The Restless Mind
Blog

Self-immolation as a way to challenge climate disaster

8 May 2022·8 min read

Trigger warning – this article contains reference to and discussion about suicide and climate change.

The story of the modern day martyr…

Last week I came across a podcast by Marianne Williamson, a favourite of mine.  Marianne is always somehow able to penetrate the minds of her viewers and guests, and I always take something away to helpfully reflect on further.  This episode left me more moved than usual, and certainly more to think about in my own life as it introduced the idea of self-immolation as a way to challenge climate disaster.

The episode in question was with the climate scientist, Peter Kalmus. The episode had me hooked, not merely because the topic interests me, but because there was reference to the self-immolation of Wynn Bruce.  I had never consciously come across either Bruce or the idea of self-immolation.  I know what self-immolation was, but I don’t think I have ever talk to someone about it, possibly just read about it across the years. I was horrified, alarmed, and intrigued as to what had led to this.

If you haven’t come across Self-immolation, this essentially refers to the process of a human setting fire to themselves.  I know, horrifying.  Self-immolation as a way to challenge climate disaster seems to be the next way climate activists can challenge the world’s lack of progress. What I found even more horrifying, was that there have been waves of self-immolation across the world, throughout time.  On the 1st January, 2022, someone even self-immolated to protest the Covid-19 vaccination.  Now, that definitely never made the news!  In India, there were around 1,548 self-immolations alone between 2000 and 2001.  The information about the act itself leaves me gobsmacked, horrified, and afraid, not least because this is kept from popular news. And this is aside from the various reasons that people make such a choice. 

What happened?

On the 22nd April, 2022, Bruce decided to self-immolate in protest against climate change. So impacted by the lack of progress with making appropriate changes around the world, Bruce covered himself in a flammable liquid, and set it alight on the steps of the supreme court building.  He wrote a note, which apologised for those who had to deal with the aftermath. Some people attributed his suggestibility to brain injury he sustained in a car accident in 1989.  That his act was reduced in this way leaves me insulted for the conscious choice that Bruce made. There is a presumption, however, that his act was conscious, intentional, and made of sound mind.

Ultimately, this was an incident, or spectacle, designed to remind the world of the danger we are in. Thich Nhát Hanh, who wrote in 1965 on the self-immolation of Buddhist monks, that, “… to burn oneself by fire is to prove that what one is saying is of the utmost importance.” I imagine that Bruce’s self-immolation was also designed to show the world the level of importance he places on this.

What I was initially influenced by was Kalmus’ claims that the event was hardly reported on. I became a little paranoid and annoyed, wondering why the Government would cover this up. Indeed, I was not aware of it until I had heard the podcast.  However, upon searching the t’interweb, it is clear that the incident was reported variously, and that this reflected, perhaps, Kalmus’ frustration and own paranoia about the government. Let’s call it counter-transference. It may not have been reported as widely as Kalmus would have wished, but it is certainly there.  I guess that the media has to be careful in how it reports such an event, simply because of the distress such an event could trigger in people.

I also imagine that Kalmus was hoping for greater responses to the event than what we have seen.  There doesn’t appear to be any government rushing to reassure the public.  I certainly do not see any government radically revising their response to climate change, and doing anything immediate or helpful to the crisis we are in.  In fact, for governments such as our own rabble, they are actively developing plans to worsen the situation through the development of eight new nuclear power stations.  We’ll come to that another time, let’s think a bit deeper on the process of self-immolation.

Self-immolation in history

In history, self-immolation has been associated much with religion.  Even today, there are associations between buddhism and self-immolation.  Whilst most do not consider Buddhism a religion, the practice does engender a certain fervour for the benefits of the practice that practitioners experience. However, there are also deeper political connotations underpinning much of the self-immolation process.

For Bruce, this was clearly the climate situation.  But I wonder if it is just desperation that drives people to self-immolate. Even with issues such as the climate crisis, I don’t see that self-immolation is the only or ultimate way to effect change. Are there truly no other options available?  If the act you undertake ends up in your own death, you clearly expect an impact on the world, not just locally.  But in erasing yourself from the world, you actually remove your support and power within the world.  In a way self-immolation strengthens climate denial, it doesn’t reduce it.

I wonder if it is desperation that pushes people to douse themselves in accelerant and light a match?  Are people so desperately worried by something in the world, that it is desperation that drives the act?  I don’t buy this position fully.  In reality, if it was desperation – that intolerable mix of frustration, exasperation, fear, and panic – it is more likely to result in an unplanned act, not one which requires planning and patience, and often determination.  And actual management of all the feelings to ensure the act is accomplished in the anticipated way.

I see self-immolation as a manipulation, albeit a profound one.  The act is designed to impact people, and make them wake up.  Bruce wants the world to wake up to what he sees as climate disaster.  But in a way, by ending his life, he accelerates the process of climate change as we now lack another ally. 

Copycats…

But why the silence from governments?  Did they wish to avoid copycat behaviour?  Copycat behaviour is a well-known phenomenon (read The Copycat Effect by Loren Coleman (as a start), whereby people act out something they have seen on media.  Copycat behaviours don’t have to be self-immolation, they can more frequently occur with regards to crime.  If you think about the Will Smith debacle, it was not a mere coincidence that Dave Chappelle then found himself in a similar position to Chris Rock.  Copycatting is real, and requires caution. 

The danger in attributing the lack of governmental response is that they do not wish to be seen as reacting to an act of self-immolation, as this will suggest to the world that you only need to self-immolate to control government decision making.  Now that would be especially dangerous.  So in a way, I think it is important that the government does, on the one hand, not have a knee jerk reaction to the act.  However, I do think it is equally important that they do something more in response to climate change. 

Will we choose life or death?

Bruce was, however, on the side of nature, and gave up the ultimate gift to the world, his life.  Bruce was on the side of abundance, nature, and, as such, life, opportunity, and healing.  In supporting everything that nature has to offer, Bruce valued life and progress.  We either support and protect that which protects us, or we support the opposite – destruction, death, and annihilation.  For myself, there is no choice. I support life.  I support growth.  I support diversity. 

Alarmingly, there is much about humanity that supports the latter rather than the former.  Putin has repeatedly and explicitly and consciously stated that he will, under specific circumstances, trigger cataclysmic events.  He has repeatedly expressed an intention to use nuclear warfare.  One of his media goons has also stated that Britain itself could be completely wiped out by one of their weapons. 

When I hear such comments I am, myself, filled with deep despair and horror. There is a complete lack of any positive in any part of that process.  In fact, I can’t even empathise with it – the disregard for life is an utter abomination, regardless of justification. I fail to understand what drives people in such positions of power to abuse that position.  The lack of empathy for life I can comprehend in itself, the wish to act on that lack of empathy is not.  And here I do not just mean my own life, but the lives of their own families.

So we will forget Bruce’s act very soon.  We will get on with our lives, and we will continue to subconsciously expect the governments to fix our problem.  We will do our ‘bit’ – through recycling, and maybe even trying to use the car less.  But the climate disaster will trundle on.  And governments will benefit from it financially, and the world will remain stuck in check mate, expecting everyone else to do something that they could start with, until our annihilation arrives.  And this is the problem, and perhaps also contributes to Bruce’s self-immolation – the world lacks the compassion to act in a robust way.  It is only through the development of compassion, and empathy, that we will do anything different. Let’s just hope that others do not follow Bruce’s suit.

Is it not time to start the process of change?

Receive new essays

New pieces arrive infrequently and without filler. No newsletters about newsletters. Just writing, when there is something worth saying.