The Restless Mind
Spirituality

Psychotherapy, Algorithms, and the Loss of Human Becoming

26 May 2026·6 min read

Psychotherapy is still a relatively young profession, perhaps 80 years old. In many ways, psychotherapy emerged into the cultural space left behind by declining religious authority. Where priests once invited confession and promised absolution, therapists offered reflection, meaning, and healing. People entered consulting rooms hoping that, through speaking openly about themselves and their suffering, life might become more manageable. And often, it did. And psychotherapists filled the gap that the withdrawal from religion left.

Indeed, there is something profoundly valuable about being offered a safe, respectful, and attentive space in which to speak honestly. Many people experience therapy as life changing. But psychotherapy was never the complete answer to human suffering, nor was its history entirely benign. Much of early psychotherapy was shaped by white, educated, middle-class men, frequently theorising about populations whose lives and realities differed greatly from their own. Therapy was frequently inaccessible to poorer communities, to men, and to people of colour. Some approaches also carried the risk of dependence, professional mystique, and exaggerated claims about therapeutic omnipotence. Some could easily be called Cults. Then something else happened.

As psychology professionalised and healthcare systems expanded, we became increasingly invested in measuring and quantifying human experience. Commissioners, researchers, and institutions understandably wanted evidence that treatment worked. Human distress became something to categorise, score, and statistically analyse. We developed questionnaires to measure human experience, often believing this to be unequivocal. 

This brought benefits as research matters. Accountability matters. Ineffective or harmful interventions should rightly be challenged. But measurement also introduced its own distortions. Human experience is extraordinarily complex, and not everything that matters can be easily reduced to a questionnaire or algorithm. 

Over time, systems increasingly sought therapies that were brief, measurable, and cost-effective. This inevitably shaped research priorities and service provision. Cognitive and behavioural approaches, particularly C.B.T., gained prominence, not only because they could help many people, but because they lent themselves more readily to manualisation, standardisation, and outcome measurement. This is not an argument against C.B.T., as this approach has helped countless people and remains a valuable approach. But problems emerge whenever any model is elevated into orthodoxy.

The danger lies in mistaking one useful tool for the entire toolbox.

As shorter, manualised approaches became increasingly dominant in many settings, longer-term and relational therapies often found themselves pushed to the margins. Commissioners sought efficiency. Services faced budgetary pressure. Therapy increasingly became framed around symptom reduction rather than wider transformation.  Then came the algorithm.

Ironically, the same characteristics that helped certain therapies flourish within healthcare systems also made them easier to replicate technologically. Manualised thinking translates readily into digital systems, scripted interventions, and increasingly sophisticated AI-driven mental health tools. Some of these developments are genuinely useful because digital resources can increase access, provide psychoeducation, and offer practical support. But we should also ask difficult questions about what may be lost when human complexity is filtered through increasingly automated systems. We should also ask why humans are so influenced by algorithmic interventions, to the point of sycophantic and delusional escalation.

Psychotherapy, at its best, was never simply about techniques, but about a reparative human relationship. Psychotherapy was about remaining present with another human being in real time, resisting easy answers, and attending to the unfolding complexity of a person’s life. And perhaps here lies one of the profession’s own paradoxes. While psychotherapists often remained deeply committed to relational work, many failed to articulate or evidence what they were doing in ways that wider systems could understand. Focused rightly upon the client, the profession sometimes neglected the political, scientific, and technological forces reshaping the landscape around it. This is still the case – whilst the work does speak for itself, the system does not necessarily grapple with the need to research in the way that the manualised therapies understand. 

Meanwhile, the medical model increasingly shaped how distress itself was understood. It is clear that the medical model has strengths, and should not be dismissed outright. Severe mental illness deserves careful assessment, protection, and evidence-informed care. Yet when applied too rigidly to ordinary human suffering, relational pain, developmental trauma, or existential struggle, something important can be lost. It is my view that human beings become symptoms, diagnoses, and, ultimately, objects. And treatment becomes narrowly focused upon symptom management rather than the wider project of living.

Personally, I am not interested only in reducing distress. I am not interested in offering six sessions of symptom management and calling this healing, particularly when many such strategies can be learned from books, apps, or structured programmes. What interests me is something far more profound.

If I am forthright, I want clients to experience safety, care, honesty, and respect. I want them to emerge from psychotherapy understanding themselves more fully, including the ways they may have absorbed limiting or painful messages from the world around them. I want them to explore how trauma, shame, attachment, and relationship patterns operate not simply in theory, but in real time. I want them to build themselves deliberately and on their own terms, and I want to use as much reliable information from the world as I am able. 

This is not magic, and I would never profess to having a magic wand. Nor is the work I offer ‘perfection’. Psychotherapists make mistakes, and I certainly have/do. I can own this because I’ve done my own work. I would also argue that some therapeutic models remain strangely frozen in time, practised today much as they were decades ago. I can go to some institutes and largely predict their syllabus; not because I’m intelligent, but because the syllabi do not develop – the ‘founding fathers’ have gone, and there is no individual taking the mantle in the way they did. How can they? It isn’t theirs. 

Our profession is hardly beyond critique, but nor should we ignore what is lost when therapy becomes excessively manualised or transactional. Many psychotherapists recognise a familiar pattern in contemporary practice.  People arrive having previously engaged with approaches that felt overly formulaic, rushed, or disconnected from their deeper experience. They describe feeling unheard, reduced, or processed rather than understood. I’m sure many of you will get this, even if it generates defensiveness in other quarters. 

At the other extreme, we now see the rise of parts of the coaching industry, where profound psychological work may be undertaken by individuals with little training in trauma, attachment, or relational process. Sometimes this helps. Sometimes it risks harm. Ultimately, none of this is simple, and nor should we adopt simplistic approaches.

However, my wider question is, what is psychotherapy ultimately for? If you say that the answer is merely symptom reduction, then increasingly sophisticated manuals and algorithms may eventually suffice. But if psychotherapy is also about helping people reclaim agency, deepen relationships, rediscover meaning, and become more fully themselves, then the human relationship remains central.

I want my clients not simply to suffer less, but to help them to love life again. I want them to recognise that, beneath their shame, their fear, their trauma, and their adjustments to things that they should never have needed to adjust to, they are fundamentally ok. And I hope for something more than just temporary symptom relief. I want their financial investment to last, and for them to discover even mastery of something; a process that strengthens who they are as a person, deepens their contact with life, and helps them navigate future difficulties with confidence and self trust. 

Psychotherapy should never be that endless revolving door of survival, but about helping them move way beyond coping, and towards a life in which they thrive. This is what I endeavour to offer – if you would like to hear me talk more about this, then please sign up to my newsletter, and/or get in touch.

Andrew 

Receive new essays

New pieces arrive infrequently and without filler. No newsletters about newsletters. Just writing, when there is something worth saying.