Why now?
You might be wondering, why would I want to talk about the moon as a professional psychotherapist. Why should a psychotherapist be seen as fuelling the public perception of the Moon? As we have recently just began a new moon cycle, I thought it would be pertinent to offer a few reflections on the idea of the moon and its relationship to mental health. I have experienced my own mental health in a rather interesting way this month, and I do believe there was some relationship with the cycle of the moon. Thus, I decided to make some investigations and find out for myself whether or not this was either an old wives’ tale, or something corroborated by evidence.
This effect during the full moon is also called the Transylvania effect. This word obviously has associations with Dracula and vampires, and is more symbolic of the dark sky and full moon’s eerie silver gleam. I feel that this word is more romantic and less pragmatic, so I tend not to use this terminology as I find it less helpful. I also tend not to use the Lunacy effect, due to negative connotations with the word.
History of the idea of the Moon
Most of us have or will have formulated some sense of what the moon means to us. We may have associations of the Moon with science fiction or horror movies. Some of us may associate the moon with religious or spiritual practices. Others may have a more biological relationship or connection with the moon. Whatever your association, they are all valid, and I make no attempt to persuade or dissuade you of anything. But how did our ancestors view the moon?
In history, the moon was always significant. In pre-scientific times, we created Deities of the Moon in order to explain the wonder of how it changes each month. There are Moon Deities across the world suggesting the wonder and fear that the Moon invoked in humanity. My particular favourites are the pagan deities such as Hekate and Ceridwen.
In some cultures around the world we have associated the moon with changes in human behaviour. For centuries, people have believed that the moon affects human behaviour. If we look at the word, Lunacy, the translation from Latin is lunaticus. Both Aristotle and Pliny the Elder (the Roman naturalist), both thought that madness and epilepsy were caused by The Moon. Pliny also suggested that it is during the full moon that we see more dew forming, and the increase in moisture leads to increasing moisture in the brain, which is subsequently said to lead to madness. There are obvious problems with this argument, as the same effect isn’t recorded when swimming!
Even in the 1700s a British legal expert wrote that a lunatic sometimes is lucid and sometimes is not, frequently depending upon the changes of the moon. There was also a popular book in the 1970s that posited the effect of the Moon on biological tides and human emotions. In this book, an eminent psychiatrist presented evidence which indicated that the moon affected not only man’s geophysical environment but also his day-to-day behaviour.
The Moon and Art
Most of us will have had our subconscious triggered by Moon art. Many artists have been inspired to draw the moon, and the range and variety of the art which conceptualises the moon is incredible. Are there images of the moon that have stuck in your consciousness? How about Van Gogh? How many of us know not only his art but also his own mental illness?
The Moon more generally…
There is lots of other interesting material out there. There have been associations also with pregnant women being more likely to give birth on a full moon, but the evidence based on this is inconsistent. However, there is evidence that violence amongst psychiatric patients of prison inmates and even outdoor criminal activity such as incidents occurring on the streets. Even in natural settings such as beaches are communities, incidents may also be higher when there is more Moonlight. However, this evidence is also somewhat controversial. Some academics will claim that there is not one single replicated finding in the literature that suggests a link between the full moon and changes in behaviour. However, some of these studies start to make this claim do not hold up to scrutiny.
In fact, the monthly and annual cycles of the moon as it passes across the night sky, has shown a truly remarkable similarity to patterns of mood swings in, for example, some psychiatric patients. But what does the evidence actually say?
The Moon and Sleep
Thomas Wehr studied the sleep phenomena in 2013 under the highly controlled conditions of a sleep laboratory. He found that people took longer to fall asleep on average and slept for 20 minutes less around a full moon. This was compared to the rest of the month, even though they weren’t exposed to any Moonlight. Measurement of the brain activity, however, suggested that the amount of Deep Sleep they experience dropped by 30% during a full moon. However, a follow-up study failed to replicate these findings. Wehr maintains that his patients fell into one of two categories. Some mood swings appear to follow a 14.8 day cycle, whereas others follow to 13.7 day cycle, and some switched between the cycles. I find this evidence fairly compelling.
I think it is also equally compelling to remember that the tide follows the course of the moon, taking two weeks each side, like Wehr’s sleep cycle, to ebb and flow. In terms of explanation, this is not so straightforwards. Many people have suggested that it is about moonlight that affects people. In reality, we are exposed to unnatural levels of light throughout our day as we sit staring in to the brooding matrix box of the computer. It must be something else. I always return to the gravitational pull as, even though the saying is that a mosquito offers more of an effect. How else could our brains and circadian rhythms be affected?
The Moon and Health
For there is also a relationship between the moon and health. One study reported a 19% increase in the risk of heart attack or stroke. This was from a large, population-based study, with good levels of rigour. Another collected data from 263 U.S. cities and found high associations between lunar activity and increased mortality risk from heart attacks. From my reading of the material, it is clear that there is some relationship, the issue is that there needs to be even more research in an attempt to substantiate this further. And perhaps we should also remember the tiny sea plant, Arabadopsis thaliana. This plant completes a growth cycle each 24.8 hours, the cycle of the moon. None of the growth stages are huge or dramatic, but it does complete in this time. Perhaps the answer lies in the depth of the phenomenon, not the breadth?
My analysis
It is clear that there is a relationship between the moon and mental health. Even though ‘science’ may not agree, this may suggest more about the method than the reality. Is science so comprehensive and unified?
Science isn’t everything (although it is a lot), and I am minded to support something which has occurred for thousands of years – doesn’t the longevity of human recording and noticing count for anything? Could we ever truly make a problem free experiment to measure this? We cannot fabricate an alternative moon!
And ultimately, I encourage my readers to find their own position. What is your evidence? What have you seen that works for you? When I recall my own relationship with the moon, I always check where we are within the cycle. If I am ever in difficulty, I am almost always nearing a new or full moon. This isn’t inevitable or happening every time, but this is my reality. And I encourage you to do the same. Monitor the connection between cycles and what’s happening for you.
Workbook
As always, I encourage readers to get out their workbook at the end of my articles. I find it always helpful to at least write a few words, or draw a few squiggles to connect with the idea of the article. Let me know what comes up for you!
- Draw a mind map, free-associating the moon. What words or ideas do you come up with?
2. Write down the films which you associate with the moon. Any surprises?
3. Think of other art you know of that reflects the moon.
4. Think about the way in which your family processes the moon. What do they say about it? How does this impact your perception?
5. Monitor your own mental health in the coming months, and record any blips in your mental health. Is there a connection between the moon cycle?
Finally, stay safe, take support where you need it, and continue to nurture the adult inside you. You can do this.
Dr. Andrew x