The Restless Mind
Spirituality

How to Spot Cult-Like Groups: Warning Signs, Risks, and How to Choose Safe, Healthy Communities

29 Dec 2025·7 min read

Introduction

Groups can be powerful forces for growth, healing, creativity, and belonging. Many people find genuine connection and transformation through spiritual communities, therapeutic groups, creative collectives, and personal development programmes. In fact, our brains have developed over thousands of years as a response to contact with people.

However, not all groups are safe.

Some groups operate in ways that undermine autonomy, discourage critical thinking, and gradually exert unhealthy psychological control. These groups are often described as cult-like, even if they do not resemble extreme or widely publicised cults. And we’ve all seen them. But have you actually been part of one, and why is this important to understand?

This article outlines key warning signs to look out for, explains why these dynamics are psychologically risky, and offers practical guidance on how to assess whether a group is likely to be a healthy, ethical, and supportive experience.


What Is a Cult-Like Group?

A cult-like group is not defined by its subject matter. Spirituality, therapy, wellness, activism, religion, business, or creativity can all be healthy or harmful depending on how they are structured and led.

The defining feature of a cult-like group is control.

Specifically, control over:

  • Beliefs and meaning
  • Behaviour and boundaries
  • Identity and autonomy
  • Relationships with outsiders
  • Access to information and dissent

Most harmful groups do not start this way. They often begin as warm, inspiring, and seemingly supportive environments. I personally have had involvement with several cult-like groups, there are plenty out there, and this is the point – they need to be warm and inspiring in order to seduce followers.


Key Warning Signs to Look Out For

1. A Leader Who Is Beyond Question

Be cautious if:

  • The leader is treated as uniquely enlightened, gifted, or morally superior
  • Questioning the leader is subtly or explicitly discouraged
  • Criticism is reframed as resistance, fear, ego, or pathology

Healthy leaders welcome scrutiny. Unhealthy leaders require reverence. I remember once challenging the ‘leader’ of a group that shall remain nameless, and I was struck out forever. He didn’t like being questioned, especially about his illegal drug dealing, and was a complete megalomaniac. I continue to challenge that particular group until the larger organisation in which it sits, challenges it.


2. Pressure to Commit Quickly

Red flags include:

  • Urgency to sign up, invest, or “go all in”
  • Claims that hesitation means you are “not ready” or “avoiding growth”
  • Emotional pressure framed as a test of faith or courage

Ethical groups respect pacing and informed consent. If you doubt it, don’t do it. That simple. When being pressured, you will question the pressure, and this is the time to step back. If you’re not given breathing time, don’t do it.


3. Us-Versus-Them Thinking

Watch for language that:

  • Portrays the group as uniquely awake, evolved, or chosen
  • Dismisses outsiders as ignorant, unconscious, or unsafe
  • Encourages withdrawal from friends, family, or other perspectives

Healthy groups strengthen your capacity to engage with the wider world, not retreat from it. This is truly key – a development group is there to help you find yourself so you can live differently in the world. Unhealthy groups want you to lose confidence and withdraw, in order to feed the cult leader’s ego rather than nourish yourself.

If your group encourages you to detach yourself from your network, even if it sounds laudable, ask why they’re not helping you to manage the environment differently.


4. Suppression of Doubt or Disagreement

Danger signs include:

  • Shaming people for raising concerns
  • Pathologising dissent as trauma, fear, or lack of commitment
  • Encouraging silence rather than dialogue

Growth requires curiosity and disagreement. Control requires compliance.

I recall challenging the fact that some men were using their role as ‘helpers’ in order to try to have sex with the people they were allegedly there to ‘help’. There was outrage, naturally, from the ‘helpers’, and although there were attempts to address the issue, which was positive, the concerns were not seen as positive.


5. Blurred Emotional or Ethical Boundaries

Be cautious if:

  • Leaders overshare personal material to create emotional dependence
  • Members are encouraged to disclose deeply personal information without safeguards
  • Power dynamics are unclear or unacknowledged

In ethical groups, boundaries protect everyone, including the leader. But this is a tricky balance in my view. I know some leaders who just don’t have the skills to manage the complex dynamics within group processes, and aren’t creating cultures of over-sharing to create dependence. But some are.

In my view, the important strand to takeaway, is to consider why you’re sharing personal processes, with whom, and for why. If it helps you and it feels safe, do what you need to do.


6. Escalating Financial or Time Demands

Red flags include:

  • Repeated upselling framed as spiritual or personal necessity
  • Guilt for not spending more money or time
  • Lack of transparency about costs, refunds, or obligations

Ethical groups are clear, proportionate, and transparent about financial arrangements.

I remember moving into a very special Buddhist centre for some extended time, and it was heavenly. There was always encouragement to contribute to the running of the centre, as it required the support to exist. And the expectations were clear from the outset. The goal posts didn’t change. This was, in my view healthy, even though some people just couldn’t be bothered helping. What wasn’t helpful was another group where everyone knew the money was being spent on certain people’s substance misuse, but nobody dared say anything.


7. Claims of Guaranteed Transformation

Be wary of promises such as:

  • Total healing
  • Permanent enlightenment
  • Absolute answers to life’s problems

Authentic growth is complex, uneven, and never guaranteed.

Even for myself as a psychotherapist, I have to constantly check expectations and not sell myself as offering a ‘cure’ or ‘enlightenment’, neither of which truly exist. Certainly not in the way you would expect.


Why Cult-Like Dynamics Are Psychologically Risky

Cult-like environments can lead to:

  • Loss of personal agency and confidence
  • Dependency on authority figures
  • Erosion of critical thinking
  • Shame around normal doubt or disagreement
  • Difficulty trusting one’s own perceptions

Over time, individuals may feel disconnected from themselves, even while believing they are “growing.” This isn’t just a feeling though, but reality – they have become disconnected from self. The self regulation has gone – and you are spending your time trying to meet external demands, so of course you lose sight of yourself. This is also, in my view, one of the most damaging elements of being in a cult – the loss of self, and the long, slow, path to re-finding yourself in a very new way.


What Healthy Groups Do Differently

Healthy, ethical groups typically demonstrate:

  • Transparency about aims, methods, risks, and limitations
  • Clear boundaries between leadership and participants
  • Respect for autonomy, including the right to leave without penalty
  • Encouragement of critical thinking and dialogue
  • Integration, helping members function better in their everyday lives
  • Accountability, including external oversight where appropriate

Importantly, healthy groups do not claim exclusivity over truth, healing, or meaning. I have to say that this is like manna for me. The clarity, the openness, and the reflexivity is such a wonderful thing. Why on earth would anyone not want this approach to be central to their work?


Choosing Growth Without Giving Up Yourself

Groups can be profoundly beneficial when they are grounded in ethics, humility, and respect for individual autonomy. The goal of any healthy group is not loyalty, dependence, or identity fusion.

The goal is supporting people to think more clearly, feel more whole, and live more freely.

Trust groups that make you stronger, not smaller. More capable, not more compliant. More yourself, not less.


Final Thoughts

Curiosity, connection, and growth are not dangerous. What is dangerous is surrendering your critical thinking, agency, or identity in the name of belonging.

Healthy groups do not need to control you to help you.

If you are exploring therapeutic, spiritual, or developmental communities, take your time. Ask questions. Stay grounded. And remember: any group worth joining will respect your freedom to choose.

In my next article I explore the facts we know about cults…

Receive new essays

New pieces arrive infrequently and without filler. No newsletters about newsletters. Just writing, when there is something worth saying.