The Restless Mind
Environment

Pondering climate disaster as a psychotherapist

13 Dec 2022·8 min read

Apologies for not writing in a while. I have been caught up in various transitions, and needed time to reflect and work through them all carefully. I made a big decision to withdraw from permanent teaching contracts. This was a thoughtfully-made decision, but having been pondering climate disaster as a psychotherapist, I realise that the climate emergency is more of a priority for myself at this moment in time. I want to do my bit in the movement towards climate recovery, and now.

And I will still teach – I am currently committed to a range of institutions – but only for intermittent, helicoptering provision.  This means I am now able to be back writing also, and I hope to write with some passion today. 

Talking about the climate

I was in a meeting earlier this week with an erudite professional whom I respect immensely, and we were reflecting on the notion of eco-therapy. This is a term we are hearing about increasingly, without any of us truly understanding what it means, or what the expectations are. I don’t have any sense of priority or urgency from the regulatory or training bodies to support this, although do hear – for example, within organisation member assessments – of the need to incorporate this topic within training. Without any clarity about how, when, or where. I am sure many are talking about it, but probably working through the issue on their feet, as I am today.

This does leave me with a frantic disappointment in these bodies, as many appear to be in so much disarray themselves.  This isn’t just a backhanded comment, but an observation. In particular, things appeared to be so difficult within the UKCP recently that the chair, the exec chair, and some trustee members stood down on the shortly after the same meeting.  Similar changes have been seen across the industry, in a range of institutions (i.e. the collision of SCoPEd with BACP), and there seems a distinct issue in terms of retention of staff within many of the training institutes in the UK. I sit here as a lowly member in exasperation at what is happening ‘above’.

Moving away from waiting for our leaders

But I realise that we cannot let the failings of our ‘leadership’ get in the way of this absolutely vital issue. We must, as a profession, collectively and individually, do whatever we can on this matter. And now. We don’t need external leadership telling us what to do, or how to do it, but we need to develop our own strategies, ourselves, now, and make decisions and actions that are not dependent upon greed or bonuses.  We are powerful people as individuals, with incredible skills and knowledge on the process of change, and we need to use it. Here’s my offering.

What do you think about the climate emergency?

Firstly, the question is, what are your views about the climate emergency?  Do you deny it? Are you ambivalent about it? Do you think there is probably something in it, but you are too busy to do anything? The first step for us all is to assess or reassess our own level of belief in the emergency. And to hold that belief in awareness in the therapeutic encounter. I think it is fine to share that position if it will be in the service of our client, but not if it will fuel their frustration, their hurt, or their anxiety.

Do you disbelieve the emergency? Are you questioning the reality of the record heatwaves, floods, and ecological devastation around you? I do believe that, if you are in any doubt, you probably need to explore that yourself. If you are ambivalent about this, you bring in to the therapeutic field and the therapeutic contact that ambivalence. If you are ambivalent, the client could be influenced by that ambivalence. My position is that, if you are in any level of denial about the emergency, that you truly need to focus on that at this juncture. 

My position is that there is absolutely no doubt at all that we are in a climate emergency, and it is time for immediate action. I would hope that that is the baseline for you. But I am not panicked, I understand the issue, recognise the role, and nurture optimism that I can and will do something about it. But what is eco-therapy, and what are our responsibilities as therapists, regardless of your discipline, modality, level of training, or colour hair.

What is eco-therapy?

For myself, I understand eco-therapy as an openness to thinking about the environment and the climate emergency within the therapeutic space. However, thinking about it, and being open to it – as we would about any other issue that the client chooses to bring in – is not the same as bringing the climate into the therapeutic space ourselves. In my view, we are not offering a politicised space, and we have to remain sensitive to what the client chooses to bring in. It is vital we do not lose sight of that. But that we are in an emergency; this isn’t a make-believe notion. But eco-therapy isn’t just about working being open to exploring the emergency.

The issue of eco-anxiety

In addition to being open to the notion of the environmental emergency, and to check our own belief system, we need to also consider the notion of eco-anxiety. The American Psychology Association (APA) describes eco-anxiety as “the chronic fear of environmental cataclysm that comes from observing the seemingly irrevocable impact of climate change and the associated concern for one’s future and that of next generations”.  I would imagine that all of you have, to some level, heard about this from one or all of your clients. You may also experience this anxiety yourself. 

For clients working with therapists who are not present due to their own process, and for those of us where the eco-anxiety is so huge that we are contaminating the therapeutic space, we need to step back and reflect, again, on our own process. This is a time to ensure that you are working through your own anxiety sufficiently to ensure that you are present enough to support your clients with theirs. As with covid, where we found ourselves needing to support people with the unexpected, distressing global emergency, and with massive uncertainty, we need to do the same here. In reality, we work through the anxiety in the same way. 

The situation is worsening, and we need to be prepared

We should also remember that this is a problem that will only worsen over the coming months and years.  As people realise the enormity of the situation, and face their vulnerability, anxieties will rise. And when they are impacted by the chaos which will result from the eco-emergency, people will need more support rather than less. I also imagine that the emergency will inevitably impact the impoverished and the vulnerable before it impacts the wealthy. Which is sobering. In a way, we need to get in the emotional health gym now, ourselves, ready to support those who need it. 

But what is our role as a psychotherapist?

Another matter is that of our role.  Whereas in the last election, I read some leading therapists advising we bring politics in to the therapeutic space, I think this contaminates the client’s process and also the therapeutic alliance. Certainly at that time, my experience was that people did not want to talk about politics. There were other concerns they were focused on. Our clients do not need influencing, they need holding; many clients have already been influenced enough. We need to offer a safe space that clients can explore their own process, not ours.

Is this the space for rescuing?

Another ethical issue is that we cannot offer any pragmatic reassurance. We cannot say that there is no issue. We cannot say that the issue is in the client’s mind. It isn’t. It’s reality. And there is also an ethical issue in what we do with this. Does our support reduce their anxiety and subsequently raise their indifference to the issue?  Do we really want to manipulate our clients into not feeling the anxiety at all, and thus become less of an ally in the process? Should we even see our clients as an ‘ally’? Is there an issue is seeing everyone as potential allies/ Would this also be contaminating the space?

I think this is a precarious balance to hold, where we are supporting the client’s anxiety, not desensitising the client to reality, and maintaining appropriate professional boundaries. And our own.

Thoughts for today

I guess, overall, we firstly need to ensure we are in good shape regarding the emergency. That we understand it, can navigate the impact on people and ourselves, and yet retain a presence and strength of character to support others who may not be dealing with the issue so well. In my experience currently, this appears to be affecting those who work in the allied eco-professions (i.e. tree surgeons, sustainability professionals etc) field more deleteriously. I am reminded of the recent self-immolation from a key ally, which I wrote about here.

So let’s keep our doors open for those who are working tirelessly to support the ecological recovery. Keep ourselves in shape emotionally and physically, doing whatever we can to prioritise the climate within our own personal lives. And stay connected – return here as I continue to explore and write about strategies and action, and ultimately ways of using our specific skill most effectively in the world.

Much love,

Dr. Andrew x

Receive new essays

New pieces arrive infrequently and without filler. No newsletters about newsletters. Just writing, when there is something worth saying.