Now, being someone who works in the field of change, this is an area of thinking that I want to tread carefully with. This is because there is a big difference between the notion of transformation and change, and the two can merge. Also, that there is a difference between offering realistic expectations to a client, and selling them something that just isn’t realistic, for anyone. Thus, I will write about the myth of transformation, offering some clarity about what is achievable within therapeutic encounters.
The myth of transformation as sold by the great Salespeople
I was listening to an Oprah Winfrey podcast yesterday. Bishop TD Jakes was on the show, espousing everything transformation. He is both an inspired and inspiring speaker, and knows how to whip up a crowd. I could hear people yelling and hollering every other sentence. I felt, after a few minutes, a tad confused. It began to seem as though the audience were his followers rather than people simply watching someone speak about their beliefs and values. The yells were bordering on the hysterical, inevitably moved by God and/or TD Jakes.
I also began noticing his use of the word ‘transformation’, and he was clearly selling a potent, compelling brand of Christianity. He was making huge but vague promises, and the audience loved it. Indeed, his various books also sell the idea that the ‘greatest breakthrough you will ever have’ is from the new identity in Christ. This is all well and good, especially to those of us already sold to the power of God. However, I am left with the question, is such a powerful transformation such as that espoused by the likes of TD Jakes (and there are MANY more promising this) actually possible or realistic? Let me give you a few of my ideas.
The physiology of trauma
Firstly, there are always miraculous ‘cures’ and changes that science can’t explain. I take this as the bottom line, with careful consideration of the evidence, and a further pinch of salt. However, for most of us the reality is that the hurt we experienced in childhood will have caused physiological patterns in our body and brain. Pre-clinical and clinical studies have both shown traumatic stress to impact memory, as well as cause circuit changes in the frontal cortex, the amygdala, and the hippocampus. A secure attachment has been shown to inoculate individuals from future damage, but the pathways exist.
If we consider the issue of chronic neglect on brain development, we can find the scans below. What these show is how badly our brains are affected by inappropriate, poor, or just abusive parenting.
However, for someone whose brain is so badly affected by trauma – whatever the source – a full recovery is never going to be possible. We know this through the likes of feral children such as Genie Wiley, who, despite endless support and care, never fully learnt how to speak or move as well as their peers. Hopefully this will change with scientific research, but it is where we are right now.
The possibility for growth
However, even in the extreme case cited above, change did occur, albeit on a more conservative level that we would want. Indeed, there is evidence that supports the idea that change can occur, even in older adulthood. In fact, the wish to change personality characteristics is known to also positively impacts emotional well-being. It is those personality characteristics that are usually the way we adapted to difficulties in children, that no longer serve us well as adults. So change is possible, but depends also upon motivation.
So let’s not be a Doubting Thomas. We can change, regardless of age, although the issue is the level of change. How much can we expect to change? Firstly the issue is whether you are rigid or malleable; both are vital to think about. If you are rigid, you need to focus more upon self-discovery, such as that through therapy. If you are malleable, self-improvement is the way forwards. This means that people can change, but not necessarily that they WILL.
James, the ‘groundbreaking’ Harvard psychologist wrote in 1890, The Principles of Psychology. This is thought to be the first time that modern psychology observed the idea that personality settles down, or stabilises, in adulthood. “In most of us, by the age of thirty, the character has set like plaster, and will never soften again,” reads one of its most quoted lines. However, subsequent research is reviewing this. We now know that, whilst our core personality may remain the same, therapy can support change throughout our personality.
My view
I have worked in the field of change for thirty years. My experience is that people can change how they relate to others. This improves wellbeing when we feel more confident in having our needs met. People can also change factors in their environment, such as jobs and relationships. This also improves wellbeing, especially if we reduce stressors within that process.
Indeed, we do bandy about the notion of ‘characterological transformation‘ in the field. However, this may not be as huge as one would either imagine or want. In fact, change takes time, concerted effort, and some level of optimism in the possibility. So transformation is possible, but not in one swift visit to a miracle worker. And this is not to diminish the ‘a-ha’ moments we all get.
In my clinic I see people change over years rather than months. Habits themselves take over 90 days to form, and that is for just one new way of doing something. If we want a raft of changes to occur in our lives, we also need to factor in the reality that this will take time.
Miracle workers
I don’t doubt that the likes of TD Jakes can help people feel different, but I imagine that this is often about a heightened arousal in the presence of his seminars. I reluctantly doubt that people change so dramatically, so quickly, as opposed to a sustained, sustainable process.
So the issue for me isn’t about transformation. We can transform. There is no myth in this. What we can’t do (yet) is do it in the way of the miracle worker. You are unlikely to wake up tomorrow with your entire existence changed. Growth will occur, but it will take time, determination, and commitment to yourself.
The role of spirituality in change
I mentioned TD Jakes specifically because he promotes the role of God in our change process. I am actually on board with him on this. If we focus simply on the mind within therapeutic encounters, we shut down or deny the possibility of the transpersonal elements to support change. Perhaps controversially, humans don’t know everything. Being spiritual, even engaging in religious organisations where that fits for us, is known to not only kick start our change process, but also sustain it. And even though miracles are unlikely, should we shut out the possibility?
I guess my ambivalence about ‘transformation’ is the role of setting up unrealistic expectations for clients. Like most professionals, I want people to know what they’re getting. I don’t want to factor in disappointment to what should be a growthful process.
Finally, in my book, Nine Steps to Health, Strength and Happiness, I offer nine different ways in which we can kickstart our own spiritual growth process. These are well-evidenced steps, and they can complement whatever you’re doing in therapy yourself. I know they work, because they worked for me.
Why not start your process of change today?
Much love,
Dr. Andrew x
Facebook Twitter