The Restless Mind
Mental Health

Do anti-depressants affect serotonin levels?

31 Jul 2022·5 min read

Good afternoon. Before I answer the question, do anti-depressants affect serotonin levels, let’s talk about the weather. We are, here in old Blighty, ‘enjoying’ a wonderful summer. Whilst we have only had two hot days so far – and this resulted in near hysteria – we remain optimistic for another hot day before October. Whilst I am no climate denier, we still need to live as well as we can right now.

This article will explore the recent news’ articles which have questioned the perceived relationship between serotonin and anti-depressants. In particular, the evidence is now questioning if anti-depressants affect serotonin levels. I was really surprised when I read the article in question, not least because the findings completely turn what we thought we knew about SSRIs (selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors) on its head. I’m still shook!

However, it seems like an important matter to address, so follow me as I look through the evidence, and sort out the wheat from the chaf.

What are anti-depressants?

SSRIs, for those who don’t know, are the most common anti-depressants that can be prescribed for a range of emotional issues. Predominantly, they will be prescribed for depression and/or anxiety, but are also prescribed for panic disorder, OCD, PTSD, and bulimia. I’ll stop with the acronyms now.

Ultimately, the anti-depressant industry earns huge amounts from anti-depressants, with The Business Research organisation stating that the global anti-depressant industry is worth billions:

  • $15.61 billion in 2021 to $16.44 billion in 2022 at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 5.4%. The change in the antidepressants market growth trend is mainly due to the companies stabilizing their output after catering to the demand that grew exponentially during the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020. The antidepressants market is expected to reach $22.57 billion in 2026 at a CAGR of 8.2%.

So one could safely presume that the antidepressant industry also benefited financially from the global lockdown. And further, that the global need for antidepressants is only worsening because of the state of our mental health, wherever you are in the world. But why is the SSRI research news?

The role of serotonin in depression

For decades, SSRIs were prescribed because it was thought that they improved mood by increasing serotonin levels. Whilst it is clear that it is somewhat simplistic to reduce the idea of depression being a direct result of serotonin levels, this is essentially how the SSRIs have been thought to work. But do serotonin levels affect depression?

Briefly, to explain, serotonin is a neurotransmitter (a signal carrier between nerve cells in the brain), and is thought to influence mood, emotion, and sleep positively. Serotonin is then reabsorbed by the nerve cells (the reuptake part), and SSRIs work by blocking the reuptake. This means that more serotonin is available to pass further messages between nearby nerve cells because it’s not absorbed. The NHS continues to consider antidepressants as ways of increasing serotonin levels in the brain.

New research on antidepressants

This is a great question though, isn’t it? How can we, 60 years later, realise that there is no relationship between serotonin and depression? There is obviously no quick answer. But it is a sobering thought that, again, science informs us one thing, we run with it, and latterly realise the phenomenon isn’t what they originally thought it was. I am always reminded of the old alzheimer’s studies, where doctors would recommend smoking because it was thought smoking reduced the chances of alzheimer’s and because of tobacco affiliations. It did, because people tended to die from lung cancer beforehand.

The new research has shown, using fairly reliable scientific methodologies, that there is actually no relationship between serotonin levels and depression. Actually, the research suggests that long-term antidepressant use reduces serotonin levels, not increases them. This was research which evaluated and synthesised a range of systematic reviews, met-analyses, and cohort studies. Yes, how on earth did this happen? I don’t have an answer, but I will be awaiting one.

Babies and bath water

You would probably be forgiven to suddenly think about throwing away your anti-depressants. I most definitely do not advise that, as there continues to be a sense that anti-depressants can, ultimately, help the symptoms of depression. However, what this research demonstrates, is that there is less clarity about how the anti-depressants work in the brain. The question, thus, is not if they work, but how.

I think, if I’m honest, there is also a matter of asking other questions. How can we find out which parts of the brain anti-depressants do affect and how? There is a loss of coherence though, and the scientific community would, I believe, benefit from coming back to us with more insight. What we do know, is that prolonged use of anti-depressants is associated with significant risk of alzheimer’s. Therefore, we do need to balance the need for anti-depressants with risk arising from the depression.

Take-aways

I guess, it’s important to remember the environmental associations with depression. Evidence suggests that environmental factors are more significant than genetic predisposition. If the trigger to your depression is your environment, then it may be helpful to manage your environment differently, before trying anti-depressants. We also know that genetic risk factors are not automatically conclusive – if your parents were schizophrenic, you may have a higher risk of schizophrenia, but developing symptoms isn’t inevitable, especially – for example – if you lived away from your parents, with consistent love and care without the impact of living around what can be confusing, alarming adult behaviour.

It’s also important to try other options. There are lots of things we can do to affect our wellbeing overall. I shared nine specific steps in my previous book, Nine Steps to Health, Strength, and Happiness. And I would also recommend psychotherapy. Whilst psychotherapy is known to have a slower impact than anti-depressants on depression, the results are known to last longer. Psychotherapy encourages a characterological transformation, rather than a quick fix. And I use that term specifically – whilst most therapies and therapists can effect change, it is the psychotherapeutic approach – which focuses on the uniqueness of the client and the quality of the relationships – which is paramount in importance.

And finally, the levels of stress we live with in modern day life is absolutely corrosive. Get rid of the stress ruthlessly. Look after yourself, and find yourself a tribe of people to connect with. And don’t forget the immense benefits of spiritual practices. You can do this.

Andrew

Receive new essays

New pieces arrive infrequently and without filler. No newsletters about newsletters. Just writing, when there is something worth saying.