The Restless Mind
Blog

Five pieces of advice to controlling people

31 Aug 2022·8 min read

‘Five pieces of advice to controlling people’ is the title of today’s article. This arises from reading another article online. I had read this article about a woman who has married a traveller man. I hope you share the sentiments I am going to offer. However, I also think I need to stop reading online news articles altogether – is it me, or is the news so trauma-driven, and anxiety provoking? I’m not sure what it’s like for you, but I imagine it’s very similar. Anyway, onwards we must go.

The article

Firstly, the woman in the article spoke volubly about how much in love she was with her husband. This sounded lovely. I was impressed with how love could exist so passionately in this day and age. She then explained how she was not allowed to go out without her husband, unless it was to get her hair done. The woman also had to ensure the house was immaculate for when he returned to the house, whereas he could go wherever he wanted to. She went on and on about how lovely this was, and how supported she felt in this relationship. I had to read it twice as I thought I was having a senior moment.

But no, I had read what I read.

Observations

What I first noticed from the article was that there was absolutely no hint or suggestion of anything challenging within the relationship. The relationship was ALL wonderful, with no conflict, or sense of disagreement. And entirely polarised in favour of the man. The woman was entirely compliant and ostensibly supportive of her husband.

Let’s be clear, no-one in a relationship agrees on everything with our partners. Some people in relationships struggle to find any agreement. And safe conflict is healthy, vital even to ensure people are honest, and therefore able to trust each other. That this dream state was painted as the picture of their relationship left me feeling concerned.

The issue of coercive control

I was struck by the positivity. It was profusive to the extent that you would be forgiven for thinking she was saying everything she thought he would want to hear. I also wondered if she would have been so positive if she had decided to leave the relationship, and wonder what kind of reaction she would receive from the travelling family under those circumstances? On paper, I was struck by the level of control over the woman, to the extent that she was talking in a way that was totally compliant. It was then I realised that I was reading an article which was a perfect case study in coercive control.

For coercive control doesn’t have to be over-bearing or demanding, the control can even come from extended family. It can be sweetly spoken, but with clarity about the expectations. You can get lots of material items as pay-off. The control can be a manipulation, not just from the man, but from cultural or community expectations. This actually is more likely because it is easier to not take responsibility if the reason for controlling behaviour comes from elsewhere. And anyone could be the perpetrator – coercive control transcends culture, age, and gender.

And if you’re not from a particular community, but are told you are expected to behave in particular ways, who are you to disagree as an outsider?

The role of fear

We control our partners in this way out of fear. We don’t want them to go out because we are afraid of other men’s behaviour towards them, or that there could be a risk of adultery. However, a true alpha male would not respond to others from a fearful place, they are confident enough in the presence of others, and are able to live with uncertainty. It’s okay to live with uncertainty, and the fact is, that if your partner was fully inclined to do that to you, then why try to control or prevent the inevitable? If someone is inclined to have an affair, they will do it regardless. I doubt your partner has any intention or inclination to do that.

My analysis

As I’ve said, I see this as a consummate example of coercive control. What left me even more concerned, was that this was published in an article, for anyone to read. The relationship was sold as an ideal, and one to aspire to. I am left disappointed in the publishers for permitting this kind of article to be published. Readers are very influenced by what they read, and this couple in particular was sold as beautiful, wealthy, and influential. Is it truly okay to influence our young people that this is the kind of relationship that is desirable? I would say, unequivocally, no.

For I have worked in social work for over twenty years, and as a psychotherapist for a similar length of time. I have picked up the pieces with families, children, and individuals when relationships such as this go catastrophically wrong. I just want to be clear that I am left deeply troubled by the woman’s situation, not because she is married to a traveller (I have traveller heritage myself), but because the risk to her is high should she ever choose to re-evaluate her position. And I don’t believe for one minute that the story sold here is a fully accurate one, without making speculative comments.

Victim shaming

I also notice that, where the article was posted in other forums, people were making comments about the woman. One particular ‘starlet’, referred to the woman as a ‘mug’. I notice this propensity in society, and it also leaves me troubled. Why do we put the responsibility always on the victim? Maybe there is another article there! However, as a man, I think the work always has to be done with the man/men. He is the perpetrator of this; the woman wants a relationship.

I realised that, the issue of control appears for many men and women in relationships. If you recognise elements of control in your behaviour, or wonder about your partner, here are some of the things I hope you would hear. And to be clear, I am not going to troll people – I think i’ve been clear elsewhere of the futility of shaming people – I want to offer some advice so we can offer ourselves and our families some different possibilities.

From me to you

  1. It is okay to step out of what your ancestors did, even though everyone around you may also act and behave like this to other people. Sticking to the ways of the ancestors keeps your life rigid. Life requires change, and it’s okay for you to do something different. It takes confidence, but it’s perfectly okay as long as others are not hurt. Just because your father did it, doesn’t mean you have to.
  2. Whilst you have been socialised to think that the way you relate to your partner is acceptable and desirable, there are other options that are also desirable. A true strong man would not be affected by other people’s gossip and innuendo about being different. Whilst some communities can be more insular, and society is definitely critical towards certain communities, this isn’t the case for everyone all the time.
  3. I would encourage you to think about what it would be like for you if someone was controlling and dictating all aspects of your life. What would it be like for you if you weren’t allowed to leave your home? What would it be like for you if you weren’t allowed to go out with your friends? Go anywhere without a chaperone? The way forward is to understand what it’s like from another person’s experience so then you can reflect on your own. I doubt that is possible for you, but if you could, this can only benefit your experience of life.
  4. In denying your partner the opportunity to live a full, rewarding life, you also deny your children the possibility of seeing their parents thrive and fulfil their dreams. Do you truly think your own parents were happy about their choices? I don’t think so, not in reality. But being happy, relating to others with kindness and compassion is the very best role model that we can give any of our children. Offer your wife the kind of life she would love, and let her offer that to the world.
  5. It’s okay to be a strong, powerful, alpha personality. In itself. It’s okay to know who you are and to go out and achieve things that you want to achieve. No one could deny that. The problem is when that behaviour impacts the lives of other people. This is not okay, and it’s not okay to impact someone’s life in such a controlling, deleterious way.

Final thoughts

Finally, the world is changing all the time. When we become fixed in our own communities and refuse to look outside of the front gate, we also inhibit our chance to develop and grow and flourish within the world. I think it’s really important you reflect on that as an individual. And that we all reflect on how insular or outward-looking we all are. I say this because humans are always attracted to congregate with sameness not difference. Is difference so life-threatening?

I hope you’re able to at least think about the ideas I brought to you today, and avoid being triggered. It would be good if you could think about ways you could do things differently, whatever your circumstances. Being powerful can also be about vulnerability. I hope you can do this before society catches up to behaviour that no longer has a role in society. Society has changed. I would hate for the long arm of the law to intervene in your life unnecessarily, or worse, that you do something you would regret for the rest of your life.

Much love,

Dr. Andrew x

Sign up below for Great Content

Receive new essays

New pieces arrive infrequently and without filler. No newsletters about newsletters. Just writing, when there is something worth saying.