The Restless Mind
Masculinity

Why Are We Becoming More Alone?

19 May 2026·8 min read

Male ambivalence about relationships, and the intimacy social contract

Introduction: The Café and the Question

A few weeks ago, I was invited to an event at a large café in a beautiful area of the country organised by a group of single women hoping to meet men, or at least make meaningful connections. They seemed intelligent and successful, but I did not attend. I am not single, and if I were, the event sounded like my idea of a nightmare if I’m honest, like pressured speed dating. I understood later that few, if any, men attended. And if I’m honest, I’m not surprised.

Whilst this anecdote proves little by itself, social life is messy, and undergoing rapid change. Nevertheless, it prompted reflection on a broader pattern increasingly discussed in research, media, and everyday conversation. This is, that many women are actively interested in long-term partnership, particularly between 25-45, while a growing number of men seem hesitant, ambivalent, or disengaged from pursuing it altogether.

But why?

The answer is unlikely to be simple. Loneliness, singleness, and changing relationship patterns cannot be reduced to ideology or blame. Nor can they be explained through simplistic narratives about ‘failing men’ or ‘demanding women’. Instead, modern intimacy appears to be undergoing rapid renegotiation. In that renegotiation, many people, particularly men, may be experiencing increasing uncertainty about where they belong, what is expected of them, and whether contemporary partnership still offers the reciprocity, stability, and meaning they seek.

This article explores that possibility.

The Loneliness Paradox

Modern society is paradoxical. As you know, we are more technologically connected than at any point in human history, yet many people reliably claim that they have never been so lonely or isolated. This is borne out in research on Western societies.

Research has identified growing levels of loneliness, especially among younger adults and men. Social institutions that once offered comprehensive and expected connection, such as churches, neighbourhood communities, extended families, stable workplaces, and local associations, have weakened over time. Technology has drawn us into the screen and out of life. Digital communication provides immediacy but not depth. And is not real, in the real sense of the word.

This phenomenon is not exclusively male. Loneliness affects everyone alike, regardless of gender. Yet its process differs variously.

Men have typically relied more heavily on romantic relationships for emotional intimacy than women – they will take their emotional world into intimate relationships, but rarely elsewhere. Women tend to maintain broader friendship and support networks. When relationships become delayed, unstable, or absent, some men may experience emotional isolation more acutely, and this is evidenced in the increase in risk to women particularly when relationships end.

This does not necessarily mean men desire relationships less. Indeed, the opposite may be true. Many men still seek intimacy, family life, and emotional belonging. The issue is how to pursue it or whether the contemporary relational environment feels psychologically or socially navigable.

Dating in the Age of Algorithms

Contemporary dating differs profoundly from previous generations, as many know. Historically, relationships often emerged through shared social environments such as workplaces, religious communities, friendship networks, or local neighbourhoods. You were more likely to marry someone who lived within twenty minutes of your house.  Modern dating increasingly occurs through digital platforms that operate according to market logic – we can fall in love with someone in a different country, and communicate far more systematically with them than ever before.

This shift matters. Bruch and colleagues (2018), examining online dating behaviour, found that individuals also commonly pursue partners perceived as more desirable than themselves, often by approximately 25%. While aspiration is hardly new, dating applications amplify comparative processes, transforming attraction into a highly visible and competitive marketplace.  Increased choice, paradoxically, may reduce satisfaction. Or opportunity.

When presented with abundant options, people frequently become more selective, more cautious, and less willing to commit – we become spoiled for choice, literally.  Potential partners can begin to resemble endlessly replaceable profiles rather than emotionally complex individuals. The fact it rarely takes place in person also matters here. 

Communication patterns also remain strongly gendered. Zhang and Yasseri (2016) found that men initiate the majority of early online conversations. This finding complicates simplistic assumptions about male disengagement. Men are often still approaching, still risking rejection, and still attempting connection. Yet repeated rejection, limited reciprocity, or algorithmically structured disappointment may gradually foster disengagement or fatigue.

The dating environment itself has changed. Relationships now develop within a context of increased visibility, comparison, and perceived competition.

This transformation may be affecting both sexes, though not necessarily in identical ways.

Male Relational Ambivalence

Discourse in the public eye invariably frames male singleness through pathology. Men are described as avoidant, emotionally stunted, commitment-phobic, or immature; we are not sold as attractive, reliable partners full of possibility. While such characteristics may apply to some individuals, they are insufficient as global explanations for social interaction.

