I’ve recently been involved in an issue with a large organisation. This isn’t particularly unusual for me. Not because I’m intrinsically difficult or ‘trouble’, although I have certainly spent periods of my life wondering whether I am. It happens because I’m autistic, and because some aspects of autistic communication do not sit comfortably within organisations governed by powerful, but largely unspoken, social rules.
The issue itself was relatively simple. I stated that it was not acceptable to prevent a disabled person from entering a facility. I didn’t shout. I wasn’t abusive. I didn’t make threats. I described what had happened and named what I believed was wrong with it. The response was, let’s say, interesting. The level of defensiveness was shocking, although in the spirit of honesty, I had some lovely communication from others.
What particularly interested me was the apparent gap between the relatively straightforward thing I had said and the strength of the reaction it generated. And I think that gap tells us something important about autism, inclusion and organisations.
When neurodiversity becomes inconvenient
There is a popular stereotype that autistic people ‘have no filter’. I don’t think that describes my experience particularly well. I have a filter. I think carefully about language. I understand that words have consequences. I know that being autistic doesn’t give me permission to be cruel, rude or inconsiderate. The difference is often somewhere else.
I don’t always understand why something that is demonstrably happening must not be named. Human groups contain enormous amounts of unspoken information. People know who has power. They know which subjects are safe. They know which person shouldn’t be challenged. They know when a consultation isn’t really a consultation. They know which values are aspirational and which are actually practised.
Most of this is rarely written down. People learn it socially. And sometimes an autistic person walks into the middle of it and says:
“But that isn’t what happened.”
Or:
“You said something different last week.”
Or:
“How is that inclusive?”
The problem may not be that we failed to understand what was happening. Sometimes we understood it perfectly. We simply didn’t understand that everybody else had tacitly agreed not to say it.
Organisations have identities too
This becomes particularly interesting when organisations develop strong identities around their values. This particular organisation is, “We are inclusive.” “We are compassionate.” “We welcome difference.” “We listen.”
These may be sincere aspirations. They may also become stories an organisation tells about itself. There is an important difference. However, no organisation is inherently compassionate, inclusive or loving. Organisations are made of human beings, and human beings bring all the ordinary human material with them: generosity, fear, kindness, insecurity, loyalty, defensiveness, hierarchy, ego and contradiction.
An organisation can genuinely value inclusion and still behave in an exclusionary way. That shouldn’t be a shocking proposition. In fact, recognising it should be essential to becoming more inclusive. The difficulty comes when inclusion stops being something an organisation does and becomes something the organisation believes it is. Then criticism can feel less like information and more like an attack on identity.
If “we are inclusive” has become part of the organisation’s self-concept, someone saying “what happened here was not inclusive” creates a problem. There are broadly two possibilities. We can examine what happened. Or we can examine the person who said it. Human systems are often surprisingly tempted by the second.
Inclusion gets harder when difference is inconvenient
Most people are comfortable with difference when difference is agreeable. We can celebrate neurodiversity when it means creativity, unusual talents, different perspectives and colourful graphics during awareness week. The test comes when neurological difference produces behaviour we find uncomfortable.
An autistic person may be unusually direct. I am for sure. They may question a procedure everyone else accepts. I do. They may notice inconsistency. I do. They may not recognise a hierarchy that everybody else instinctively observes. Definitely. They may require explicit explanations where everyone else relies upon implication. I do. They may persist with a question because it hasn’t actually been answered. Aha. They may describe something in concrete terms when the group would prefer diplomatic ambiguity. And we often have this directness building up inside us, spending two days trying to suppress it, until we can’t hold it in anymore and it needs to get airtime.
None of this means the autistic person is necessarily correct. Autistic people can misunderstand situations. We can behave badly. We can be insensitive. We can become defensive. We can be completely wrong. Autism confers neither moral superiority nor privileged access to truth. But neither does social consensus.
Ten people being uncomfortable with what somebody has said does not automatically make that person wrong. Sometimes discomfort is information too.
The danger of turning discomfort into wrongdoing
I think this distinction matters enormously for autistic people. Many of us become extremely accustomed to examining ourselves. Did I say too much? Was my tone wrong? Should I have kept quiet? Did I misunderstand? Was I too direct? Am I the problem again? And after a further incident, the autistic person again retreats, dealing with the fallout of a further instance of just being them.
If you repeatedly experience strong social reactions to direct communication, it becomes very easy to learn that other people’s discomfort is evidence that you have done something wrong. And it’s tricky to move through this without taking an emotional beating. It isn’t.
What genuine neurodiversity inclusion requires
If organisations genuinely want neurodivergent people within them, they have to tolerate more than the pleasant parts of neurodiversity. They need some capacity to tolerate communication that doesn’t follow the usual social choreography. That does not mean accepting aggression or abandoning reasonable standards of behaviour. It means becoming curious before becoming defensive.
What is this person actually saying? Is there truth in it? Are we responding to their behaviour, or to the discomfort produced by what they have identified? Are we expecting this person to understand rules that nobody has ever articulated? And perhaps most importantly:
Are we still inclusive when somebody’s difference inconveniences us?
Because inclusion that survives only while everybody behaves in familiar and comfortable ways isn’t much of an achievement.
A message to autistic people
This is really why I wanted to write this. If you recognise yourself in any of this, I don’t want you to conclude that you should stop speaking. But I also don’t want to replace one simplistic story with another. Being autistic doesn’t mean you are always the person telling the truth while everybody else is pretending. We need humility, reflection and accountability as much as anybody else.
So check your facts. Consider your language. Be respectful. Listen when people disagree with you. Be prepared to discover that you were wrong. But don’t automatically conclude that you were wrong simply because people reacted badly.
And don’t spend your life learning to remain silent whenever you notice something that everyone else appears willing to leave unspoken. Sometimes you have misread the room. Sometimes you have read the room perfectly. You just didn’t realise that what you saw wasn’t supposed to be said out loud.
Sending love to you all,
A
