The Restless Mind
Blog

Three ways to protect yourself from narcissistic spirituality

22 Apr 2023·6 min read

In this article I want to offer five ways to protect yourself from narcissistic spirituality. We’ve all seen it. We go to a meditation group, a workshop, or a spirituality event, and the narcissists are there. Men with top-knots and perma-tans (and a few Om tattoos), women with long dreadlocks and bangles, the occasional cloak, flowers in hair, and everyone reeking of patchouli. We think they’re our friend, then realise latterly we were just a pawn in their megalomaniac quest for adoration.

I know, this is a puerile generalisation, but one which, I imagine, most of us recognise at some level. Because these personalities – or at least the energy they exude – are everywhere, insidious almost. Or at least what they represent is; that seemingly over-confident, arrogant, entitled way of ‘doing’ spirituality. Humans are hierarchical, and spirituality is tool to support that. And let’s own our own projections in this – there are some lovely people with dreadlocks, and I have been known to wear a top knot in times gone past.

Recognising narcissists

In spiritual circles the narcissists are the people who make claims to having close connections with inspirational gurus. They are the ones who dance wildly at the front of the Kirtan, so everyone can see. They are the ones who always manage to connect deeply with someone, and let the rest of the group see that connection. And, alas, also the ones who shut down others during conversations, or leave them stranded. They are the people who take up the most attention, but often give the least back in return.

And don’t get me wrong, I understand the process, and am not critical of it. Narcissism is a defence against shame. It is about making oneself seem confident and capable to the world, when internally, we may feel neurotic, afraid, and shamed. In a way narcissism is a compensation, a way of reassuring the external that the internal is potent and alive. And this is why they so often hurt others. The saying is:

“A narcissist doesn’t break your heart, they break your spirit. That’s why it takes so long to heal.” —

Unknown

Why spirituality attracts them

In spirituality there is a belief that we should always be grounded, balanced, and full of kindness, with reverence, and boundless joy. The joy which we should espouse can be seen in the wild dancing memes and insta photos. The kindness seen in groups of young folk sitting around campfires. Reverence is seen in the shrine photographs, and any pic with hands in prayer. No-one is doing this because they want to be depressed; they want to be liberated from their distress.

Again, I am generalising, but I’m sure you recognise them. May even have found yourself there at some point.

Narcissists feel empty, and see spirituality as a way of justifying their toxicity.

I recognise the above is an ideal, but some of us work hard to reflect these qualities in our being. This kind of belief, however, attracts the narcissist, as they can ape a way of ‘being’ better than anyone else. Because they do not have a coherent sense of self, pretending to be someone else is second nature to them. This is especially important if they can use the way of being as a transaction to get something they want – usually status, or people, or stuff.

The issue is that these are all projected images, not reality. They are a standing image in time; a fleeting moment. And if you don’t meet that expectation, it would be easy to assimilate that you are somehow failing in the spiritual environs. For those of us who are non-white, non-tanned, non-blonde, non-skinny, non-rich, non-confident, how on earth do we begin to process any kind of connection with that which is projected into social media? I don’t think we can.

Narcissistic influencers

And even though there may well be authentic, gentle, courageous, kind beings in the spiritual world – let’s face it, many of us work hard to try to be in that space as far as we are able – there are people who carve out their spiritual persona through delusion and pride. Let’s look at Charles Eisenstein for example.

Charles has attracted a lot of attention over the past few years – I’ve reviewed his book here – and certainly seems to take his reflections and insight seriously.  However, he also harbours somewhat problematic views and opinions such as anti-vaxing and climate denial, which I find personally abhorrent. Again, he is one of many.

Spirituality as a way of deflecting from difficult feelings

I have spoken variously on the importance of spirituality – in my book especially – and humans have always had beliefs about those things which we cannot explain rationally. However, nowadays the draw to a belief system seems to be more about protecting us from tricky feelings. We don’t want to feel lonely so we join a spiritual tribe. We don’t want to feel shame so we choose spirituality to deflect from the shame. It’s ok to feel, and if we want to actualise, we are required to navigate the trickiness in order to liberate ourselves from the hurt.

Narcissists also use spirituality to deflect from feeling anything, and this ends up reinforcing, not removing, the defended self. We therefore need to look beyond the dhoti and the dreadlocks. What kind of heart does the person in front of us have? How are they assimilating their practice? Clothes do not make our spiritual practice. Inside the protective exterior lies complex fear, insecurity, and rage.

Here are a few things to help navigate the challenges of when we come in to contact with narcissists

  1. Observe people more fully. Notice not only what they do but what they don’t do. Are they only nice to a select few? Are they only presentable for brief periods? Notice, notice, notice.
  2. Keep a sense of self. With narcissists, even in spiritual circles, the tendency is to get drawn in to the drama they bring with them. I encourage you to step aside from them, and focus on your needs as an individual. If the narcissist can’t meet them, move on to someone who can.
  3. Be wary of gurus, but not avoidant. Gurus have an important role, and it can be helpful to have a guru – not least for learning about specific points. But often gurus are people who are driven by attention and social standing, even if they seem ok on the surface. There are genuine, loving, talented gurus as well, but they serve as receptacles for our need to be part of a tribe rather than anything else. My suggestion is to hold an interest in Gurus, but just don’t move in with them on the first day.

I hope this helps, guys. Narcissism can drain us of the will to live, and so even in spiritual circles it is vital that we keep a part of us safe and separate from the energy of the group. It’s ok to look after yourself, and to move slowly within circles. It’s ok to even get a top knot if you are called. Just get to know people, know yourself, and don’t, whatever you do, give yourself away.

Much love,

Dr. Andrew

Receive new essays

New pieces arrive infrequently and without filler. No newsletters about newsletters. Just writing, when there is something worth saying.