Controversially, I would say that one of the greatest mistakes we make in mental health is assuming that recovery means the disappearance of symptoms. We measure progress mechanistically by asking questions such as: Are you less anxious? Less depressed? Sleeping better? Experiencing fewer panic attacks? Having fewer intrusive thoughts? These questions do matter, and the level of suffering matters. Similarly, reducing distress matters. However, they are not the whole story; and in fact, when we liberate ourselves from that simplistic focus, we also potentially liberate our clients from their suffering. And should our goals for therapy clients simply be a reduction in symptoms? Do we not want more for them?
Moving away from symptoms
I have worked with many people who became highly skilled at managing symptoms. They learned grounding techniques, developed coping strategies, understood their triggers, and gained insight into their histories. They can coach themselves out of a panic attack, but despite all of this, many still felt that something was missing. Their lives had become organised around avoiding pain, when in fact, pain is an elemental part of life itself.
Panksepp’s (1998) work on affective neuroscience suggested that human beings possess several primary emotional systems, including SEEKING, CARE, FEAR, PLAY, and PANIC/GRIEF. Recovery may therefore involve more than reducing distress. It may also involve reawakening curiosity, engagement, exploration, connection, and playfulness; the very capacities that draw us back into life. We all feel sadness at times, albeit at different levels. Fear is also a vital part of being human – fear is a natural mechanism intended to maintain safety. And Psychotherapy is not about making someone just feel happy all the time. Recovery is not simply about suffering less, but also about living more.
A person may experience anxiety and still live a meaningful life. A person may carry the scars of trauma and still create, love, contribute, explore, and grow. A person may be neurodivergent and still develop extraordinary mastery in areas that matter deeply to them, and potentially others. However, the absence of symptoms does not automatically create fulfilment, and if recovery is solely focused upon that, we miss a trick.
Don’t wait around for symptom removal
Many people spend years waiting for the day they finally feel ‘fixed’ before allowing themselves to live. They postpone ambitions, relationships, creative pursuits, adventures, and opportunities because they believe they must first eliminate every trace of fear, uncertainty, sadness, or vulnerability. Alas, that day rarely arrives, not least because human beings are not machines that can be restored to factory settings.
Life involves uncertainty. It involves loss, disappointment, challenge, and change. Psychological health is not the absence of these realities. It is the capacity to engage with life despite them; to not let them destabilise us to the point of complete shutdown. This is where recovery begins to look very different.
Instead of asking, “How do I get rid of this feeling?” I prefer to ask, “What kind of life do I want to build?” Instead of focusing exclusively on symptoms, we might focus on purpose, and by beginning to discover potential, we liberate ourselves from the here and now pain. Now, don’t get me wrong, I do concur that we only truly have the here and now; this is where reality exists. But we still need a direction of travel.
What life do we want to build?
Instead of measuring success by comfort, we might measure it by engagement. Instead of defining ourselves by diagnoses, we might reconnect with our interests, values, relationships, and aspirations. For some people this means returning to music. For others it means art, education, nature, spirituality, sport, family, community, business, travel, or craftsmanship. The specific activity matters less than the experience of being genuinely involved in life, and doing the thing that we love.
There is something profoundly healing about becoming absorbed in meaningful pursuits, and there is no coincidence that the creative therapies can be so effective. When people discover something they care about deeply, they often find themselves developing qualities that therapy alone cannot provide. This could be discipline by maintaining a daily practice in something, confidence in overcoming fear, resilience in persisting from adversity, patience in our quest to improve, connection and purpose in doing this with others. These qualities do not emerge because suffering disappears first, but emerge in contact. They emerge because people begin participating in life again.
Conclusion
This is why I believe recovery should be viewed as more than symptom reduction. Of course we want people to suffer less, and to begin to function better. However, I also want people to love life more, to discover what excites them, to reconnect with curiosity and self-belief. I want them to build skills, develop strengths, pursue ambitions, and create lives that feel worth living, whilst recognising their individuality, not their pathology.
Most importantly, I want people to recognise that beneath their fear, shame, trauma, diagnoses, and adaptations to difficult experiences, they are fundamentally more than the problems they have faced. Recovery is not returning to who you were before life became difficult. Recovery is discovering who you might become next.
And that, is as yet unwritten, and a potentially wondrous thing.
