Today I would like to talk to you a little bit about compassion fatigue. This is an especially important concept for those of us who work with people who have experienced trauma, whether that be social work, teaching, or therapy. I feel that compassion fatigue is a real concern that all of us would benefit from thinking about in terms of our own well-being, if not to ensure we support our clients as well as we can. Let’s have a look at what compassion fatigue is first so we’re clear on terms.
What is compassion fatigue?
Compassion fatigue is a term that tends to describe the emotional, physical, and psychological impact of being around or at least helping other people. This is especially likely to occur when those people have experienced chronic stress and/or trauma. Compassion fatigue is somewhat similar to burnout, however, the cumulative dissatisfaction that arises from burnout can also be a part of compassion fatigue. I just think that the two are not entirely divisible.
Compassion fatigue can also be referred to as a vicarious trauma. This is when we are exposed to people talking about their distress. However, compassion fatigue can also result from being exposed directly to trauma, such as working with high distressed or agitated people.
Causes of compassion fatigue
Firstly, providing therapy with people who have had extremely severe issues, such as childhood abuse or trauma, can lead to it. Another risk could arise from being threatened by a client when providing care. This is more likely to happen in venues such as local authority care provision, or in psychiatric care, where need is arguably higher. We can also feel the compassion fatigue as a result of providing care in dangerous or highly emotive environments, especially where we are confronted by threats of suicide from someone who we are supposed to care for.
There is also a risk of compassion fatigue when we work extensively under a very heavy workload for long hours, without very much support. Some of the specific examples of where compassion fatigue can impact therapists are as follows.
Impact of compassion fatigue
Firstly there is the issue of mood swings. Obviously, this is when we switch from feeling very happy to feeling very sad. We can also be overly pessimistic or quick to anger. I think this is also another association with burnout more particularly, but it’s still part and parcel of the same ball park.
Compassion fatigue can also lead to us feeling detached from the world. We might feel dissociative, or neglect our friendships and relationships. We might also actually intentionally disconnect from what is so incredibly difficult for a human being to deal with. This is less helpful for clients who need therapists to be present and in the room physically and emotionally.
Addiction is another sign of compassion fatigue. We can resort to using drugs or alcohol or sex (or anything else) in order to manage the emotional impact of exposure to very distressing circumstances. And the addiction can also mask feelings of anxiety or depression that are possibly quite healthy reactions towards unhealthy situations. If you are reaching for the bottle too frequently, then perhaps it is also time to review your relationship there?
Wider impact of compassion fatigue
More widely, we may also experience physical symptomatology such as fatigue, digestive issues or headaches, and another key issue to watch for is the issue of insomnia. Insomnia can look differently to everyone. There are two main kinds of insomnia. I’m thinking firstly of those people who can’t fall asleep, and then wake up exhausted after only a few hours sleep. The other kind is where people can get to sleep because they feel tired and fatigued, but can’t stay asleep, and wake up in the early hours of the morning. Sleep is so incredibly important for us, and I’ve talked about sleep elsewhere, so it’s vital that we work out ways of getting adequate sleep.
If you are interested in exploring more about where you are in respect of compassion fatigue, I would recommend you jump across to this website. Proqol stands for professional quality of life, and the range of accessible and free tools on this site is immense. I would definitely recommend the proqol measurement tool. This will give you an immediate indication of how how stressful your life is currently.
On the site, there is also, even more importantly, a range of self-care tools that you can freely access in order to complement your life. However, I have lots of ideas about self-care for myself, so let’s get into what we can do about the issues around self-care right now.
Helpful ways to manage the impact of vicarious trauma
Even if you have not identified any significant issues in the way you’re feeling about your work or your clients or yourself, the self-care tools here will also help prevent future issues for you. This is important, especially at the beginning of your career where you may not have developed the self management skills as effectively.
Firstly, there is the notion of breath. Our breath is a fundamental sign of how we feel inside ourselves. There is a range of resources out there to support us with managing our breath differently, and I’ve included a resource here for you now. For Gestaltists this is probably teaching you to suck eggs, but persevere! I’ll write a full article on breath very soon!
What I would always encourage you to do now is to firstly just monitor your breath phenomenologically. How heavy is your breathing, how laboured is the breathing, and how easy is it to take in oxygen? It’s always helpful to sit comfortably in a quiet place in order to practice this exercise. Once you notice your breath, this allows you the opportunity to either lengthen your breath, or begin to think about your breathing. Simply by noticing the breath, we can offer ourselves something different, and as soon as we deepen our breath, our brains will move from trauma response to thinking.
And I would encourage you to check your breath throughout the day, every day.
Physical practices
Progressive muscle relaxation is a way of deeply working on stress and tension. If you can’t get out for a massage, then there are lots of progressive muscle relaxation techniques out there that can support you with your life. I would particularly recommend completing a body scan meditation. Here’s a link. I use this most weeks at least once.
