The Restless Mind
Masculinity

Are you scared of change?

28 Oct 2022·5 min read

Isn’t this an important question? Are you scared of change? Most of us would probably say not, and yet we spend each day dreaming: of a different life; a different relationship; a different job. Yet, when faced with the option to ‘jump ship’ and change, the thought of change keeps us stuck. In fact, even if we are in highly abusive, unhealthy relationships, the fear of change – combined with the hope of change – keeps us stuck. I’m going to explain why, and offer a few suggestions as to what you can do to begin your change process.

What I know about change

As a psychotherapist and social worker, I have spent decades working with people to effect change. This was often through client choice, but sometimes not, as in statutory social work. There are a couple of things that I know for certain. Firstly, massive environmental changes are traumatic to most people. Even winning the lottery, which we may think is a panacea for life, can leave people broken. Moving from a difficult relationship into singledom can also be tricky, especially if we are left feeling lonely and isolated. However, the thought of what our new life may look like propels us forward. I’m sure many of you know the distress arising from bereavement.

I also know that lasting change has to start slow. I have written about the process here and elsewhere. Even though some clinicians report dramatic change in a miniscule number of sessions, I remain cautious about the data. There is great data that shows our childhood neurological tendencies remain throughout adulthood; our wiring is set out there, and changing this requires an arduous, consistent, and sustained effort. But I know that it is possible, but challenging. Perhaps this is what leaves people so afraid of change?

Why do people fear change?

For people are afraid of change. One study showed two groups of people a painting. One group was told the painting was completed in 1905, the other group was told the painting was completed in 2005. The former group rated the painting higher than the ‘younger’ group. This suggests and confirms the reality that we trust the older rather than the newer. This may go a way to explain people’s preferences of Boris over Rishi.

This is also about the issue of uncertainty. We cannot tolerate uncertainty, and opt for the known rather than the unknown. It has been suggested that uncertainty registers in our brain like an error message, and we need to rectify it before we can do anything. And it is the uncertainty that creates fear, procrastination, and avoidance. Does this ring a bell for you?

So what can we do about it?

In the early stages of therapy, when someone has commenced their process of change, I advise they make no big decisions – particularly around relationships – for some time. Enough is going on internally for the external to also crumble beneath their feet. The beginning of the change process can snowball, and it is vital we support this proactively; I don’t want clients leaving families unless it is truly from their adult place. And I recommend this to you – whilst change is important, it needs to be considered and appropriate for you.

Sustained change has to be slow and steady. Rather than an 8 or a 9 in terms of fear, choose something from a scale of 1 or a 2. Maybe the new job in a new country isn’t for today? But the new job after a year of saving and planning may well be a great fit. And perhaps that’s where your change process needs to start? Also, use the scale to manage your expectations. If it takes 66 days to effect lasting change of habits, attempt only one habit at a time, and a lesser habit at first. Whilst you may want to stop eating any sugar from tomorrow, what is more helpful and less threatening to your brain, is to re-organise when you eat sugar, dropping off one treat a week.

Reflecting on your relationship with change

I am in the industry of change; clients pay me to feel differently about their lives, and to let go and process out their histories. It’s a job I take seriously, and the idea of change remains central to our work together, and functions at all levels; the content and the process; the there and then and the here and now. And I endeavour to remain as open to change as my own mind will allow. And I encourage you, today, to begin to reflect on your relationship with change.

In particular, what changes would your heart wish to see, and what changes would your mind allow? What has your experience of change been? If change has been traumatic, it may help to process and work through the trauma before you attempt change itself. Issues around bereavement in particular can leave us so traumatised, that it is important we process this element before we set ourselves up for new changes.

And remember that the preliminary reflection on the process of change, is actually the beginning of change for you! So well done for making a start. Open yourself to your reflections, and see where you get. And bear in mind the notion of change being a process rather than an end result.

Much love,

Dr. Andrew x

Receive new essays

New pieces arrive infrequently and without filler. No newsletters about newsletters. Just writing, when there is something worth saying.