The Restless Mind
Mental Health

The toxic stress of social work

17 Sep 2022·8 min read

This morning I read a couple of articles on LinkedIn. This isn’t entirely remarkable for me, but what I read today did resonate with me on a personal level. This is because I read something about someone declaring that they had left social work after 15 years’ commitment to the profession. This story resonates with me because I also left social work after 15 years. I want to write about the toxic stress of social worker, because this is what, ultimately, leads to the issue of retention.

I also want to talk a little bit today about some of the other reasons which underpinned this, and my position on the industry as a whole.

Toxic Stress

Firstly there is the issue of toxic stress. The job requires you to essentially give yourself away emotionally and often physically. I have never met any social worker who has ever been able to manage the workload on a day-to-day basis with the hours they are given. Absolutely everybody, and I would challenge anyone who disagrees with this, works over the contracted hours at some point. This is very important to think about, because if they didn’t they would very quickly become swamped with other demands from the job. This theme is clear within most Serious Case Reviews. But the issue is not just about the amount of work that someone is expected to do. The stress also results of the issue of risk.

Social Work risks

Working as a social worker is a risky job. They work with people who have very different ways of living, and can relate to others in aggressive, confrontational, and manipulative ways. Clients are often caught up in addiction, crime, and have frequently experienced trauma themselves, and this is often about survival. However, being around people with these kinds of presentations can be anxiety provoking if you have no frame of reference for this (read my article on compassion fatigue). Some people manage it better than others. On top of this complexity, we are expected to have very difficult conversations with these presentations all day every day.

Social Workers have to have conversations about clients’ inability to parent properly, we talk about the risk they are presenting to their children, and we are talking about serious implications such as removing the children and going to court for care orders. This is obviously very general, but is a reality of the work. And people will defend what they’re doing, lie, manipulate, and seek to control what’s happening. There are some light moments, and situations where you can have a sense of having done something well, but this is not de rigeur.

And social workers do not have radio back up, and nor do they have tasers or stab vests.

Working in deprivation

Sometimes we complete this work in areas that are also risky; I once worked in an office where someone had fired a gun into the windows. I know of many social workers who have been assaulted or threatened. I myself once had my car hijacked. And social workers have been murdered.

Indeed, social workers rarely get involved with very rich or wealthy families. Social workers are usually working with the oppressed and disadvantaged. However, rather than the government targeting the pockets of disadvantage with resources, the preference is to target social workers for not intervening in an imagined way.

Overall, the combination of excessive demands, unrealistic expectations, and working with dangerous and often violent people, is enough to send anyone for the bottle. There is no wonder that, within several years of social work practice, people can easily reach burnout. This can also lead to compassion fatigue, meaning that social workers can end up also very aggressive and difficult personalities themselves. Also the other risk of the toxic stress on social workers is well-established concerns around their physical health. I have talked about stress variously.

Blame culture

 If the workplace risks were not enough, and if someone was able to survive the toxic stress of working day to day as a social worker, there is the issue of the blame culture. Whenever there is a child death, especially where there are concerns about negligence from social workers, that case will more than likely hit the headlines. When we look back at cases such as Baby P, or Victoria Climbié, the world responds with rage towards the professionals who were employed to protect these children. I’m not here to make judgements on whether or not the claims against the social workers are appropriate. The bottom line is, however, it is never the social worker who caused the child death. It is the parents or carers.

But this difference doesn’t ever seem to settle within the public’s perception. This means that social workers are always working with the additional risk that, if they make a mistake due to the excessive demands placed on them, they could end up on the front page of every newspaper in the country. And if that happens, it is clear that the organisations that employ them are unlikely to protect them.

I think of the social worker, Lisa Arthurworrey, the social worker for Victoria Climbié. It seems that her life was devastated as a result of Victoria’s death, and she became a recluse. I believe the public onslaught was also due to systemic racism. Ultimately, being faced with far too much work or far too much complex nature, and an unsupportive professional system around her, the intervention with Victoria was unsuccessful. Lisa took the flack for the whole process, when she was simply doing the best she could in virtually impossible circumstances.

The role of OFSTED

This is not a great selling point to any social worker wanting to get into the industry. However, we all start in the industry because we want to make a difference, and probably feel that that something bad will never happen to us because we are better, different or more clever etcetera. This is never the case. And social workers realise when it is far too late that they are as dispensable as anyone else.

Also, as a person who has picked up the pieces after OFSTED have visited local authorities and given them a negative rating, the devastation they leave in their wake is horrific. I have had social workers joke to me that they never know who is going to be in the office one day to the next. This is because as soon as a bad rating happens, people come rushing in looking for blood. And they find it. Because we always find what we are looking for.

‘Managing out’ experienced staff

And I think there is an added layer of disappointment and concern here, because the people who are removed were probably once people who functioned extremely well. However, after a couple of years of social work stress exposure, no one can manage that as effectively moving forwards.  Anecdotally, when I first became an agency social worker many years ago, I often went into local authorities where OFSTED had been in and had given the local authority a poor rating. This may have been important, but OFTSED never observe practice, they rate people’s ability to make records. And I am always surprised when it is other social workers managing out their colleagues.

In the places I visited and worked, numerous social workers had been managed out of the system, and were taking the blame for the system rather than individual practices. These local authorities often had had people who had worked at the local authority for over 30 years. This wealth of experience and expertise has been completely lost. This is a travesty, most especially for the children who would have benefitted from that level of experience in their lives.

Privatisation

The result of the problems above is that we all have a broken system. We have people who are often psychologically unwell because of the level of pressure and stress they are managing on a day-to-day level. You also have neurotic Systems that are unable to manage the complexity and the challenges within the work due to under-funding and mass deprivation in their regions. Inexperience and nervousness can lead to knee-jerking and lower thresholds. And children removed unnecessarily. This is another issue in itself.

The government then come in and use this as an excuse to begin privatising statutory services. The chief social worker, Isabelle Trowler, appears to be central to this process given the huge increase of Trusts and ‘charitable’ organisations providing services and training under her watch. Her primary goal is social work ‘improvement‘. However, there have been questions raised about her own business practices.

In the first three years of becoming the chief social worker, the organisation she set up before she became the chief social worker, Morning Lane Associates, were then awarded contracts to the sum of £2.9 million by the Government. Even though Trowler had distanced herself from this organisation, can we truly believe the contract awards were made entirely ‘cleanly’? My suggestion is that her role in government and the ongoing privatisation of social work services should remain a focus to us all. And isn’t it time for someone else?

Final words

The social work system is broken. No matter how many ‘special’ reviews they commission, and no matter how many people benefit financially from that process, the problem remains. I don’t believe it is the social workers who should be blamed, it is the systems in which they work. The need for social work interventions arise from poverty and deprivation, and capitalists benefit financially from that poverty. And that’s the issue, as long as the government keeps people in subservience and poverty through taxation and lack of resources, no amount of services will meet the need.

We don’t need another review, or more ‘improvement’ plans, we need compassion for difference, less capitalism, and more support for children and their families.  

Much love,

Dr. Andrew x

Receive new essays

New pieces arrive infrequently and without filler. No newsletters about newsletters. Just writing, when there is something worth saying.