A more psychologically nuanced concept may be relational ambivalence. Ambivalence differs from rejection. An ambivalent man may desire intimacy while simultaneously fearing disappointment, scrutiny, dependency, or failure. He may long for partnership yet feel uncertain about its costs or viability. He may want closeness while remaining unconvinced that contemporary relationships provide security or reciprocity. These dynamics are not unfamiliar in psychotherapy practice. 

Many men describe relationships as involving increasing emotional, financial, and legal uncertainty alongside changing expectations around masculinity, vulnerability, provision, and commitment. Some experience these shifts positively. Greater emotional openness and more flexible gender roles can be liberating. Yet others experience uncertainty.

What exactly is expected of modern men?

Should they provide, or reject provider roles? Lead, or avoid appearing controlling? Display vulnerability, but not weakness? Demonstrate emotional intelligence while navigating conflicting cultural messages about masculinity itself? Ambivalence often emerges where expectations become unclear. If you don’t know what you want them to do, how can they do it?

When norms become unstable, hesitation often follows.

The Problem with Deficit Narratives

An increasingly common explanation for male relational difficulty involves what might be termed the ‘skills deficit’ narrative; men are inadequate. According to this perspective, men struggle in modern relationships because they have not developed sufficient emotional literacy, communication skills, or relational competence.

Certainly, emotional skills matter. Healthy relationships are complex and demanding, requiring empathy, reflection, patience, and psychological maturity. But there are generally two people doing the tango, both with a role, both with expectations, both with presence. And deficit-based explanations deserve scrutiny in case they become self-fulfilling.

Social psychological research repeatedly demonstrates that identity is shaped through social expectation and internalised evaluation. When individuals are repeatedly positioned as deficient, dangerous, emotionally inadequate, or developmentally behind, such narratives can influence behaviour and self-concept. This is not merely theoretical.

Men increasingly encounter cultural messaging suggesting they are emotionally underdeveloped, relationally unsafe, or fundamentally unequipped for intimacy. While criticism of harmful male behaviour is often justified, broader generalisations may carry unintended consequences, not just for men.

Do people move towards relationships when they feel respected and capable?

The answer matters.

Deficit narratives may unintentionally foster shame, defensiveness, and withdrawal rather than growth. This is particularly relevant within psychotherapy and helping professions, where compassion should ideally extend across gender rather than becoming selectively distributed. A psychologically informed culture should challenge harmful behaviour without collapsing complex individuals into stereotypes.

Beyond Heteronormative Assumptions

These questions should not be confined exclusively to heterosexual relationships. LGBTQ+ communities may offer important insights. Research suggests same-sex relationships can sometimes operate with greater flexibility regarding gender roles and relational expectations. While these relationships are by no means free from conflict or inequality, they may reveal alternative models of intimacy less dependent upon inherited masculine and feminine scripts. And sometimes those scripts can thrive within queer communities – bitch and butch etc.

This raises important questions. Are certain relational tensions tied specifically to gender expectations? Or are they broader consequences of contemporary individualism and social fragmentation?

More comparative research is needed.

Conclusion: Not Blame, but Dialogue

Why are we becoming more alone? Not one single explanation adequately suffices. Technology, economics, shifting gender norms, changing expectations, and evolving cultural identities all appear relevant. Loneliness is not merely personal, it is social. And I would argue chronic.

Male relational ambivalence should not be interpreted simply as misogyny, immaturity, or withdrawal from responsibility. Nor should contemporary women be blamed for pursuing autonomy or expecting emotionally healthier relationships.

Actually, perhaps we are witnessing something deeper… The social contract of intimacy is changing. Old scripts no longer fully fit, but new ones remain unfinished; in ways, they haven’t even been described. In this transitional space, many people continue to seek love, belonging, and partnership while simultaneously feeling uncertain about how to achieve them. Our job, as helpers, is to support the transition safely, carefully, and doing our own work at the same time.

References

Bruch, E., Thomas, R., Newman, M., & Clauset, A. (2018). Aspirational pursuit of mates in online dating markets. Science Advances, 4(8).

Zhang, Y., & Yasseri, T. (2016). What happens after you both swipe right? A statistical description of mobile dating communications. arXiv preprint.

Cacioppo, J. T., & Patrick, W. (2008). Loneliness: Human Nature and the Need for Social Connection. New York: Norton.

Putnam, R. D. (2000). Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community. New York: Simon & Schuster.

Twenge, J. M. (2017). iGen. New York: Atria Books.

Receive new essays

New pieces arrive infrequently and without filler. No newsletters about newsletters. Just writing, when there is something worth saying.