Is your child controlling?
As a psychotherapist, much of my work involves helping families where children have experienced abuse or neglect. I try not to use the word ‘trauma’ so much as it’s imprecise, and I’ve talked about this issue here. In this article I not only ask is your child controlling, but offer three ways to manage the control differently.
One of the key symptoms that I work with most commonly is that of control. Control is a way of managing the internal dysregulation that is activated almost constantly in child who have experienced trauma. However, any child can learn to be controlling. Under the control is often fear and anger, and being in control lessens these feelings. Thus, in this article I will explore the issue of control and provide three ways to manage controlling kids.
Prevalence
I just want to say a few words about child on parent violence. This is because control can be linked to violence. I should say that, in adolescence, the risk of child on parent violence in adopted families especially is high. This used to be called abused parent syndrome, but is now referred to as child on parent violence (Madden, 1979). Although difficult to talk about and unlikely statistically, the risk can – in extreme circumstances – escalate to murder. I share this because it is important to be clear and safe.
The prevalence of CPV is difficult to accurately ascertain, due to secrecy, methodologies, and samples. Also, there are important cultural differences in how this kind of violence is seen (Aroca-Montolío et al
2014). However, it’s vital that cultural projections don’t impact the robustness of your work; this was a key learning from the Victoria Climbié review. Violence is violence. And any intervention where there is violence and high risks need to be approached with careful consideration so as to not escalate the situation. My suggestion is that if your child is violent, you seek professional help immediately.
Here follows some suggestions for children demonstrating different kinds of controlling behaviour for the lower end of challenges. I have only provided three areas of control, although they seem to be the most frequently arising in my clinic. They are only suggestions, be creative in your family, and let me know how it goes.
Control of space
Some children get to the stage where they cannot tolerate parents coming in to their room. or certain places in the home There is a normality to this. However, when parents are not allowed in at all, where they find themselves skirting around the issue, it’s time for action. Parents need to know their children are safe, supported, and loved, and this involves being present in virtually all areas of their lives. My suggestion is as follows.
Firstly, be clear with the child that there is a need for adults to enter their room, and this will need to happen. Agree the boundaries for this (i.e. knock before entering) – it is not ok to enter their room any time – and stick to them. Don’t agree something then change your mind. Constancy will feel safer than unpredictability, and therefore lead to better outcomes.
Build trust over time through developing recognised and regular ways of being with the child. But remain clear and focused on the reality of you being the adult, the decision maker, and the person who will be managing your house. This is linked to the idea of parental presence. Our effectiveness will be improved if we are not just physically present in our children’s lives, but also emotionally and spiritually.
Control of time
Many children, whatever age, try to push the time boundaries. We all know that teenager who won’t get up for school, and some of us know that child who won’t come home on time. Respect of time boundaries is fairly obvious. If you don’t get up for school, you’ll be late, and this will ultimately impact learning. If you are late home, especially in the dark, the risks of something happening is higher.
Playing with time boundaries builds up over time. It can creep in insidiously, until we’re at screaming pitch. Weaknesses in the time boundaries can be reflected in challenges elsewhere. This can usually be great practice for improving wider difficulties at home.
My suggestion is to again explain the importance of time boundaries. Encourage the child to understand this, check that they do, and agree what you can expect from each other moving forwards. For younger children, the old star chart may be a helpful way of setting up a new way of doing it. However, success may not last indefinitely, so be prepared to return to the idea of maintenance, and offer different incentives. We are most likely to repeat something that is rewarded, than something which we ignore.
Control of food
This can be a particularly worrying area of control. If your child has other behaviours that are consistent with an eating disorder, then I recommend you get this checked out professionally. However, if your child is just fussy, or an over-eater, read on.
Much processed food is laden with sugar, salt, and fat. This means that other food will just not taste as sparky. If your child loves their ice cream, but won’t eat their mash, you need to think about this. My suggestion is to firstly ensure that food at the table is fresh and prepared at home where possible. I also recommend that food is only served at the table, with the whole family when you can. This encourages dialogue, better posture, bonding, and better digestion. And if you can light candles (safely!), and put napkins out, we know that the food will taste better and be more appealing, even to kids, when the table is set. Perhaps encourage them to do the setting?
The kitchen is definitely a screen free room. This will improve attention and focus at mealtimes. Also, it is important that we do not encourage food to be considered a reward. Food is for maintenance of the body. Working with this idea ensures children don’t also become emotional eaters. And as for the above two points, it’s important for children to realise that adults set the menu. Children’s can’t tolerate too much choice, so be present also at mealtimes in deciding what your family will eat.
Thinking more about change
It might be that your child already has well-established, rigid food habits. My suggestion, again, is to scale the process of change. Grade the changes into tiny, achievable chunks, so that the change you need to see is imperceptible. If it is to eat greens, start with expecting them to eat one pea. Then two. Over weeks rather than days. Over time, they will be eating as you need them to. I have written on the process of change here, which explains why we have to go slow and steady.
Final Thoughts
We often, through kindness, build a rod for our own backs. We want to be permissive and kind, and this ends up feeling unsupportive to children. There is nothing wrong with a loving boundary, and it is vital you remember that you are the adult. This means your child will feel safe enough to be a child, and not a child parent.
I hope this helps, let me know how it goes, and what else you need ideas on.
Much love,
Dr. Andrew x