and build from there. The original reward will trigger more change.
3. Remember change takes time – that old 66 days of daily practice is an important one to consider.
4. Changes will slip in future months. Revisit your motivations, your dreams, and the pleasure you had in achieving your goals. Re-evaluate your goals, and do what you need to do.
5. Cultivate motivation – add extrinsic and intrinsic factors wherever possible.
Hockenbury DH, Hockenbury SE. Discovering Psychology. Macmillan; 2010.
Lally, P., Jaarsveld, C.H.M., Potts, H.W.W., Wardle, J. (2009) “How are habits formed: Modelling habit formation in the real world.” European Journal of Social Psychology, 40:6
Tranquillo J, Stecker M. Using intrinsic and extrinsic motivation in continuing professional education. Surg Neurol Int. 2016;7(Suppl 7):S197-9. doi:10.4103/2152-7806.179231