The Restless Mind
Book Reviews

Let’s review ‘Friendish’

12 Sep 2022·4 min read

Good morning. I hope you are all excited about the imminent emergency of autumn, and all that it brings with it. I am especially looking forward to Mabon celebrations at the end of September, and also the arrival of Halloween. Obviously, it’s not just about the hot chocolate or pumpkin pie! Anyway, images of autumnal wreaths aside, let’s review Kelly Needham’s Friendish. I hope you find it helpful.

Format

It’s a short read, of only 97 pages. The covers are flexible, and it feels nice to turn the smooth pages. the cover design is accessible and clean, with a small blob of paint in primary colours, and some written insight in to the content below. There are ten chapters, but no list of chapters, meaning you have to flick through a lot.

Title

The title is intriguing. I am not sure if I missed something, but I’m still not sure what it means. She talks about ‘friendships’, but I don’t understand the leap to ‘friendish’. I had hoped for some clarity. Was this just a play on the sound of words, or to create a word that would suck readers in, just for the sake of it? I guess the jury’s out.

Content

The book is essentially a workbook. The material is largely comprised of questions about your friendships, from the context of Christianity. The book’s focus, therefore, is specific and maintained throughout. This book does not seem to be for non-Christians. In fact, some of the questions specifically ask about mistakes in community with others instead of Jesus.

In this sense then, the content is unequivocally Christian. Needham single-mindedly frames and refers all the content to Jesus Christ. I guess if you are a non-Christian then this book will be less accessible. For the book requires a Christian lifestyle and practice for it to be of benefit. In this way the book is exclusionary.

In offering a book that just asks questions, you never fully have a sense of any content. Asking questions for people to reflect on is helpful, but a full book of questions seems over-kill. I would have liked more from Needham on her philosophy and approach to religion. More importantly, how she believes we can develop our friendships in spiritual ways.

Analysis

If I’m honest, I haven’t read much fundamental Christian material, and I was taken aback by most of the content. In particular, the terminology is often shaming and blaming, and we are reminded of the need to avoid, for example, idolatry as it leads to disordered desires. What Needham was referring to was idealising – in fact, this is a helpful, important part of many friendships, albeit unsustainable, but does not inevitably lead to ‘disordered desires’.

It seems as though Needham’s position is specific and intractable. The tone is also shaming and relentlessly harsh, whereas I would have hoped for more optimism and love from a spiritual practitioner. It is ok to forgive and encourage, regardless of your religious views.

Whilst I agree with the content around God being our saving grace, there is no freedom to think about what God may mean to us on an individual basis. God is only seen from the Christian viewpoint. I think Needham would have done better to open up the understanding of God, and provide different ways of thinking about him. In turn, this may have provided more ways of exploring God as a basis for understanding and creating friendships. It may also have increased her readership.

Conclusion

I wouldn’t be able to recommend this book, as I recommend books that are suitable for as many people as possible. This book is only suitable for those on, or at least considering the Christian path. Whilst being and practicing Christianity is a commendable thing in itself, I don’t think that attributing loneliness to deficiencies in making friendships to be appropriate. For my audience at least.

I also think that, primarily, the workbook doesn’t offer us any pragmatic understanding of friendship, which is disappointing. I would have loved for lots of helpful and accessible ways of developing friendships, rather than just asking leading questions from a fundamentalist position. I hate saying that, but need to be honest.

What do you think?

Much love,

Dr. Andrew x

Receive new essays

New pieces arrive infrequently and without filler. No newsletters about newsletters. Just writing, when there is something worth saying.