The Restless Mind
Mental Health

Is it important to be in person or online for Psychotherapy?

28 May 2022·11 min read

The impact of the pandemic on psychotherapy practice

Many psychotherapists have been working online now for well over two years.  Our sudden introduction to such a way of working happened as a critical response to the pandemic.  No longer deemed safe to be working face to face with people, we had to find alternative ways of still offering services to clients.  So we did.  Colleagues and I developed online materials, and we began the work on a new format in earnest. This article explores both the impact of the pandemic on Gestalt psychotherapy practice, but also the differences from online working.

What happened for psychotherapists? 

Over a short period of time, it was clear that many of us favoured working online during the pandemic.  This was because, when direct contact was allowed, this was often only permitted when wearing masks – for myself at least, attempting psychotherapy with a mask on was a non-starter. So we went online. I have written about some of the inherent challenges elsewhere.

However, at first, we had to adjust to new technology.  As many Gestalt psychotherapists are from the older generations (not inevitable), this wasn’t straightforward.  This meant that many meetings would begin with the usual séance-like questions – are you there, Susan?  Can you hear me, Salma? Screen-pausing happened constantly, and a few psychotherapists stopped working altogether.  This was disappointing and stressful, as the profession began to lose experience within its ranks.  Yet most of us persevered.  

We also found ourselves at the mercy of programmes such as Teams and Zoom, and different organisations began to take up their favourites.  This process created different kinds of challenges. When working at Universities, we were not permitted to use Zoom, even though most people preferred the ease and format of Zoom.  We needed to work effectively with multiple programmes – Zoom, Teams, FaceTime, WhatsApp, and ‘normal’ phone calls.  This created an additional level of complexity, as not only did we need to organise sessions, we needed to stay on top of which programme we would be using for which pieces of work, and to set the rooms up.  We had to stay attentive and organised far more intensely than ever before, and the bureaucracy began to ramp up. And it was exhausting.

Feeling tired…

Some of the exhaustion resulted from the need to focus in on a tiny screen, a much-reduced square of experience from the usual therapeutic space. We were required to attune to our clients in the same level of intensity, with a reduced sensory experience of them. Moving from face-to-face work, where psychotherapists can take in the full phenomenological experience of our client, to online, was difficult. I had colleagues who lamented, ‘We can’t smell them’ (clients).

We noticed that there was also less material to experience.  It wasn’t possible to see everything about our client, and our brains had to fill in the gaps; sometimes accurately, sometimes not. No longer could we notice who came to the consulting room door first.  There was no space to breathe or think on the way up to the room, as the work started immediately.  And it was exhausting. 

And distracting.  Calls came through the computer, both ends, with neither of us anticipating it.  This was distracting from the therapeutic moment.  The distractions also took us away to the person who called.  This began to feel overwhelming, the sense of always being on call, never knowing who would interrupt the sacrosanct therapeutic space.  What rarely happened in person happened often online. And this was aside from the distraction of icons on the screen, new emails arriving, wifi stalling, wanting to check a date in the diary.  It became easier to get distracted, and easier to lose focus.  We had to work harder to stay present, manage the distractions, manage the compulsive and incessant buzz of online activity. 

I noticed that the tolerance of time difference was reduced. All of us quickly learnt to join rooms almost on the dot.  We were all waiting in our rooms, staring at the screen, waiting for the action to start.  And we still do.  I remember the halcyon days when we could tolerate a minute or two here and there.  This is a time gone past, as although time boundaries remain central to effective psychotherapy, people’s expectations are much different.

Urban Legends

As time went on, and conflict between Zoom and Teams rattled on, urban legends began to emerge.  I heard of the group of surgeons, in a meeting, when someone entered the room and shared pornography.  This allegedly led to a police investigation.  This became the reason why we had to use Teams.  I heard other stories.  Kids were making up random room numbers on zoom, and appearing in meetings for a laugh.  No-one did it in any of my meetings.  But the technology certainly didn’t seem to keep up for a while.

There are still differences between Zoom and Teams.  There is no whiteboard in Teams to scribble on and connect with children. Sharing documents within meetings is different for various programmes.  I still don’t have a clue as to how many people can be in either software. The beginning of lectures remains difficult to deliver online as it is impossible to ‘gauge’ the room’s atmosphere.  The silence leads to an often suffocating propensity to project.

We also became face to face with ourselves at a level of intensity none of us had experienced before.  In normal psychotherapy, you don’t have to see yourself at all during the day.  Online, we saw ourselves throughout the day; noticing imperfections, focusing in on self endlessly.  This could sometimes be a distraction from the work.  We all began to develop a complex, seeing ourselves as fat, thin, ugly, old, imperfect… even worse than before! This self-consciousness spread like wildfire across the world.  There became mechanisms to turn off your own screen – people preferred to lose their own image in their subconscious, focusing only on the other.  The thought of seeing ourselves became intolerable. And we projected our fears on to how we imagined others saw us.