There is also the benefit of stretching, such as in yoga. However, if entering a room full of lycra clad youngsters is not your thing (I know, a generalisation), then simply unlock your shoulders. Or turn your head gently from side to side. And walk.
Other options
There are lots of practical things that we can also do to self-care. Firstly is the idea of boundaries. I would always recommend to people I supervise that we take our boundaries seriously. If we work too much, and end up burnt out, then we are not of service to anybody. This is also something to monitor for those we supervise.
And as many of us are often private practitioners, a key part of our income is attributable to private sources. Thus, it is really important that we do not burn out. Thus, it’s vital that you think about the hours of work of that fits for you, and most importantly, stick to it. The thing with burnout and fatigue is that the impact is cumulative, it creeps up on us, often without warning. It’s not uncommon to reflect on previous years when we were clearly not at our best, but lacking awareness at the time.
Practicing what I preach
As a professional working with complex developmental trauma, and have done over 20 years, I take self care very seriously. I never work before 10 o’clock in the morning, I never work after 8 o’clock in an evening, however, I also take a couple of hours off in the afternoon for a siesta. I fill my life out of work with long walks in nature, connecting with friends and family, and have a daily spiritual practice that nurtures everything I do.
It is also important for me to always ensure that I eat properly and have good quality food whenever possible. I never see more than five clients a day. I also think it’s important to have snacks and treats when possible, as long as we don’t end up emotionally eating. If we are to serve our clients at our best, we have to be at our best.
Other tools
Some practical techniques such as grounding, intentional avoidance, focus, managing intrusive thoughts and flashbacks are also helpful. I do think that an overall meditation or mindfulness practice can begin to manage all of these challenges. However, if we are having intrusive thoughts and flashbacks about particular pieces of work, I recommend you definitely take this to supervision to manage this effectively with support. And if supervision isn’t helping, maybe change it up?
Direct therapy, even if for a couple of top-up sessions, can also help you unwind and unravel what happened for you in the work. The research suggests that it’s important to have these conversations especially after stressful or traumatic incidents. One piece of research suggests within 24 hours after in order to have maximum benefit. Another suggests playing Tetris, but let’s not believe everything we read without scrutiny!
Grounding can also help reorientate or calm the body and back into the here and now. The here and now is another fundamental technique in order to stop our minds from wandering into the imagined future, and fretting about what could happen. Especially important if we still have to work with and meet certain people again under certain conditions. If you haven’t read it, I’d suggest Tolle’s book to support you further with this idea.
Practicing intentional avoidance
There is also a specific meditation practice that I like to practice, which is particularly helpful for people who are new into the industry. When we first start the work, we will have intrusive thoughts and flashbacks, and it will be very difficult to feel grounded. This is a normal reaction to what can be quite unusual material. However, learning how to intentionally avoid and focus on our here and now is a great practice to start from the beginning.
I train my mind to certainly not think about work until 5 or 10 minutes before I actually start work. I do this by noticing those thoughts entering my mind, and letting go. Over time, we can work wonders with our ability to manage what we think about and when. Here’s a video to support you with thinking about letting go.
I don’t think about work at all afterwords nowadays, and try to not harbour any thoughts about work outside of those times. And when I finish work, early in the evening, I very rarely think about work anymore. But this has taken time to practice, and early in my career my mind was often full of content.
Other suggestions
You can also do this in a range of different ways, I particularly like to play an instrument to disconnect, or have a meal with friends or family. It’s also quite important to be busy and occupied in the run-up to starting work so you don’t get into the anxiety or acting out the dynamics in your head before time. I also sincerely believe that good quality supervision and good quality therapy, where you can unpick productively the transferential part of the work you are completing, is also of immense benefit.
Counter-transference
Many modalities don’t include learning on counter-transference. If this is you, I’d recommend you learn about this vital element of therapy. Understanding the nature of counter-transference and projective identification can support us in letting go of the client’s processes, and work with the content more ‘cleanly’. This can be liberating if you find the work difficult.
Final thoughts
Overall, there is a real need for roles as practitioners with people to maintain our equilibrium and our health over the years that we will practice. I know of so many people who just resort to the options of alcohol or food. The stress is toxic if not managed more productively. This was especially apparent during the pandemic, when suddenly therapists found themselves working online. We were faced with an unprecedented level of need, working with huge amounts of loss and distress about something we also knew little about. We will, I believe, need to unravel this continuously over the coming years.
This is why myself and another highly experienced colleague, Natalie Kennedy, have set up some groups for practitioners who work with people in traumatic circumstances. These groups are highly effective ways of managing the impact of the fallout from the work that we do. Simply connecting and processing in a non-judgemental way, on what has happened to us, enables us to process and let go of that material. The spiritual practices we incorporate within the work also strengthens us as practitioners.
Register to join us below. Or sign up via the contact form.
I am passionate about these groups, and know they can work. Consider joining us for your own transformation and ongoing support.
Much love,
Dr. Andrew x