The Restless Mind
Mental Health

Five ways to think about gaslighting

3 Aug 2022·10 min read

Five ways to think about gaslighting – (trigger warning – reference to domestic abuse)

Last weekend, my partner was attempting to encourage our son to do something. I was playing the harp, predictably. The son wasn’t particularly keen on complying.  The situation escalated slightly, with my partner attempting to help him think differently about the problem at hand (sounds worse than it was haha). Out of nowhere, the son quipped, ‘stop gaslighting me’. We all paused, taken aback our son knew the word, and I noticed my partner blatantly didn’t really understand it either.  So we laughed, and finished what we were doing. I then stepped back and reflected on not only the process in our home, but the term itself.  Subsequently, in this article I will offer 5 ways to think about gaslighting. I think it will be helpful to understand not only the concept, but also how to deal with it, from the position of a psychotherapist. 

What is gaslighting?

Over the past couple of years, the term ‘gaslighting’ has slipped into common parlance.  In this article I explore the term, not only in terms of understanding it, but also beginning to analyse some of the difficulties in recognising and intervening.  I think it’s vital that, as psychotherapists, we remain on top of developments in our communities.

Essentially, gaslighting is a method of emotional abuse, leading to victims doubting their own sense of reality.  This is an incredibly serious intra-personal process, with a corrosive impact on victims. However, there is also a danger in that some people use the term both in an inaccurate way (as my son did), but also in an attempt to shut down dialogue, or to malign someone else out of feeling hurt or angry.  No-one wants to think that they gaslight, and if someone tells them they gaslight, this can also create panic.  And is, in a way, gaslighting. Thus, we need to consider on the one hand, the importance of understanding how gaslighting works, but also to understand how gaslighting as a term can be used to gaslight.  If you catch my drift.

So what’s the back story?

Let’s start with what we know about gaslighting. The terms derives from the title of the 1944 film, Gaslight.  In this film a husband convinces his wife that she is mentally unwell so that he is able to steal from her. Gaslighting as a word is not used or mentioned in the screenplay or movie. It became more popular around 2016, when key agencies such as Oxford University Press began to celebrate the word.

The internet is clear.  Gaslighting is a kind of power dynamic.  Robin Stern claims that the ‘manipulator’ holds sufficient power, so that the ‘victim’ is terrified to change or step out of the gaslighting dynamic because of the threat of losing that relationship, or being seen as less than who they want to be seen as.  The process between the two people may start out with small instances of questioning your own reality, but soon builds up and snowballs in intensity.

Examples?

Stern claims that the victim can end up in a cycle of being unclear in their mind, doubting their capacity to make decisions, and lacking a sense of well-being. However, the process is not always intentional or malicious, apparently.  Let’s think about a few examples.

  1. Julie is in a relationship with Davide.  She is conscious that when she raises the fact that money seems to be going out of the account, he always ends up shutting her down. She ends up questioning if she got it right.  Was money going out.  Was she miscalculating the family expenses.  She worries about her capacity, and decides to leave the budgeting to Davide.
  2. Marcus is feeling anxious at work.  His manager, Maria, often denies the issues he raises, and he begins to overthink.  This leads to him becoming burnt out, and less effective than he used to be.

Gaslighting appears to have begun more prominently in the domestic violence arena.  This makes sense as gaslighting is an abuse of power. The National Domestic Violence Hotline has a factsheet, which breaks down further the notion of gaslighting.  They refer to:

Witholding (refusing to listen)

Countering (questioning the victim’s memory of an event)

Blocking (changing the subject)

Trivialising (making needs or feelings seem unimportant)

Forgetting/Denial (pretending to forget what happened, or denying something they previously agreed to). 

I guess, when you consider gaslighting in the context of an abusive relationship, the whole concept seems more fitting and vital to include in our thinking about how we relate in relationships.  And for psychotherapists, how we support recovery. However, gaslighting is used in contexts where issues such as, say, physical violence is never seen.

Misuse of the term

It is also becoming acknowledged that the misuse of the word, gaslighting, is at best, unhelpful. This is possibly similar to what happened in our kitchen, that fateful Sunday! On the Bachelorette, Katie Thurston publicly believed Grep Grippo gaslighted her during the show’s finale episode on August 9th.  However, what was observed was her using the term to refer to a communication style that was obviously poor, but not fitting of the gaslighting definition. I can’t claim Thurston used the term manipulatively to undermine Grippo, this may just have been misunderstanding.  But I think it does demonstrate how the term is becoming bastardised and misunderstood.

“Gaslighting is often used in an accusatory way when somebody may just be insistent on something, or somebody may be trying to influence you. That’s not what gaslighting is.”

—Robin Stern, PhD

And this is a concern.  We read about terms such as gaslighting, and begin to use it in everyday ways.  The original source may not be fully legitimate, and we might misremember the original source.  This leads to misrepresentation.  And as people jump on it, and misuse the term, intentionally or not, this creates a massive challenge.  Those people who are truly being gaslit end up more vulnerable as the perpetrators can use this to exert more control.