But despite the self-conscious staring, we persevered.  I now find it helpful to see myself, and how I’m being seen.  The added awareness helps me adjust what I do even further.  But I think somewhere along the line we began to accentuate our face and our square.  People began to curate their background more, and others began to use artificial ones – I still blur mine at times.  I remember meeting up with a famous psychotherapist, and was in awe of her incredible background – wood hangings, and a desk full of interesting objects.  In a way, this process of seeing oneself fuelled change and growth.  I now continue to reflect far more on how I am seen than I ever did.

The trauma of the pandemic was, however, easily forgotten.  No sooner were we flashed images from China of people dying in the street, leading us to imagining that that would become our fate, we were having fun.  Some of us were enjoying not having to go in to work.  Even though the roads were eerily quiet, like a post-apocalyptic world, we knew there were people behind the curtains, even if we didn’t see them as much.

Outside the consulting room

The supermarkets became an ordeal.  The British in particular were tested for their queue preferences like no other time in history. We queued for everything, patiently, hoping to buy food, wondering if we would starve.  People panic bought – toilet paper was a curious one.  Most of us were horrified at people brawling over packs of toilet rolls, simultaneously judging if there was a need to rush out and grab some rolls.  In fact, I learned it was a copycat behaviour seen on images from Australia – it seems that their toilet roll came from China, but the panic caught on here regardless.  In fact, the panic caught on around the world. And then, when it seemed no-one would go short of toilet roll, the naming and shaming of panic buyers spread, and people had to then try to sell the excess. 

As lockdown eased, I remember that people had to re-face the impact of the trauma on themselves.  I recall a woman being escorted around the supermarket, panicking and hysterical, but needing food.  No longer did we see the huge, scary spaceman masks that had appeared from nowhere, instead we saw people struggling to manage the known risks with needing to live. I honestly stared – the image of the woman’s trauma traumatised me.  The pandemic had certainly been real. The thought of being around people, despite precautions, seemed insurmountable to her.

Kids thrived, though.  Even kids with complex needs, welcomed the chance to go on the computer again.  They picked up the whiteboard and chat functions far quicker than any parent.  They adjusted effortlessly to online therapy, and we messed about with smiley faces and chat.  This offered new, exciting ways of working and engaging with kids.  I noticed they were also the first to ditch masks.  And I noticed my age creeping up as I stared in disbelief at people flouting rules on the street – the pandemic never really seemed a way of joining communities together, more about separation. 

And we cheered on the NHS staff.  I recall myself standing out in the street, cheering them on.  Signs appeared in windows, and it was clear the idea of supporting the NHS staff stuck.  Until the gesture filtered out.  Suddenly no-one was really celebrating them anymore, and life was moving back to normal.

The psychotherapists also had our own experiences to process.  Not only were we still dealing with complex trauma with our clients, there was the added layer of working with their traumatic response to the pandemic.  And our own.  We too lost friends and family.  We too were denied the ability to touch relatives in care homes.   We had to manage this to present a semblance of normality back in the consulting room.  Of course, we wanted to talk and gossip like every other human out there, but our profession prevented that.  We had to be there for others, not ourselves. And this was difficult – our own lives were impacted, and our own isolation grew. But we had to continue to serve the client.

And here we find ourselves, back where we started, but scarred.  We all were.  But is it better to be back in person?

Back in person work

I can now smell my clients again – long having lost the olfactory sense of the other person.  I notice the kind of smells, the perfume they wear, the clothing.  I see the whole person, not just the curated part.  I notice how they walk up the stairs, if the shoulders are hunched, if they have water, and I begin my analysis of the process. 

And they notice me.  They see me drink from my flask, and notice when I shift position and at what point. We breathe the same air for that moment in the room. We connect as humans, as we always have, using the senses we have. The work feels more real, and easier to achieve depth of connection.  I didn’t realise how much I longed to be back in person.

I can use Gestalt experimentation again in the room.  I can offer two chair experiences, and I can offer more creativity in what we choose to play with. My attunement to the client process is more acute.  I can observe families play games, and I can notice sounds around me.  The contact is, in person, infinitely superior to that online.  My whole sensory phenomenology is alive, and feel as though I am reconnecting with the client’s whole field, rather than the square. 

I relish the opportunity to be back in person with someone else.  The face-to-face work feels more alive, more vibrant, what I’ve always done.  Many of us ran back to the consulting room, craving real contact. Some of us still work online, this isn’t an inferior way of working, but it is very different, different challenges, different possibilities.  I now find myself to be a more rounded psychotherapist, improved by the need to adapt.  This evolutionary enables me to integrate my experience more, and that of the client. 

So the pandemic has provided challenges and opportunities.  But as we have returned to in person work, I realise the infinite superiority of face-to-face work.  For me.  In person connection is more profound, more alive; real. And I hope the profession doesn’t turn their back on this way of being.

Receive new essays

New pieces arrive infrequently and without filler. No newsletters about newsletters. Just writing, when there is something worth saying.