Awareness of interpersonal dynamics

The reality with gaslighting is that victims rarely know they are being gaslit.  They are often being led by someone they admire or love, and trust this person.  This opens them up to the process of gaslighting, because they want to believe and connect with this person.  Another important point is the intention of the perpetrator.  Gaslighting seems to be about control and power.  In my kitchen, the ‘perp’ was endeavouring to help my son think about his actions. But this is another challenge – what is gaslighting for one, may be helpful to another, or at least justified.  

If you disagree with something someone is saying to you, by challenging them and correcting their perception, you are not being gaslit.  You are challenging what you see to be unjust.  And this is the other problem.  Human perception is so problematic – we see what we feel, not necessarily what is real.  This is why I think someone external, a professional ideally, needs to help you understand the process you are in. 

You don’t want the perpetrator’s parents to give you an opinion, as they give their view from a personal, subjective perspective.  You want someone who can analyse each side of the process, and formulate a coherent observation in partnership with you. I think this is also important as if you are being gaslit, a professional is possibly best suited to avoid retraumatising the victim through denying, minimising, or deflecting from what the victim feels is happening.

Evolution versus humanity

The process of gaslighting is aggressive, but the perpetrator has sufficient control to do so in a softly, almost unobtrusive way. Think about the serpent seducing Eve.  Fifty years ago the gaslighters, without domestic violence legislation, may have been more overt in their control and abuse of another.  Now, society’s intolerance has sent the process of control and manipulation underground, which potentially makes it even more insidious and dangerous. 

Social Media standards also perpetuate the idea that everyone has to be kind and everyone has to be a particular kind of way. This potentially leads to some people trying to mask their shadow emotions, becoming passive aggressive and inauthentic.  Is gaslighting actually a product of this? 

Ultimately, humans are not robots, behaving in perfect ways – we are angry, fearful, shameful beings, and thousands of years of evolution has not changed that.  We as a society want everyone to be kind and lovely, but in doing this we split off from our shadier sides.  By shaming perpetrators into silence, we send the problematic behaviours, the ones we want to resolve, underground, and people avoid taking responsibility.  We deny them the opportunity to grow and make different choices.  The problems sticks around, but becomes more insidious. These are not the behaviours we want to be going underground.

This makes the actual behaviour, in real terms, far more dangerous. It’s the kind of behaviour that people with narcissistic and sociopathic personalities will be drawn to naturally. So let’s think about how to manage gaslighting in everyday life. Obviously, if you are in an abusive relationship, get professional help. The tips are for navigating what might be seen as gaslighting in everyday life.

Five ways to think about gaslighting

From the above, we can see quite clearly the misuse of power, and is not just someone expressing a different view, as in my kitchen. It’s serious stuff, and more than just the general conflict we engage in with those we love. However, I want to raise a couple of observations, to help your thinking around this matter.

  1. Firstly, if you have been gaslighted in the past, say by a partner, you are more likely to project that dynamic in to the here and now.  This means that your perception doesn’t necessarily equal reality, although it may well.  There is a need, therefore, to ensure that you take external advice around discussing the dynamics at hand. This will help avoid projective identification, and will offer some distance from the dynamic. Life doesn’t need to feel unnecessarily tricky with unprocessed material in the background.
  2. There is a need for sensitivity and awareness around power in all of our relationships.  Inevitably most of us will have managers, we may be in relationships, and we may have older, more senior friends and family around us.  The risk of gaslighting shouldn’t inhibit our ability to be in these kinds of relationships, just an important need to check out stuff that feels awry.  Before acting on that.
  3. Trust your internal thermometer.  If something feels icky, it probably is.  Try to separate out the feelings from the thinking.  Remember, we are not thinking beings that feel, we are feeling beings that think.  Our instincts are vital mechanisms to keep us safe, even if the process is partially unconscious.  Once you have a grasp of the two, it is time to consider action that fits you as a person and your circumstances.
  4. I also think that therapy can come in handy, because of the insidious nature of gaslighting.  In therapy we have the opportunity to explore our interpersonal processes in safety, privately, and clarity, over time.  This will help us identify those things that are out of our awareness, and help formulate safe responses.  If we’re not in therapy, there are other mechanisms we should use in order to ensure we are protected and supported in everything we do.
  5. Don’t worry for two.  Whilst there is not a huge range of specific and high-quality statistics out there specific to this concept, gaslighting doesn’t appear to be endemic. It is around, there are risks to your emotional health from this interpersonal process, but it will generally involve other, easier to observe behaviours from the problem person (unfortunately) as well.  There is no need to see it where it doesn’t necessarily live, and vital that we don’t minimise the seriousness by claiming it lies in more places than it does.  And remember your own vitality and power as a person – you can say no, you can challenge, and you can make different choices for yourself. And there is support out there to help you navigate the intricacies. I know, easier said than done, but not impossible.

Much love,

Dr. Andrew

https://www.nbcnews.com/better/health/what-gaslighting-how-do-you-know-if-it-s-happening-ncna890866

Receive new essays

New pieces arrive infrequently and without filler. No newsletters about newsletters. Just writing, when there is something worth saying.